
(S01E10) "What does a heart attack feel like?" - Finn, in a panicky call to Kurt after facing Quinn's parents at dinner
The subject of this episode of Glee was ballads. It was learned that the club must perform a ballad at sectionals in a few weeks, and the writers managed to weave the soulful songs into every storyline. The first was "Endless Love," sung by Will and Rachel. It set the tone for one of the storylines -- her crush on the teacher. In fact, the episode was filled with odd-couple pairings, thanks to a hat-draw for ballad partners.
Sooner or later, it has to come out that Terri's pregnancy is a fake. It nearly came up tonight when she mentioned something about having a rash on her tummy and Will wanting to see it. I realize married couples can go months without ever seeing each other naked, but you just have to think it'll all come back to bite her in the butt. Maybe it will be his way out of the marriage. He says he doesn't want out, but she seems like such a shrew. And making Rachel clean the bathroom? That's just wrong.
Meanwhile, you've got the drama going on in Quinn's house. Was Finn right to burst into song -- "Havin' My Baby" -- during dinner with Quinn's parents? Who knows? But the whole thing brought to light a lot about Quinn's home life: her dad watches Glenn Beck, is a heartless loser, and her mom won't stand up for her. That's all the important stuff. Oh, and nice to see Charlotte Ross.
But thank goodness Finn's mom is kind and willing to take Quinn in. That says a lot about her, as well as Finn's home life. He got the hug from his mom that Quinn so desperately wanted -- and didn't get -- from her dad.
On the pairing of Finn and Kurt -- what an unlikely but lovely pair. Finn talks to Kurt about the baby and suggests he sing his feelings out with "I'll Stand By You," envisioning his daughter sitting in the audience. Then it cuts to Finn singing to the little video sonogram on his computer. Such a sweet little scene. It makes me wish the baby really was Finn's. But I think Puck will make a good dad, too. Stereotypes are getting smashed to bits with this show.
And poor Kurt. He's going to get his heart broken unless Finn turns out to be bisexual. But Kurt says it's all part of his master plan, because he knows Finn will end up getting his heart broken. Still, it was really nice to see these two guys bond.
Will's mash-up of "Don't Stand So Close To Me" and "Young Girl" -- nice, but mostly because of the expression Emma had on her face while he was singing.
Loved the last song, "Lean on Me."
"Just remember the power of the ballad." -- Kurt
Did you guys like this episode?















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
11-19-2009 @ 2:43AM
McKinley Bass said...
For a show that preaches at it's core tolerance, equality, love and acceptance, to not judge a person by what they are but to judge them by WHO they are, "Glee" showed tonight in a sad and predictable moment, that it applied that correct and proper axiom to everyone BUT Christians, Conservatives and Republicans. That, I hope, is the one thing I hope will change in which has been, to this point, an otherwise brillant and profoundly moving television series that I feel a personal connection to. Who knows? Maybe Quinn's parents will come to Jesus, say "We were wrong", quote a bible verse and take her back. Now THAT would be showing some guts on behalf of the writers.
You want equality, tolerance and acceptance? Physician
"Glee"....heal thyself. And you can bet that I will be right there watching next week. Because to forgive is devine.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 4:57PM
Jennifer said...
You are absolutely right. Watching the scenes with Quinn, Finn, and her parents was so tense I could have sworn there was a big boulder in my stomach. It made me angry to watch Quinn's father treat her the way he did, although him kicking her out of the house I saw coming. I even yelled out "You Jerk!" (Sorry). My fellow Gleeks, listen carefully. All he (Quinn's dad) is is a negative stereotype, not at all what Christians are really like. He is an example of how Christians are NOT supposed to act in such situations. As a Roman Catholic Christian, I find that type of behavior absolutely appalling. I am still a little angry as I type this. This is kinda personal for me. Twenty-six years ago, my parents got pregnant with me out of wedlock. They decided against killing me in the womb and married each other a month before my birth. It didn't take my dad's Roman Catholic parents long at all to accept my mother and me into the family. That, to me, is how real Christians should act. I am holding out hope that Quinn will reconcile with her folks. Dianna Agron did say in one interview that Quinn will sing Madonna's Papa Don't Preach in the upcoming Madonna episode, so I think that a reconciliation is in the works. I would like to see that since Christians also believe in forgiveness. Before you ask, I do not condone Quinn's getting pregnant out of wedlock. It's too bad she had to learn the hard way, but sometimes that's how some people must learn a lesson. If I had a daughter who got pregnant, I wouldn't be happy either, but not so angry as to abandon her in her time of need. Quinn is still young enough to need her mom for crying out loud. (Her mom was a bad example also.)I was happy when she decided not to have an abortion. I still think she and Puck should fess up to Finn who the real father is, but after what Mercedes told Puck, I don't see that happening. What do you all think?
11-19-2009 @ 6:54AM
Jen said...
If you go back to the Pilot, you'd see pictures of both Bush presidents on the walls at Finn's house.
Yet Finn's mother treated him with love and understanding when he told her the information.
I don't think it's a dislike of Christians, conservatives and Republicans - I think it's a dislike for hypocrites and close-minded people. Every race, religion and political party has their fair share of both.
11-19-2009 @ 7:01AM
Robert said...
That is total crap. The show is nothing but stereotypes. Finn, the dumb as post jock. Rachel, the annoying "better then you" girl. Kurt, the musical gay boy. Quinn, the prep who gets knocked up. Quinn's parents, rich, perfect people.
What the hell were you expecting? The conservative, Christian parents to be excited that their second daughter got knocked up? Even realistically I know parents who have thrown their kids out on their ass because of Pregnancy, its not really that far of a stretch.
11-21-2009 @ 8:23AM
mbs said...
Well said, McKinley, and I agree. I love Glee, but I really get tired of the constant Christian bashing on television. I know lots of Christians, and I don't know any who would act the way Quinn's parents did. Of course, there are people who claim to be Christians who don't act very tolerant, but almost every single time a Christian is portrayed in a fictional tv show, that character is always intolerant, frequently evil, and just never very nice. That's not reality.
11-19-2009 @ 2:50AM
kkingdon said...
I loved the final number. The baby drama, not so much. I feel frustrated when a little honest communication could clear up so many misunderstandings.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 3:08AM
Man said...
Glee's formula is make 2-dimensional character then weeks later show their 3rd dimension. We are sure to see more Charlotte Ross in the future.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 3:49AM
CB said...
I have really enjoyed Glee. I'm not the typical audience I'm sure, but it is a show that I DVR and look forward to each week.
I am also...Conservative, Christian, and a Business owner supporting over a dozen people in Southern California.
So what a blessing when I am tarred and feathered and represented as an intollerant biggot simply because I occassionally watch Glen Beck.
Thank you for making it clear that my viewership is no longer required or wanted. I will also make a note that my contributions to mulitple charities are no longer warranted by my company, nor am worthy of being considered anything other than your sterotypical gutter trash.
Teen pregnancy is a difficult subject. Certainly something that is difficult for everyone directly involved with the teen...but it is clear that the writers clearly feel that unless you are an aging hippie or a fatherless child, you cannot possibly have compassion or sympathy.
Yeah...for a show that always has something good to say, you have decided to take a cheap shot at perhaps the demographic that most appreciates this show.
Oh, and by the way, your NOW gang ball busting babes would much prefer to have Quinnie go through a late term abortion just to bring the point full circle...as opposed to actually giving birth to the baby and giving it up for adoption...since we know that every child should be wanted.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 5:29AM
hub said...
Wow. You might want to see a doctor about that chip on your shoulder. And that narcissism.
11-19-2009 @ 7:06AM
Robert said...
Yep, Pretty much. That was their exact goal. To alienate you, not to express that their are people out there that do this. Sure they were screwing with you a bit, just like Ryan Murphy does to all his characters, they all come out being an uncontrolled stereotype.
Kurt is a great example, he knows how to dress, he sides with the "ladies", he has a crush on a man he can't get but has a plan, he can sing, he can dance, he can do it all! I'm sure the goal was to alienate all the people who are gay but live normal lives, don't dress that great, and can't dance well.
11-19-2009 @ 12:21PM
scott said...
just wondering if by aging hippie you mean Finns mom, and why you came to that conclusion (her being an aging hippie)? because most aging hippies i know don't hang pictures of the Bushes on their wall.
One conservative family shunned her, the OTHER took her in.
get over yourself, man. i'm sorry that the 'bad guy' in this episode shares some of the same interests you do, but its a TV show and it's NOT about you.
11-19-2009 @ 6:50AM
Andrew said...
Families who have chastity balls or whatever tend to have a disproportionally large amount of sex before marriage and teen pregnancy compared to those without. The show is just making light (and fun) at a hypocrisy that exists in society.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 8:40AM
Emily said...
The scene with Quinn and her parents, while very good, struck me as out of tone with the rest of the show. A bit too serious, a bit too heavy. There was no music during that scene either. I don't know how I feel about the happiest show on television taking a turn in that direction. What do you guys think?
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 9:23AM
Christina said...
Emily,
This show has a definitely undertone of deep sadness. I suggest seeing Todd van der Werff's reviews of the show at the Onion's AV Club to give you an idea of what I mean--he's written very eloquently on this subject.
11-19-2009 @ 9:11AM
Dean said...
In all the comments about the parents reaction, no seems to note Mercedes response to Puck when he told him he was the baby's father. She said that Quinn chose her babys father and that Puck screwed up her life enough and he should back off. No mention of the fact that Quinn is lying consistently and burdening Finn with a responsibility that is not his. Where is the moral outrage? I think this speaks very poorly of the Mercedes character. (I understand of course this is just another plot device to move the story forward and yet delay the Finn finding out the truth.)
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 10:34AM
Gina said...
I agree that it's unfair of Quinn to be burdening Finn with a baby that's not his, but I can see how Mercedes, another teenage girl, would instinctively see it from Quinn's point of view. I think I would be more upset about this unfairness to Finn if I wasn't pretty confident that the truth will come out before the babies actually born. I am wondering what Quinn is going to do if/when Terry's fake pregnancy comes light. If she and Will break up, will Quinn keep the baby? Or just give it up to a different couple.
11-19-2009 @ 10:17PM
Eldritch said...
Quinn may be in a tough situation, but it's one of her own making. And because of the way she's handling it, I'm finding it hard to give her much sympathy.
She was a hypocritical practitioner of chastity. Remember "Tease, don't please?" She bargained bits of her chastity away simply to manipulate Finn. Remember "Under the shirt, but over the bra!" Then while bargaining with Finn, she cheated on him. She knowingly had sex with his best friend.
Since then she's lied to everyone she could until she was found out by them. She's lied to the Finn about his paternity. And continues lying to Finn, not because she loves him, but because he portends to be a better meal ticket than Puck. What kind of marriage will they have? Can she even love him? She seems on her way to become another Terri, Will's wife. Her selfishness will deny Finn any future with a woman who would genuinely love him.
She's indicated she's actually more attracted to Puck. But she's refusing to allow Puck a role in the life of his own child because he's not as good meal ticket, despite his honorable desire to step up.
Without doubt, she *is* her parents daughter. She learned from them well.
And let's not forget that she's now she's lying to Finn's much less prosperous mother and taking advantage of her charity for her own personal gain.
What exactly has she done to earn anyone's sympathy? She's evil incarnate, certainly the spawn of Satan.
11-19-2009 @ 10:26PM
Eldritch said...
Quinn may be in a tough situation, but it's one of her own making. And because of the way she's handling it, I'm finding it hard to give her much sympathy.
She was a hypocritical practitioner of chastity. Remember "Tease, don't please?" She bargained bits of her chastity away simply to manipulate Finn. Remember "Under the shirt, but over the bra!" Then while bargaining with Finn, she cheated on him. She knowingly had sex with his best friend.
Since then she's lied to everyone she could until she was found out by them. She's lied to the Finn about his paternity. And continues lying to Finn, not because she loves him, but because he portends to be a better meal ticket than Puck. What kind of marriage will they have? Can she even love him? She seems on her way to become another Terri, Will's wife. Her selfishness will deny Finn any future with a woman who would genuinely love him.
She's indicated she's actually more attracted to Puck. But she's refusing to allow Puck a role in the life of his own child because he's not as good meal ticket, despite his honorable desire to step up.
Without doubt, she *is* her parents daughter. She learned from them well.
And let's not forget that she's now she's lying to Finn's much less prosperous mother and taking advantage of her charity for her own personal gain.
What exactly has she done to earn anyone's sympathy? She's evil incarnate, certainly the spawn of Satan.
11-19-2009 @ 11:28AM
en said...
The fact is, the show went out of its way to identify the father as a Christian Conservative Republican, then went out of its way to tar him as a heartless bastard. The show (which I like, for the most part) has become increasingly politically correct and strangely partisan. I don't understand why, since it's so out of tune with the rest of the script.
The fact is that the script *did* deliberately go out and try to offend conservative Christians. That was the whole point of the scene. And for the record, though I'm neither a conservative or a Christian, I know many who are. And a few of them have had teenage children get pregnant. None of them would ever consider even for a moment to throw their child out of the house. It's a lie that liberals tell themselves to make themselves feel better. But it's not even remotely realistic.
There are certainly legitimate ways to poke fun at Christians and conservatives, but that scene struck even me as being over-the-top stupid.
Reply
11-19-2009 @ 2:29PM
Leroy said...
There most certainly are christian extremists who kick their pregnant daughters out of the house. To state otherwise as you do shows you have your head buried in the sand. However, that does not mean that ALL christians behave that way. These characters being in the show does not imply that all conservatives behave this way, just that this couple does. When you add in the fact that Finn's equally christian and conservative mother behaved entirely differently, your complaint becomes nothing but whining over the idea that any christian ever be portrayed in a negative light. Get over it. Not all christians are saints.