
(S04E03) "I met JJ Abrams once, and I don't know what this means, but he said that the island was just Hurley's dream." - Jenna
In a typical 30 Rock episode, not all of the plots always work. While the A plot will be great, B and C will be lame. If A and B are great, then C will be lame. If A and C are great, B will be lame. Sometimes A is great and B is fair, but C will be really unnecessary and forced. Sometimes there will just be an A and it's great, and there will be dashes of B and C. I don't know where I'm going with this because I was terrible at algebra.
Oh yeah: tonight A, B, and C all clicked, and that made for a very good 30 Rock.
So ... will people from "real America" be angered at this episode because it depicted them to be just as mean, dirty, and insulting as "non-real America?" Or will they just laugh that people are alike all over the country and there's only one America, like Liz was saying (in her tortured way)? I bet there will be some that will say Tina Fey and company, in their attempt to portray everyone in America as the same, still managed to "insult" real America (in this case, the South).
I like how the show has a plot that is running throughout this whole season. I guess you could say season one had that too, with the show getting used to Tracy being hired and Jenna fighting for the spotlight on the show and all that. But this season's plot, finding another cast member to be a regular on TGS, makes a lot of sense, and Jack and Liz going to Kenneth's hometown to find "real" comics made sense, too. Though I wonder why Kenneth didn't go with them to show them around.
Of course, this was a Halloween episode, too, so we got Frank, Lutz (very funny), and Toofer being friendly to Jenna just so they can go to her gay friends' Halloween party where there will be hot chicks. Is this a real thing? I remember a Will & Grace episode that said gays throw the best Halloween parties.
More thoughts:
- The show did some stunt casting a year or so ago that was rather ill-advised, but when you have them in small cameos like tonight's episode, it's OK. Betty White was great in her short scene, and Jimmy Fallon ... well, he was on the show, too. His acting was horrible, but it was a nice tie-in with NBC, and he and Tracy Morgan got to act together again (and there was a nice jab at the quality of his guests). So Tracy was going to kill both Betty White and Jimmy Fallon? Good to know. (I thought Brian Williams was going to be in this episode, but maybe he's on a later episode when the auditions start in NYC.)
- One of the many things this show does well is refer to pop culture. I know, I know, that's not exactly a profound statement, but having a subplot that revolves around the "rule of three" when it comes to celebrity deaths is a clever choice, especially since 30 Rock fans are the type of fans who know and follow that sort of thing. But if you think about it, three celebrities die every single week, it's just that they're usually not major.
- I think we've had enough "Liz farting" jokes to last us the rest of the series. I don't want to think of Fey that way.
- First the show gave us the funcooker, now we have the chuckle hut.
- Jenna mentioned being "pushed aside" at her sister's funeral. Is this the same sister who urinated in her eye?
- For the record, like Liz, I didn't get Jack's joke to her at the beginning either.
Quotes:
"I asked you to find an actor from middle America, a real person. You're not going to find him in the People's Gaypublic of Drugafornia." - Jack, about San Francisco
"The American public doesn't want your elitist, east coast, alternative, intellectual, left wing..." - Jack
"Jack, just say Jewish, this is taking forever." - Liz
"At least he died doing what he loved most: blogging on the Huffington Post." - Kenneth, about a celebrity dying
"Mr. Donaghy, I wasn't sure if you were going to participate in this year's pumpkin carving contest or like last year I should go jump up my own ass." - Kenneth
"When the Parcells first came to America, they lived in a town called Sexcriminalboat." - Kenneth
"The usual, I suppose. Two hobos sharing a bean. Lady airline pilots." - Kenneth, on what he finds funny
"The folks who are teaching our kids, running our prisons, growing our cigarettes." - Jack, on small town America
"Good God, Lemon, your breath. When did you find time to eat a diaper you found on the beach?" - Jack
"And no making fun of me for using outdated pop culture references. Are we cowabunga on this?" - Jenna
"I believe that all anyone really wants in this life is to sit in peace and eat a sandwich." - Liz
"How surprising that your world view is food-based." - Jack
"Keep refreshing. Maybe Andy Dick has died in the last 20 seconds." - Tracy, to Kenneth on the computer
"Oh, don't look at me like I'm a football game." - Jenna, to her gay friend
"That's three! Tell my wife I went to Philadelphia on business!" - Tracy
"Down here we call it Sexcriminalboat." - Travis, about Manhattan
[Watch clips and episodes of 30 Rock and other shows at SlashControl.]















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
10-30-2009 @ 1:36AM
Master Cylinder said...
Really, Bob? I honestly thought this was the worst 30 Rock ever. The Liz/Jack story line was dull (with way too much bathroom humor) and the Tracy story line was pointless.
Jimmy Fallon's cameo was the worst acting I've seen besides child actors.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 1:55AM
Andrew said...
Disagree, I thought this episode was much funnier than the previous two this season.
Jack's face when Liz ordered the sandwich w/ "chuckle" was hilarious, as was Betty White telling Tracy she would be at his funeral. I also liked:
Tracy- Are you a celebrity
Fallon- I have a show on NBC.
Tracy- No, I said a celebrity.
(Fallon is an atrocious actor though)
They were really hitting the "gays have great Halloween parties" thing on NBC tonight, there was a mention of it on Parks & Rec as well.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 2:32AM
JR said...
Don't think this episode will offend people from the "real America" as not many "real Americans" watch the show. Most are probably watching CSI instead.
That being said I agree with the review and think all three subplots worked and were funny this week for the most part. Especially enjoyed the rule of three reference.
It was definitely the best ep of the season so far. Sure, we're only 3 episodes in, but still. It does seem to be true though that 30 Rock always starts off a little shaky but keeps getting better as the season progresses so it's only up from here I'm hoping.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 2:54AM
BugKiller said...
As I have lived in Georgia almost all my life and grew up close enough to Stone Mountain to spit, I was mildly put out by this episode.
I mean, the truth is often funniest, right? So why did they make a suburb of Atlanta with a majority minority population look like some hick town in Alabama or Arkansas?
Sorry, Tina, but you're wrong and Jack was right.
We ARE better down here and life is generally more preferable in Georgia than New York.
That's why my New York parents MOVED to Georgia in the 80s along with half of New Jersey, New England, and 1/3 of the entire Long Island population.
What they SHOULD have shown was all the damn yankees who clog our interstate highways and drive like maniacs and who infest every Metro Atlanta County in and outside the perimeter.
Thank God for Athens.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 7:17AM
Jason said...
Heh, if they wanted southern Georgia redneck, they could have filmed in Winder. Stone Mountain is 10 minutes from one of the most expensive neighborhoods in Atlanta, and Emory... I mean, c'mon... Emory is gorgeous and $$$??!! They totally missed the mark on that one.
-J from Lawrenceville
10-30-2009 @ 7:54AM
Adam said...
You do realize that Donald Glover, a former 30 Rock writer and current star of "Community", is from Stone Mountain, and that Jack McBrayer, Kenneth the Page, is from Macon? I'm sure they were fully aware that Stone Mountain was nothing like they portrayed. But, when people not from Ga hear Stone Mountain I'm sure they conjure something on par with Pigeon Forge, so I don't blame them at all.
See this interview and all will become clear:
http://blogs.ajc.com/radio-tv-talk/2009/09/29/interview-with-former-atlantan-donald-glover-on-nbcs-new-community-with-joel-mchale-chevy-chase/
10-30-2009 @ 8:56AM
Jason said...
I disagree. Stone Mountain is internationally famous and recognized as a U.S. tourist attraction with over 4 million viewers each year. Granted, it does have a bunch of Confederates carved into its face, but the int'l community mostly comes for the laser show. It would have been better to pick a city with less international recognition.
10-30-2009 @ 9:47AM
Matthew G said...
I honestly can't tell if these comments are tongue in cheek or not...
I think the joke of picking Stone Mountain was that they were making fun of the average New Yorker's idea of the south rather than what the south is actually like.
10-30-2009 @ 1:57PM
Matt said...
geez, when did everyone in the world move to GA? How is it that the east coast is still so populated when from the comments, it should be a deserted wasteland?
You all are taking it a bit too seriously. It's not reality. It's a television show.
I really hope you apply the same sense of reality to shows like FlashForward, Lost, and Fringe.
Seriously...when have comedy shows not played upon stereotypes?
11-01-2009 @ 3:07PM
compuguy1088 said...
I've actually been to Stone Mountain.....minus the history of who funded the very nice carving, its is still a marvous work of art.
10-30-2009 @ 3:52AM
tunaman said...
I didn't get it either, BugKiller. Stone Mountain is so close to the city limits of Atlanta that it barely qualifies as a "suburb". Hell, you can be in Stone Mountain in ten minutes from Midtown if you hit the lights on Ponce just right.
Plus, as you said, Stone Mountain is (and has been) majority black for ages now. It's far more likely that Tracy Jordan would own a comedy club there instead of a bunch of "hayseeds".
Also, you neglected to mention that a good 1/5 of the population of Ohio moved to Atlanta in the 80s, too.
I too thought this episode was "meh", but then I always think that the farther away they get from the studio, the less funny the show is. This, and the "class reunion" episode, and the one that was mostly at Steve Martin's home were all quite lacking.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 8:21AM
Jimmy said...
Please cite examples of 30 Rock in which the B AND C plots are lame.
This reads like revisionist history to me.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 8:30AM
Jim said...
I don't mind *what* they're saying about the red state-blue state issue. It bothers me *that* they're focusing on it so squarely, for multiple episodes.
30 Rock's humor is best when it's drive-by. (Jack last year: "...the recession Nancy Pelosi caused." Zing, and on to something else before you have time to laugh.) There's no agility or obliqueness to this year's "culture war" plot thread. They're just taking it head-on, and doing it to death in the process.
I'll know they're in trouble when they send the cast on a side trip to Pahrump, Nevada... except oops, they kinda just did.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 8:42AM
Jimmy said...
Pahrump? Good one!
Take that, Sassone! ;)
10-30-2009 @ 8:31AM
Dan said...
Did anyone count how many cameos Jack McBrayer made as different people in the Stone Mountain scenes? I saw two, but wouldn't be surprised if he were there more.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 3:36PM
Johnzo said...
Yes, I noticed the same thing!!! How is that not in the review???
10-30-2009 @ 11:19AM
Tater said...
Stone Mtn is internationally known?? Hahahahaha!!! Silly redneck, no one outside of the 404 has heard of it. Get over yourself. And yes, that was one of the funniest shows I have ever seen. That Chucklehut comedian doing his best impression of dumb "Blue Collar Comedy Tour" stuff was dead perfect.
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 11:16AM
Gin said...
Umm...is no one gonna mention the obvious cameo of Jeff Dunhum as the ventriloquist?
Reply
10-30-2009 @ 1:53PM
Matt said...
and the commercial for his new NBC show following his first appearance?
synergy at it's best.
11-02-2009 @ 2:25AM
Dan Buckley said...
Yes his new NBC show... On Comedy Central. :)