
(S05E22) So, what's going on inside House's head? We left off last week with House getting a surprise visit from a very dead Amber and she's still around this week, running rampant and unchecked through his life, an eerie hallucination from House's subconscious. For a while it looks like House is onto something good, he has a direct link to the inner workings of his mind, which helps him solve cases and plan bachelor parties. But, that all comes crashing down when the Cut-Throat Bitch (as she was affectionately nicknamed) tries to kill Chase.
We start as we always do, with our patient of the week, a deaf high school wrestler, who, like House, lives in a singular world of his own that he doesn't want breached by a Cochlear implant. Opps. Then he shouldn't' have come to PPH. While the team is trying to figure out what's making him sick, House manipulates Chase into inserting one anyway.
That just felt so wrong to me. First off, House doesn't care about anyone's choices if he thinks his is better, so I'm not totally surprised that he did this, but...eek. It's just such a blatant disregard of what the kid wanted and it had nothing to do with solving the case. It's the last part which sends a shiver down my spine. Also, I'm sure that the deaf community probably has strong opinions on implants as well as whether being deaf is a disability or a lifestyle. These are all good points that get brought up but not thoroughly discussed in this episode. Does inserting the implant make the kid's life easier? Yes. Was House right to do it? No. Should Chase actually grow a pair and tell House to eff off? Also, yes.
So, while the team tries to figure out why this kid is hearing explosions in his head, House is busy being besieged by Amber. She's a nuisance at first, but House realizes that having such easy access to his subconscious is making him a better doctor. He decides to keep her around, playing off of her like he would the team. At first, she's helpful and insightful, allowing House to manage not only the case, but Chase's bachelor party as well. Seriously, House throws a pretty awesome rager. That party looked like a lot of fun, though it was highly embarrassing to see Wilson do a pantsless body shot off of a stripper named Karamel.
Anne Dudek, by the way, is awesomely creepy as House's subconscious. She plays off Hugh Laurie beautifully, but still retains that Amber attitude. Whatever happens with this story line, I'm glad they found a way to bring her back. The lighting in the episode is very well done too. Props to the lighting team for surrounding Amber in this odd, harsh bright light, that sort of looks like a halo, but isn't warm and soft, but something you want to shield your eyes from.
Sadly, Amber's helpful nature is only a disguise. Like House says, everyone lies, and apparently his mind is no different. Trusting the path she leads him down, House not only misdiagnoses the patient, but he almost gets Chase killed. Apparently, Karamel uses strawberry body butter, which throws Chase into anaphylactic shock. Thankfully, everyone survives, but House is visibly shaken.
And for what it's worth, Cuddy was totally ineffectual as not only House's boss, but anyone's boss. Her handling of the situation with the implant and outraged Mom was pathetic. How are we supposed to see her a strong character if they keep making her cave to House?
We had a similar set-up last season as well, with a two-part season finale that revolved around the inner workings of House's mind, and I feel like we're back there again. Yet, this time around, the consequences may affect House directly. We get a really interesting look at the way House's mind works through this conceit. Rather than just see the moment of insight when it flashes on House's face, we're shown the odd and non-linear way his mind works. Now, this is all fun and good, but it doesn't answer the question of why Amber has shown up in the first place and why she won't go away.
Is this a sign that House has a brain tumor, a la Izzy from Grey's Anatomy? Or is he just slowly losing his marbles? And did he really try to kill Chase because he hates other people being happy? I don't know about the last one, but I think not. The sad fact is that House doesn't trust his own head anymore, which can lead to real trouble.
Fringe' Show & Cast Photos
FRINGE Walter (John Noble), Peter (Joshua Jackson), Olivia (Anna Torv) and Broyles (Lance Reddick) enter a governement warehouse to examine a mysterious cylinder found among the debris of a construction site explosion in the episode "The Arrival." Airs Tuesday, September 30, 2008.
Fox
FRINGE Peter (Joshua Jackson), Olivia (Anna Torv), Walter (John Noble) and Broyles (Lance Reddick) return to the lab to gather more information on a mysterious cylinder found among the debris of a construction site explosion in the episode "The Arrival." Airs Tuesday, September 30, 2008.
Fox
FRINGE Olivia (Anna Torv) chases a suspect through the woods in the episode "The Arrival." Airs Tuesday, September 30, 2008.
Fox
FRINGE Walter (John Noble, L) and Peter (Joshua Jackson, R) examine a mysterious cylinder found among the debris of a construction site explosion in the episode "The Arrival." Airs Tuesday, September 30, 2008.
Fox
FRINGE Olivia (Anna Torv) chases a suspect through the woods in the episode "The Arrival". Airs Tuesday, September 30, 2008.
Fox
NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 13: Actress Jasika Nicole attends FOX's "Fringe" premiere during the 2008 New York Television Festival at New World Stage on September 13, 2008 in New York City. (Photo by Neilson Barnard/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Jasika Nicole
Getty Images
Executive Producers John Wirth, Josh Friedman and James Middleton arrive at The Paley Center and TV Guide
Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com
Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Molly Stanton arrive at The Paley Center and TV Guide
Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com
Jesse Tyler Ferguson arrives at The Paley Center and TV Guide
Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com
Mark Valley arrives at The Paley Center and TV Guide
Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-28-2009 @ 12:57PM
David said...
In, what, 5 seasons of House, M.D., this was one of my all-time favorite episodes. It was spectacular in its storytelling and it furthered the character development of the main character -- something I didn't think was possible this late into a series.
"The limp leading the deaf" made me laugh out loud.
Reply
4-28-2009 @ 1:30PM
Alicia R. said...
After having a MASSIVE case of insomnia this summer, the lighting was perfect. Things that you think are important do take on that harsh glow that we saw Amber in.
I really enjoyed this episode. The inner working of House's mind are always the episodes that I find the most fasitnating.
Reply
4-28-2009 @ 2:32PM
Blu-Sam said...
First thing I was excite as I await for deaf patient being involved in House MD. It was surprise as old same Greg give something terrible by give CI without permit, not even from take exam from audiologist to see if the patient being quality.
However, I notice there are few America Sign Language doesn't provide the all subtitle as I can read their communicate without subtitle show up.
I have to give the applause that Thirteen appear to know bit about deaf culture during discuss with Foreman.
Reply
4-28-2009 @ 2:52PM
Wii60 said...
Take note medical dramas that bring back dead people in hallucinations.
THIS. IS. HOW. IT. IS. DONE.
Best House ever, and I mean that. Even better than "Three Stories" and Kutner's suicide. This is the best written show on TV now, and maybe ever. At the beginning I didn't like Amber's return, because she was so out of character, then I grew to like her as she was House's subconscious, and in the end, was afraid of her. I cannot believe how well they nailed this one.
Reply
4-28-2009 @ 3:37PM
Wii60 said...
Also, I will give 20 brownie points to whoever can show me where I can get a robe like House's
Reply
4-28-2009 @ 3:57PM
bruce said...
I disagree with those who say this is any better than Dead Denny on Grey's Anatomy.
A doctor seeing a dead acquaintance in hallucinations and then being diagnosed with some condition simply is not clever nor original.
If they are going to make House sick, why not have it be something with his leg, or his other leg, or something that threatens to cause him more - or more severe -chronic pain? That's the logical thing to do based on his character. Just because something is logical doesn't mean it should be avoided.
I like seeing House and cutthroat bitch Amber interact (especially on the basis of being equals, rather than employer/employee), but she's dead, and that's that. Assuming this is headed in the direction of House being sick and having to diagnose himself, I don't feel like seeing that. All I can hope is that it won't drag on too long, like the Tritter thing.
Reply
4-28-2009 @ 8:43PM
judy said...
Well, I don't know about the deaf lists buzzing, but the cochlear implant message boards and listservs are seething about the multiple inaccuracies which I won't even go into since there are so many. What bothers me (and I have never seen House) is that millions watch it and now think they know everything there is to know about about these implants. How can the writers prepare a script that has no basis in fact? I know, it must be a fairy tale. Why didn't I think of that?
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 2:00AM
xnifex said...
i love anne dudek & i hope this hallucination stays for a bit.
Reply
4-29-2009 @ 1:45PM
Tim.Z said...
One laugh out loud line, courtesy of Wilson:
"...to avoid House's bachelor party.
Have you ever seen Caligula?"
and of course, House's 'chemical burn' victim.
This show is great because it combines well-written and relevant drama with amazing comedic moments alike.
Reply
4-30-2009 @ 12:40AM
ral said...
ARGH!!! I still have a 4:3 television and the scene when Wilson and Chase were talking in Wilson's office was painful. I couldn't even SEE Chase's head, and I could see about 1/3 of Wilson's.
Anyone else with a 4:3 screen having this problem???
Reply