TVSquad

I think you're way off. It was fun entertainment and Simon was genuinely surprised. I've seen his face on TV for longer than most of you yanks and I know when he's faking. This time he was not.

Reply

Anka and Sedaka have already done Idol performances.

Reply

Have you ever studied pop culture. Frankie Avalon was not just a bit part in Grease. He was a teenage heartthrob for many years and a star of many movies most notably the beach blanket bingo movies with Annette Funicello. You need to more research before you comment. read this http://www.nydailynews.com/entertainment/americanidol/2009/04/09/2009-04-_why_was_frankie_avalon_on_american_idol__why_not.html


I usually enjoy the intelligence and knowledge of tvsquad articles but I was appalled at this one. I should mention also that I am not some "old fogey" I am just a little over 30.
gridmonkey

Reply

Four words: Back to the Beach

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0092608/

Reply

I disagree. I think Simon was pleasantly surprised and genuinely happy to see him there. Actually, I noticed that right away and thought "Wow, it's so rare to see him like that". It was cute. His reaction was so different from his usual "I don't care" attitude that I don't understand where you saw him "gritting his teeth".

Reply

From someone of Simon's era, this was a big deal and congrats to Frankie for a) being able to still belt it out, and b) looking pretty damned good for his age. So, you are way off here,

Reply

Your age is showing. You have no idea what you're talking about. Frankie Avalon was HUGE. I was there. I remember.

He had 7 Top Ten songs in 59-61, as well as 13 Top 40 hits and 24 Top 100 hits in 58-61, a bunch of MONSTER beach movies with Annette Funicello (of the Mickey Mouse Club), and was a clean-cut cutie pie, just what all the girls wanted. And he was the only singer you mention who had a number one record in 1959 and a number one record in 1960. "Venus" was the number 3 song OF THE YEAR in 1959.

Contrary to what you said, "Lonely Boy" was not a bigger hit as the number 7 song of the year and "Put Your head on my shoulder" was the number 16 song of the year (and a #2 hit). Paul Anka was a talented songwriter but he started out as a short pudgy dumpy kid with oily hair and a big nose who almost always sang on key. Check on the R&R movie "Let's Rock," 1953 I think, to see him sing "Puppy Love." (That movie starred JULIUS LA ROSA, that's how very hip it was). Anka had hit records but he was no heart throb. He may have been a wonderful human being, I don't know, but I can tell you that none of the girls were swooning over him.

Same for Neil Sedaka. Another great songwriter who wasn't much of a pop star. "Breaking Up is hard to do" was his only number one of the 1960s (he didn't have a number one in the '50s) and that was in 1962. By the way, that was the original "Breaking Up," which was NOT a ballad. (His two other number ones were in 1975)

Dinah Washington was a jazz artist, not a pop star or a rock&roller. She sang with Lionel Hampton's band in the 1940s. "What a Diff'rence a Day Makes" was her first appearance on the charts (went to #8 in 8/59), folllowed by two more top ten hits in 1960. She's been dead for forty-six years, probably wouldn't have been available for AI rehearsals.

(Okay, you're already gagging than An Old Person is speaking, but I just remembered that "What a Diff'rence A Day Makes" was playing when I had my first kiss. Yeah, go ahead and laugh now, but I got to live through the 1960s and you didn't.)

Bobby Darin's "Mack the Knife" was the number one song of 1959 but he was not a pop star.. he was a pop singer who appeared in nightclubs like the Copacabana and wore tuxedos when he sang and sang standards and big band songs. "Mack the Knife" in fact is adapted from Dreigroschenoper, the German extravaganza on which "Cabaret" was based. He was older. He wasn't a teenager. "Mack" was his only number one record. His other pop hits were (the first) "Splish Splash" and "Dream Lover," but if you look at his catalog you will find real oldies, ie, songs from the 1930s and 40s.

The top ten Number One records of 1959 (in order of ranking from the most weeks at #1 to the fewest) were recorded by Darin, Johnny Horton, Avalon, Lloyd Price, The Browns, The Fleetwoods, Anka, The Platters, Guy Mitchell, Santo & Johnny. Darin, Avalon, Price, The Platters and, marginally, the Fleetwoods were the only ones you could really call stars of the time. The others were basically in the one-hit-wonder category or novelty songs.

And, FYI, Frankie Avalon is the only one of ANY of the people I've mentioned who had a number one hit in 1960, the year Simon claims he was actually born.

So, now, tell me again, who do you think they should have invited on AI?


By the way, You want to learn about rock&roll singers and great records? Go find "Tweedlee Dee" by Lavern Baker. (Okay, it's R&B, but go find it. Trust me.)

Reply

And I thought Simon looked totally surprised and genuinely delighted.

Reply

Sorry, typo. Let's Rock was '58.

Reply

A better question would be what was Flo-rida, or however you spell it, doing on American Idol?

Reply

My goodness, you must be very young. I was there, a twelve year old in 1959 who had "discovered" rock and roll and was in love with it. Frankie Avalon was one of our first "idols" and he was cute and very "swoonable". His movies with Annette made him more accessible to us. Simon struck me as very pleased to see Frankie and I was pleased to see one of the "original" idols still looking and singing so well. Allison, you don't know what you're talking about.

Reply

One more thing, you changed your original post, didn't you? You also removed the original comments that had been posted, too. Obviously didn't do you any good. People remember good talent.

Reply

I thought Frankie did a GREAT job and is definately an original idol. The whole judge panel looked pleased. I, by the way, am 28 years old and love Frankie. I developed a crush on him when I first saw Back to the Beach! I've seen all the old Frankie and Annette movies. You have got it wrong. He was a perfect fit for the show. Frankie, it was great hearing you sing. You have still got it!

Reply