
Southland, the gritty new police drama from film producer Ann Biderman, puts the spotlight on the dark and grimy corners of Los Angeles as seen through the eyes of uniformed cops and plainclothes detectives. Unfortunately, the series premiere is mired in cop show clichés and forgets to deliver anything we haven't seen before.
The first episode – stream it now or watch it below, a week before it debuts on NBC – owes a lot to NYPD Blue, Homicide: Life on the Street and countless other cop shows that came before it. It's a procedural with a large cast about cops struggling to balance "the job" with their personal lives.
Regina King gives a standout turn as a smart, understated detective. The rest of the cast is solid, but the show relies on too many clichés and rarely gives the actors anything interesting to do.
We follow a greener-than-green rookie beat cop, Ben Sherman (Ben McKenzie), on his first day working with hard-line vet John Cooper (Michael Cudlitz). Ben is an earnest rich kid trying to prove himself on the force, but John's hazing -- and a few nasty crime scenes – tests his commitment to the badge. Does this fresh-faced probie have the right stuff to serve and protect the people of L.A. and earn the respect of his grizzled partner?
Later we meet detectives Nate Moretta and Sammy Bryant (Kevin Alejandro and Shawn Hatosy) investigating the gang-related shooting of a teenage boy. Bryant has been neglecting his wife, but will a successful day on the job change his attitude at home?
King and Tom Everett Scott play detectives working a kidnapping case that ends with a "surprise twist" that will surprise no one who's ever seen a cop show before.
Aside from some hammy scenes meant to shock viewers and make the show feel edgy, the only thing that makes Southland stand apart is its practical production and visual style.
The show is shot almost documentary style, with handheld cameras and lighting that looks natural. It uses real-world locations, like crumbling street corners and out-of-date office buildings, instead of sets. There's little to no gloss here, which feels fresh after nine years of CSI-style flash influencing almost every procedural on the air. Still, it's not enough to keep me coming back.
It's hard to commit to a show that's stacked with fine actors and interesting production values but delivers stale stories and concepts in its first episode. NBC is giving Southland the 10 p.m. Thursday night timeslot starting next week. Judging by this first ep, I'm not expecting it to last nearly as long as ER, the show that held that slot for 15 years.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-03-2009 @ 2:13PM
Beanie said...
Hey, I remember seeing this before, only it was in Baltimore and it was called "The Wire". There shouldn't be any more cop shows made after "The Wire", because none of them can even come close to the perfection that it reached.
Reply
4-04-2009 @ 9:42AM
Mike Moody said...
I wouldn't even start to compare this to The Wire. This thing probably has more in common with Police Academy: The Animated series than The Wire.
4-03-2009 @ 2:54PM
Tony said...
The Wire was not only the best "cop" show on TV ever but it has to be ranked as a top 5 show of all time. I have not seen Southland yet so I won't judge but I can't imagine it's even fair to compare it to The Wire. The Wire was not only a show about cops but it was a show about life in today's inner city. It focused on the gangs and the people as much as it did The police. Not only that but it gave almost every character incredible depth and development. I can't imagine this show will even come close .
I'm personally hoping it's more like The Shield. Although the Shield had some procedural elements to it , it was about the characters . It also had an ongoing storyline from season to season that made it much more interesting than any normal cop procedural. I am hoping Southland is half of the show The Shield was and that it gains comparisons for more than just the similar type of camera work. Otherwise I may have to check out on this one.
Reply
4-03-2009 @ 3:20PM
Adam said...
This sounds like "The Shield"-lite. They filmed with handhelds and showed real, gritty parts of LA and it focused the same subject matter.
Reply
4-03-2009 @ 3:33PM
Brent Schmidt said...
It was alright... the way that the Det lady found the daughter/got knocked out was rather cheesy and seemed like they couldn't come up with anything better. Up until that point, it seemed like a good show... but yeah. I dunno if it's something I'll come back to everyweek...
Reply
4-04-2009 @ 12:28AM
ryan said...
"""
NBC is giving Southland the 10 p.m. Thursday night timeslot starting next week. Judging by this first ep, I'm not expecting it to last nearly as long as ER, the show that held that slot for 15 years.
"""
Given how they have already promised that slot to Leno, I think that's a pretty safe bet.
Reply