TVSquad

Didn't miss much. Basically, House's vision gets blurry and he says he's not going back to the shrink because it doesn't work.

Reply

I'll have to disagree with you about Mos Def in first-person... I thought the voiceovers were jarring and really sounded out of place for many of the scenes... I guess just because we're stuck in his head they'd make sense, but they didn't.

Then, in the scenes where he had his visions/dreams, he was effectively mumbling even though, in his head, he should have been able to talk just fine. In certain parts, he did, so I'm trying to figure out why it was inconsistent. I guess he should have kept his towel handy. (Readers: Don't get the reference? Look it up!)

I caught House's vision blurring at the end too, and then upon seeing the half-preview for next week (my DVR cut it off too), I'm going to assume that it's either a red herring for what's about to happen or the rumored event actually does involve House in some fashion. Maybe there's more to his accident then he led on?

Reply

The "fresh spin" seems a lot less fresh if you've seen The Diving Bell and the Butterfly, which tells the story of a man with shut-in syndrome and is shot largely from his perspective.

Oh, and the last scene was from House's perspective with a touch of the "locked-in" visual effect and Wilson telling him (something like) "You'll always be alone."

Reply

I think your review is pretty off. The previews for this ep looked good, but I thought it really disappointed. The first-person view didn't flow or mesh with the episode at all and everything else was just bland normal simple character progression. I mean, character progression is good, but as far as this episode is concerned, they might as well have just had everyone sit in a room for an hour, break the fourth wall, and say "I am not progressing as a character."

I thought the patient was boring too, no empathy for him at all. All in all, I really felt like this episode was recycled. I felt like I had deja vu the whole time I was watching it..."Didn't House already have a motorcycle accident? Didn't we already have a guy in a coma that was pretty much dead come back to life? Didn't Foreman and 13's completely chemistry-less relationship already have a "cute" story about jewelry? Didn't Taub already steal one of Kutner's diagnoses? Didn't we already have a rat-pee and/or rate-bite diagnosis?

Reply

i wasn't very happy with this episode at all, it was almost as if they cribbed an episode of ER (Alone in a Crowd S11E15)where the entire episode is from the eyes of a patient.

Reply

I liked it.

Reply

I thought it was one of the best episodes of the series. Mos Def was fantastic, and the writing/storytelling had me gripped.

Reply

I'm in the one-of-the-best-eps-ever camp. Nice to have a better-developed character as the patient - and Mos Def was, indeed, impressive. And nice to avoid a major "ewwwwww" shot.

Reply

Loved this episode. It was a nice switch to have it from the patient's perspective for a change. Best line: (from the patient to Forman) Can't you tell this to someone who can walk away?

Had me laughing so hard!!!

Reply

I think Mos Def did a pretty good job on the show, and I think he's a pretty good actor. I've seen him in a few other things. The HBO movie he did a few years back "Something The Lord Made" was really good. I reccomend it. I liked this episode myself. Yes the first person perspective at this point is cliche but it didn't hinder "House". I once again enjoyed the sub-plot of House questioning Wilson about his trips, but I'm so tired of Kutner. If he's so damn miserable working under House just quit. There are other hospitals he could work for. Losing that character wouldn't be a big loss. 'The wil he be fired will he quit' thing they keep doing every few episodes is worse then the 'will 13 die or will she live past this epiosde', episode.

Reply

I also thought it was a great episode. I wonder who is going to die in the next episode? Any ideas? Again, I'm also sick of Cuddy/House relationship storyline. I shudder whenever it is even mentioned. No chemistry whatsoever. I miss Cameron working for House and that chemistry.

Reply

I'll have to agree with the above poster, as The Diving Bell and the Butterfly is one of the greatest movies of the last decade I couldn't get past how inferior this episode felt in comparison.

Mos Def was alright though not show stealing good. To be fair though after watching him display his ignorance on Bill Maher recently i'm not sure I can ever take anything he says serious again.

Reply

I'm pretty sure that House's vision blurred to illustrate that he is "locked in" like the patient was. He tried therapy and wasn't going back. He's "locked in" as who he is, and not willing(yet) to change.

Reply

I have to agree; I liked this episode a lot! I wasn't sure at first either about the first person view thing, but I actually grew to like it; mainly because of Mos Def's voiceovers but also because I began to sympathize with the patient at how ungodly frustrating it must be in a situation like that.

House is always good, but this ranks among the better episodes in my book.

Reply

Of course I was thinking "The Diving Bell and The Butterfly" and that is an amazing movie and a true story, but the writers did well enough with this episode of House. I felt the same kind of horror of being trapped within. It is definitely metaphoric for House's personality in any case. Mo Def was effective. I'll also point out that it was important that Taub came off as a liar at least according to House who said that it showed he cared enough to lie. Thirteen's and Foreman's romantic entanglement I find the most distracting, banal and lame. Better to show them getting it on and moving on. The less said the better. . . Who thought Kutner would become a favorite?

Reply

I quite enjoyed the episode and I thought Mos Def did a fine job. (I thought the mumbling was a deliberate reference to the character's real life inability to speak at all.) My only complaint is that I want more than cryptic remarks at light speed about House's and Wilson's situations; WHAT nurse? WHAT shrink?

I don't think House's blurred vision was a red herring.. I think it is a hint of something that we'll find out about next week. Maybe on the way to a summer cliffhanger about House having temporary vision loss?? Just spitballing here.

So is next week when we find out about the shocking death of "a main character" or is it just a superdramatic episode? Does anybody have any clues about who is leaving the series?

And a final note for all you DVRers who didn't get the last few seconds of last night's House: I learned long ago that I can't trust Time Warner Cable not to start shows late and therefore stop recording before they're over. So I set each series I DVR to stop recording later than the stated show time; in whatever menu shows your series record details, just add two or three (or four)minutes, and each episode of that show will record that way. No more wondering what happened in the last minute or two of Grey's Anatomy or House. And now I always get to see to whom the tribe has spoken. It's unfortunate that the cable companies can't be trusted to abide by Greenwich Mean Time, but it is an easy fix.

Reply

I thought the reason for the blurred vision was obvious. Like the patient, House has his own "locked-in" syndrome. He is unwilling to change and is therefore just as paralzyed as the patient was.

Reply

thought this episode was fantastic
a lot of guest stars dont really "engage" house and i thought their exchanges were superb.
the first person POV was very very good and i thought overall Mos did a good job. but then again i am a fan of Mos Def so that does help.

Reply