(S04E05) Like so many TV shows before it (such as 24), Battlestar Galactica is built on those "what the frak" moments in which the revelations continue to astound us. Between those WTF moments, there has to be some sort of explanation as to why the moment happened and the events leading to those moments. They're not as much fun, and rabid fanboys have a tendency to nitpick the frak out of them, but they're necessary to the narrative. Tonight's episode was heavy on exposition and light on WTF.Obviously, we learned that Ellen Tigh resurrected (no surprise there) and she was apparently in charge of the project from 2000 years ago which created the human-style Cylon race. I didn't even catch all of the explanation. The following is what I did understand:
- The Cylons on Earth were some sort of scouting unit to see how the humans lived. They re-discovered resurrection at that point.
- John Cavil has become the main villain of the story. It is likely that he ordered the attack on the 12 colonies.
- Cavil wiped the memories of the final 5 a few decades ago and sent them to live among the colonies in hopes that they would see that his "pro-machine" beliefs were correct.
- The final 5 were boxed at one point.
- Despite only having one model each currently, the final 5 were capable of resurrection when the hub existed.
Please mention in the comments any important elements of the historical backstory that I may have missed.
We also know that Anders made it to Doc Cottle. The bullet lodged in his brain made a convenient excuse for him to rattle off the history of the final 5.
The mystery behind Starbuck's resurrection deepens. She obviously has a connection to the temple based on her knowledge of the supernova symbol and was resurrected at the end of last season. Perhaps she was Daniel after Cavil interfered with the birthing of that line of Cylons. Or perhaps Daniel is, in fact, that other doctor that operated on Anders. After all, he's a P.C.
It was slightly surprising that Adama still held on to his anti-Cylon tendencies after his fight against the recent coup (or perhaps not so surprising since he's been fighting all his life). His resistance to Cylon repair-people and using Cylon technology to save his ship doesn't quite jibe with me. Was this a comment on racism?
The synopsis in the opening was a good idea. It's tough to jump on at this stage but I think newbies would have been utterly confused by Anders' explanations without anything to help.
I once said that Tyrol acted the most human of the cast. I may have to give similar credit to Cavil, although in his case, I don't mean that in a good way.
I wonder how Ellen will react when she learns her husband is having a child with another woman (and a Cylon woman at that).
Given the adult nature of the show, I couldn't help but marvel at the sponsor of tonight's show: Viagra. No, really.
Starbuck's comment to the brain-dead Anders was funny. I would give good money to see a Battlestar Galactica Musical based on the 2003 re-imagining. It would be the best musical television episode since "Once More With Feeling."
The ending would have been better if Anders died rather than the vague ending shown. A Cylon death without resurrection would have caused major dissent in the Cylons and a rift with the human population. It would even have possibly forced a confrontation with a dying humanity and their dying flagship.
Of course, there are five episodes to go. Anything could happen.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
2-14-2009 @ 3:34AM
Heccy said...
I don't think the earth-cylons were a scouting party. From what I understood of Anders' ranting, it appears the Cylons were the 13th tribe of Kobol (built by the original 12 tribes) and eventually left to Earth. Why this happened wasn't explained but I'm guessing they rebelled and after losing the war were expelled/exiled (thus the "this happened before and will happen again" mantra).
On Earth, they eventually forgot about the resurrection technology seeing as they could reproduce biologically. Eventually a nuclear war was threatened (did the Cylons build rebellious machines of their own or regular old-school USA/USSR antagonism between factions) and 5 scientists re-invented that technology, used it after they died in the war and went to warn the other 12 tribes (now on separate planets) about building and/or mistreating AI. I'm guessing the 12 tribes had forgotten about it when they moved from Kobol. Another possibility is that the Lords of Kobol were a race separate from Human or Cylon and created both and later expelled them for warring (a Cain and Abel story writ large).
Anyways, the Five got to the 12 colonies too late but negotiated a truce by promising to help the toasters build skinjobs such as themselves. And then we get to some Paradise Lostish themes with the Five being God and Cavil as Lucifer.
While the dramatic means of exposition were a tad deus ex machina, the actual story being told was worth any clunkiness. The acting was pretty memorable, with props going to Kate Vernon and Dean Stockwell for their intense scenes that sometimes made you forget that you were being exposited to.
Reply
2-14-2009 @ 3:48AM
plinstrot said...
As I took it, the people on earth were originally human. The Final 5 had human counterparts who created the 5 in their own image so they could resurrect and live forever. This is how "John" was built in the image of Ellen's father. The original Ellen and the rest were human scientists who had their conciousness transfered like is said to be the plot of "Caprica."
Speaking of Ellen and Cavil, I totally forgot she had sex with him on New Caprica. Ewwww.
2-14-2009 @ 3:53AM
Heccy said...
If I remember correctly from "Sometimes a Great Notion" the remains found on Earth were Cylon and not human. I thought that and Deanna wanting to stay on her "ancestral home" were indications that the people who lived there when the bombs fell were Cylons.
2-14-2009 @ 1:28PM
James said...
Thank you. That was a great explanation.
2-15-2009 @ 2:04PM
Stigmata said...
good explanation, here are my 4 theories on 'daniel';
1. daniel is kara, whose sex changed when cavil messed with the amniotic fluid
2. daniel is baltar, thats why he can see chipsix and knows about the 1 true god
3. daniel is the father of kara and or baltar. thats why these 2 are 'special', and also hybrids. also its creepy since incest is involved.
4. daniel downloaded as pure conciousness that exists within cylon network, projecting himself to his possible son baltar and possible daughter kara. also it activated the music beacon to re-activate the final 5.
2-14-2009 @ 3:47AM
Mike said...
"but I think newbies would have been utterly confused by Anders' explanations without anything to help."
Not much more confused than you apparently are.
You claim there weren't WTF moments, yet you clearly have no concept of what happened... what was said regarding Kobol, Earth, the Earth colony, etc.
I'd suggest a new reviewer that had a greater understanding than my 9 year old 3rd grade nephew... but with only a few eps left, not much point.
Reply
2-14-2009 @ 9:30AM
mikelite said...
what a useless turd remark
2-14-2009 @ 4:23PM
Andrew Yoon said...
Mike is right. The reviewer has clearly missed one of the most pivotal points of the series. Considering his pai job is to, er, review things, he should be a bit more attentive than the average viewer.
2-14-2009 @ 4:49PM
Morden, J. D. said...
Yep, I concur with mark. if your job is to let your readers know about a show episode, then either know your show, or get someone who knows your show write your review.
This review was biased by ignorance of the preceding plot and a failure to link the current exposition in with that plot. The W.T.F. moments fall out of making the links which the reviewer did not.
2-14-2009 @ 4:00AM
JA said...
Daniel is Adama's father, see here:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0799862/
It's going to be played by Eric Soltz in the new series Caprica.
That's means that Bill Adama and his son are descendents of a cylon, hybrids, and this sets the stage for the new series.
Reply
2-14-2009 @ 6:14AM
Picviewer said...
Really? You gleemed that all from a common name to state the Adamas are hybrids? Missed the fact that the whole lines "factory" was contaiminated and essentially killed/boxed/erradicated?
2-14-2009 @ 6:26AM
Tom said...
Except that isn't Caprica supposed to predate the war with the Centurions? And didn't we just learn this week that the Centurions were shown how to create the 8 cylons in exchange for ending the first cylon war?
No, I think Daniel is...Starbuck. The amniotic fluid was contaminated and the genetic material was corrupted, turning a boy Daniel, into a girl Kara Thrace. Daniel was an artist (Kara's paintings on Caprica) and very sensitive to his environment (Kara's sensing things about the way to earth). And, let's face it, Kara Thrace is a Tomboy.
Of course, I think it makes some sense, borrowing from your theory, that Daniel is Daniel "Zac" Adama, named for his grandfather. We'll see.
I'm just kind of mad at they way they handled all the reveals this week. Revealing (though it was suspected and suggested for some time in the blogs) that there were 13 models, even though this whole time we've been told there are only 12. I always knew it was a #7 that was going to end up being special (and therefore Starbuck, IMHO). And why would Cavil and the Cylons call them the final five all that time, when they were really the original five?
Plus the use of the bullet in the brain that leads to all that expository information dumped on us by Anders. Its not as bad a plot device as that shark-jumping baby cylon blood that cured Roslin (albeit temporarily), which I detested, but that much exposition is disappointing. But, I guess, what are you gonna do if you want to get answers for everything at this point? I just think its pretty cheap. I did like the way they slipped in Special Relativity there, though.
BTW, did anyone else think Anders (Michael Trucco) was channeling his best Brad Pitt as Jeffrey Goines from "12 Monkeys?" I also thought the casting of John Hodgman as the neurosurgeon was a little distracting, and kind of broke down the fourth wall for me in this episode. You might as well have put John Stewart up there.
The religious overtones were THICK this week, maybe a little too thick. Free Will, Creators and children, one true god (who was a convenient explanation one too many times). Its a legitimate and major theme to the show, and I liked some of it. But a lot of it again was exposition, and much of it confusing. Would Cavil really side with Centurions over his more human creators as he suggests? Then again, I could identify with his wanting to be more and resentful of the limitations placed on him by his "creators." But Centurions originated the "one true God" concept? How about you, did you buy it?
All in all, I think I'm hitting about 80% on my predictions (I didn't think the final cylon was going to be Ellen Tigh, but then now we know she's not the final cylon to be revealed). I'm still waiting for the Beings of Light or the Ship of Lights to make an appearance (5 shows to go).
My next prediction: the biological resin that will be used to repair the ship will also play a role in some environmental cleanup of Earth in the end. Oh, and I thought it became clear about 2/3 of the way through this show that Boomer and Tyrol would find love again, the way their scenes were cut back-to-back (by the end of the show it appears to be an absolute certainty).
Now a show that I was calling brilliant a week ago has left me a little bit confused. Was the 13th tribe human or cylon? What happened on Kobol, why did they leave, and why is it a dead planet? Who made cylons (or ceturions, for that matter) first? Was it before or after leaving Kobol? Did colonies come up with it independently? Was earth populated by humans or cylons or both? From the beginning? How were they able to procreate? Why (and how) did they lose resurrection and then find it again? What fraking year of our history is all this supposed to have happened anyway?
I think this many questions this close to the end is walking dangerously along the edge of the cliff. Looking forward to more information next week.
2-14-2009 @ 9:20AM
DanteAmore said...
In the upcoming Caprica, Joe Adama is Bill Adama's father, played by Esai Morales.
Stoltz is playing another character named Daniel Graystone.
2-14-2009 @ 5:39PM
Dion said...
FYI: In "Caprica" set 52 years before the events of BSG, Daniel is not Adama's father. Joseph Adama (played by Esai Morales) is. Daniel Greystone (played by Eric Stolz) is a wealthy Caprican industrialist/inventor/scientist who will usher in the first era of Cylon technology on Caprica.
2-16-2009 @ 9:44AM
Ro said...
Actually, I think you're right. "Daniel" is going to end up being Daniel Greystone, who however is not Adama's father--that is Joseph Adama.
The reason why this makes sense to me is because the premise of Caprica involves Daniel Greystone's daughter dying, but him creating a Cylon copy of his daughter. How would a regular caprican figure this out on his own? Unless he was one of the Cylons with Ellen, Tigh, Anders and all.
Daniel knew the process for creating skin jobs, he used this process to save his daughter's memory, and Cavil caught wind of this "abomination" created by Daniel, then punished Daniel by screwing up all his copies so no resurrection for Daniel.
I also like the theory that when Daniel died, since there was no copies for him to download in to, he exists in the network and is behind the Head-Six, Head-Baltar, and Head-Rosiln (when she was getting counsel from that dead religious leader).
2-14-2009 @ 6:33AM
Tom said...
Odds on who the #7 Cylon Model is:
Starbuck 2-to-1
Baltar 3-to-1
Zac 10-to-1
Gaeta 20-to-1
Field 25-to-1
Reply
2-14-2009 @ 11:40AM
Clayton said...
Where did you get those odds? Make them up yourself or do you have a link where they came from?
2-14-2009 @ 3:02PM
Tom said...
Those odds are just my way to capsulize my thoughts on who the #7 turns out to be. The only way to get true parimutuel odds would be to have a place that would collect real money bets on who it is. Any volunteers? Just kidding....
2-14-2009 @ 8:26AM
Bald_Jason74 said...
"And why would Cavil and the Cylons call them the final five all that time, when they were really the original five?"
Because they are the Final Five surviving Cylons from Earth.
Reply
2-14-2009 @ 8:34AM
Bald_Jason74 said...
"Revealing (though it was suspected and suggested for some time in the blogs) that there were 13 models, even though this whole time we've been told there are only 12."
On the show, in the mini-series, Six told Baltar there were 12 models, but at that point it was the truth. The Sevens had been destroyed so there were only 12 models left. They never hid the fact that in that lineup we had models 1-6 & an 8. So in retrospect it all fits together. And when it became clear that The Final Five logically didn't have model numbers based on their history ("Sometimes a Great Notion"), the question of model #7 became more relevant. And as for the writers lying about there only being 12 models, it's common for television show runners to lie about upcoming storylines to protect the show from being ruined by spoilers.
Reply