TVSquad

The stars were out at NBC's big fall kick-off party, but no one was having as much fun as Jerry Springer and Piers Morgan.

The two opposing sides of some very emotional dice on America's Got Talent actually get along famously ... when they're not still bickering over whether a certain 4-year-old contestant should've gone home.

We talked to Jerry and Piers about what they're looking for on the show, whose name gets chanted the most and why Springer has become a total softie.Do you ever miss the "Jerry!" chanting when you're hosting Talent?
Jerry: [Laughs] Oh, no -- joking aside, the show is about the people that are on. And it's so neat because these people are not famous -- in our pop culture society, we're just used to seeing all these celebrities.

Piers: And also, to be honest, they prefer to chant "Piers! Piers!" It's a bit embarrassing for Jerry.

Jerry: [Laughs] But we never get a chance to see people before they're famous -- some of these people will be. So we're seeing this transition: regular person from a small town in middle America and, all of a sudden, wow.

What does it take to impress you?
Jerry: I just like their stories.

Piers: He's a sucker for 4-year-old girls.

Jerry: She was great.

Piers: He was so upset when Kaitlyn went home. He was more upset than she was!

Jerry: I was!

Piers: I think they did well with the voting. They totally just put the sympathy to one side and voted for talent ... that's what it should be now.

So what does the competition come down to now?
Piers: At this stage of the show? Talent. Who's the most talented, who's the most entertaining. They have to have both.

Jerry: But the truth is, if I told you this great singer was gonna come on and sing, you may listen and say, "That's pretty good." But if I told you that a 4-year-old girl was gonna come out here, you would really watch that, wouldn't you?

Piers: Jerry, it's over! He's just became a grandpa and he's being a softie about it ...

A grandfather -- congratulations!
Jerry: A little boy. Richard Nathaniel. "Richard! Richard!" [Laughs]

Will he be inheriting the Springer empire?
Jerry: [Laughs] Well I'm not sure he'd want it -- I want the kid to have a good life.

Piers: You know, I used to watch The Jerry Springer Show when I was a teenager ... Jerry was getting into his 70s. [Laughs] I used to think, Wouldn't it be funny one day to work with Jerry Springer. I thought it would be me coming on as one of his contestants. But here we are -- having a blast.

So is that your only guilty pleasure show? And Jerry, what does the king of guilty TV watch?
Jerry: Yeah, I'd like to take this opportunity to formally apologize. I think my show is the guiltiest. It's been 18 years -- we're starting to get the children of our original guests on, which is wrong because they were told not to procreate. But America's Got Talent ... that's a clean, all-American, rah-rah show.

Piers: It's Jerry's redemption really ...

Jerry: It's my only shot at heaven. [Laughs] I mainly watch sports and politics ...

Piers: Gossip Girl is quite a bit of a guilty pleasure ... I'm big into that.

You know that Madchen Amick, who's playing the sexy older woman who seduces Nate, is here tonight?
Piers: She is? Well then why the hell am I still talking to you? [Laughs]