Now that the confetti has been swept away, all the balloons popped, and the St. Paul cops are stowing their riot gear, it's time to recall the surprisingly eventful Republican National Convention in Minnesota. Is it really only one week ago today that Senator John McCain pulled a rabbit out of his hat and introduced little-known Alaska Governor Sarah Palin as his running mate? She's not little-known anymore. In fact, the 2008 Republican Convention is forever more to be remembered for her ascent, whatever her future portends.Here's some other thoughts from the TV coverage of the RNC:
Media matters
Having the two political conventions back to back was a plus for the TV pros. All the mistakes from Denver were rectified in St. Paul. The MSNBC set ups avoided train stations and noise interruptions. Splitting up Keith Olbermann and Chris Matthews worked better, with Olbermann as the point man throwing the coverage to the other news pros. And there was less bickering and fighting, at least compared to the week before.
Gustav
This had to be the first time ever an imminent weather disaster -- which thankfully never materialized into epic scale -- caused a major change in a political convention. These cons only come around every four years, remember. They're a very big deal for their parties and the Republicans had to be ticked off about Monday night being a wash out. The network anchors were all in New Orleans or nearby in case Gustav became Katrina, and the Republican con got off on the wrong foot. However, hidden in that coverage of Gustav was Sarah Palin's bombshell revelation about her daughter Bristol's pregnancy.
Oops
You think they'd learn after Jesse Jackson's Fox moment. But no. There was a great off-camera gotcha when Reagan speechwriter Peggy Noonan and Republican strategist Mike Murphy were caught on an MSNBC open mic. Check it out: All Palin all the time
For someone who was an unknown a week ago and was only seen on camera a short time over the four (really three) days of the convention, Palin got most of the TV coverage. NBC dispatched a reporter to Alaska, Savannah Guthrie, and her reports from Wasilla reinforced the Sarah-small-town success storyline. When Sarah Palin finally addressed the convention on Wednesday, the only way she could fail was to have a breakdown on stage. She didn't. Her pitch-perfect performance -- presenting a speech she did not write, so they weren't her own words -- proved that she's an adept politician. She looked good, sounded homey (that accent sounds like Edie McClurg), and energized that St. Paul crowd. The reviews were strong, the Nielsen numbers boffo. The shock to me was how condescending and snippy her speech was. She didn't write it, but she delivered cutting lines like a pro. I don't know if that helps her win over Hillary votes.
Pat Buchanan
I thought he'd pop a blood vessel over Sarah Palin. This is a man in love, politically speaking.
St. Paul
On TV, the arena looked considerably smaller than the one the Democrats used in Denver. Also, while the reconfigured stage for McCain's acceptance speech was different, it was window dressing. There was no matching Obama's stadium visuals. As TV spectacle, fireworks trump balloons. One more thought: that huge video screen was annoying. During McCain's speech, he was framed by green lawns (that looked like green screen) and blue skies. It was distracting.
Baby talk
The media has been all over the Palin baby stories -- and yes, there are more than one -- carefully treading the line between tabloid sensationalism and responsible journalism. Kudos to Obama for immediately coming out and telling the press that children are off limits, evening reminding them that his mother was on 18 when she gave birth to him. Still, the baby story was covered extensively, fueling the McCain campaign to call a war with the media. They're now saying that Palin will not be doing Meet the Press, Face the Nation, not even The View. Media blackout. The last time I recall this kind of hatred of the media was Nixon and the Watergate years.
On the other hand... Campbell Brown
Maybe it was Campbell Brown's interview with McCain rep Tucker Bounds that caused the McCain camp to turn on the press. Brown was persistent in her questioning of Bounds, asking for specifics about Sarah Palin. Bounds was not prepared to answer and things got testy. The next day, an email campaign denouncing Brown was all over the net. Ouch.
Drinking game
Okay, every time the Democrats say Scranton, take a drink. Every time a Republican says POW, take a drink. I realize the latter is a sensitive subject, but McCain has said he would never use this part of his biography in campaigning, but the story was told at least six times during the convention. I respect and admire John McCain's courage. It's time to stop talking about the Hanoi Hilton.
CNN twins
Is it just me or are Wolf Blitzer and Anderson Cooper starting to look alike? If AC grows a beard...
Leave that baby home
I did not like the way little Trig Palin was passed around like a loaf of bread. Why was a five-month old infant at the arena at all? He's never going to remember the night. The baby was used like a prop and I was offended. If Sarah Palin wants to prove she's a great mother, protect the baby and keep him home or in the care of a nurse or family. I have no problem with the rest of the Palins appearing, but the baby was being used.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
9-05-2008 @ 1:18PM
Michael said...
Great convention. Probably could have been rolled into just 2 days, versus 3, but I guess it could've been 4, so I'm not complaining too much.
Tucker Bounds is terrible, and should be fired. Come on, so many ways to respond to Brown, yet he keeps babbling the same indirect response.
Palin, FTW!
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 1:29PM
Cincinnati Mike said...
So Allison...are you saying she didn't write her speech? That's shocking, because just about every politician from Lt. Governor on up has a speechwriter. Even a certain Senator from Illinois who can't seem to function without a teleprompter.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 1:42PM
rick cokely said...
You are absolutely wrong. He writes his major speeches. Here is a link to the TIME article about him writing them: http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1837368,00.html.
But then again you don't care about truth, so why bother.
9-05-2008 @ 1:51PM
Cincinnati Mike said...
Obama says so, then Time prints it. I'm satisfied. Thanks Rick!
9-05-2008 @ 2:01PM
Thom said...
Actually, Cincinnati Mike, if you had read the article, it is Axelrod who is saying so, not Obama.
Then again, I'm not shocked at any of the piss poor comments you've made, either.
9-05-2008 @ 2:05PM
Cincinnati Mike said...
Axelrod? One of Obama's top, top guys? THAT's your unbiased source? Dang, I feel myself getting smarter by the second. Thanks, fellas!
9-05-2008 @ 2:11PM
Thom said...
Cincy Mike, don't get your panties in a bunch just because you have the reading comprehension of a 5th grader and have a worldview the size of a head on a pin. I am sure that long lineage of breeding first-cousins is to blame, unless you find willful ignorance a positive trait.
9-05-2008 @ 2:28PM
Cincinnati Mike said...
Cincy Mike: "Why should we trust David Axelrod to be unbiased?"
Thom: "You're an inbred moron!"
...I'll let the crowd decide who's ignorant.
9-05-2008 @ 3:39PM
B said...
McCain can't function, period.
9-05-2008 @ 5:05PM
Michael said...
B, we'll see how Obama does in the debates when he has to think on his toes.
9-05-2008 @ 1:35PM
No1Dad said...
Who wrote Joe Biden's speech? Inquiring minds want to know.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 1:38PM
rick cokely said...
WOW! That Peggy Noonan thing was great, first I read about it (and this is a TV SITE WTF?). Speaking of that Green Screen/Blue Skies thing, here is an interesting story about that: http://talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/213806.php
Turns out that was supposed to be Walter Reed Medical Center, instead it was Walter Reed Middle School. Guess the Republican's don't know the difference.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 1:39PM
Vince said...
Agreed.
I felt very uncomfortable watching John McCain's adopted daughter being used as a prop so often during the RNC too.
Any way to measure how many TVs were turned off during his acceptance speech? I didn't last despite wanting to see the whole thing.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 1:49PM
Unknown said...
Gee, Allison, I wonder who you're voting for? In the future you should at least be intellectually honest and disclose this in your opener.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 2:13PM
Captain Obvious said...
Alison,
Great job sneaking in teh bias. In your thoughts on the DNC, you never referenced the convention as a "con", but you managed to do it twice here. Nice work!
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 4:54PM
Andrew said...
This is a blog not a news site, she can display any bias she wants.
9-05-2008 @ 2:20PM
Michael said...
What's with all the emphasis on Palin not writing her speech? Most politicians don't write their own speeches, and especially a vp nominee since she only found out barely a week before. Joe Biden didn't write his speech, did you point that out also? Nope.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 2:21PM
Patrick said...
Allison -- snarkyness level achieved -- I think we all get where you and this posting come from. Just slightly left of Keith Oberman.
I just hope some day you hit that famous "glass ceiling" and you can thank yourself for this hit piece.
I'm really getting sick of TV Squad and your political coverage of said.
Stick to what you know -- celebrities and entertainment
Disgraceful!
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 2:28PM
chadwick said...
Allison:
Why do you bring up the fact that she had a speech writer. They all do! Period. Do you hate the Republican party so that you have to make every little dig possible in your post even if it's lie after lie? Let's face it. The media was caught off guard by McCain's pick and they are pissed. Mostly because they can't find any negative things about her so they attack her family. Telling you right now that this willcome back to bite them in the butt. The media will do just about anything to put Obama in the white house and even Obama said stop when they went after the Palin's daughter.
As for McCain's POW story, it happened. If your going to break down each candidate you have to bring this up. Along with his deep experience in congress he has a brave and respectful military background. He is strong on issues and has real solutions. His V.P candidate is perfect. Actually when you compared her to Obama he only has 132 days more in congress than her and he is a presidential candidate who still hasn't put anything into a law or amended. However when you put down "Present" on your vote ballot for a law how can you.
Continue your digs and your bias hate but remember many see right thru it and are not buying it.
Reply
9-05-2008 @ 2:28PM
Malren said...
I can't believe the new liberal meme - "SHE DOESN'T WRITE HER OWN SPEECHES!" No one has written 100% of their own speeches for years. You failed to get her on being a woman, you can't talk about experience as she has more than Obama, she's flipping you off when you try to attack her kids...is this the best you got?
Bring it. Keep flaunting all the pettiness that lives in you. Keep attacking her. Tell her she's a bad mother, accuse her of affairs, accuse her daughter of being a whore. Tell her she can't work and raise a family at the same time. Do it. Do all of it. Say every errant thing that comes into your head and try your hardest to destroy her.
You're looking at the first female president of these United States. She's conservative enough to appeal to people with faith and libertarian enough to appeal to people who like small government. Plus she can physically kick all your asses. The fact that I have to hold my nose and vote for McCain is made entirely palatable by Sarah Palin's presence on the ticket, and there are tens of millions of people that feel like I do. Good luck insulting us all over the next few months.
Reply