(S01E07) This was quite possibly the best In Plain Sight so far. This is the one I'd submit for Emmy consideration next year. Seriously. From start to finish, this one had it all -- a good story, interesting characters, not too much voice over, a relatable situation and ultimately, a satisfying resolution that was realistic but tough. It also had what has been sorely lacking in the previous six episodes -- balance. Marshall got as much to do as Mary, for a change, and was equally involved on an emotional level. Too often, Frederick Weller's character has been reduced to Mary's sidekick and support system. Not this week.
The credit for this show likely goes to veteran director Sam Weisman. Bring this man back! He gets In Plain Sight and has a feel for the wry humor off-setting the real drama.
The situation was a tough one. You know how in the opening, Mary says the Witness Protection Program places people: some criminal, some not. The McBride family fall into the "not" category. They have everything to lose when their daughter's in the wrong place at the wrong time. With very little time, they're uprooted, kicking and screaming all the way.
Subplot of Raph and Brandi is going to some strange places. Apparently, Brandi is as nasty, selfish and bitchy as we thought. For her to see through the door that Mary and Raph were getting it on, and still knock on the door, was out of line. Geez, Mary's her sister! That's wrong. And you know that her attempt to dump the suitcase of cocaine -- notice it didn't go in the river -- is going to blow (ha, ha) in her face.
Warren was a complete asshole. His anger and disappointment in Iris was understandable, but that monumental selfishness was stunning. My favorite scene was when the adoring wife tells him straight out that as much as she adores him, and she clearly does, he better not ask her to choose between her children and him. That reminded me of Sophie's Choice, not the situation, just the idea of a mother loving her children equally.
Why has it taken till now for Mary to present the Memorandum of Understanding for the Witness Protection Program to clients? This was such an important scene, it makes me wonder why they haven't played this out before. Maybe it was the way Weisman directed it; there was much more relevance to it this time.
Warren finally comes around, especially when he learns that Lily was as responsible for the situation the family's in as Iris. Can he really blame both his daughters to the point of losing them? Marshall's words about reconciling sink in and Warren forgives and becomes contrite.
Other points of interest
-- "Not supposed to situations" like Lawrence says is prefiguration, all right.
-- Background symbols abound. When Warren walks out of the office and Marshall confronts him at the elevator, the sign in the background is "High Voltage." That completely describes Warren's emotional state. "Now I have this rage inside me," he bellows, and you can see and read it.
-- Another symbol, the high school is called Rio Bravo. Also, the calendar story is told instead of the Alamo story. That's two homages to John Wayne movies, which is who Mary is most like. Can The Searchers be far behind?
-- After the shooting, it was great the way the innocent bystander with the lawnmower was shown to have been mowed down by the machine gun. You didn't see the body, just the lawnmower going down the driveway by itself.
-- The opening gag with Mary, Marshall and the stewardess story was great banter, and for a change McCormack paced herself. She has a tendency to talk too fast and rush the joke.
-- Marshall's so smart and observant. Bach on the piano, the measurements on the door. Mary's sensitive in her own way, hard though it is for her to show it. Marshall's heart is in the job, too. He also pegs Warren as all bluster and no balls.
-- Mary's calendar on the refrigerator, her setting a goal for them to survive six months, was gone after one scene. Continuity error or did the McBrides dump it.
-- Like I said, there was just enough voiceover, like Mary overhearing Lawrence's romantic words to Iris and saying, "Only a 17-year-old can pull off that kind of crap." She's right and because she is, it's funny.
-- Over the wrap, Mary says a few words that really speak to the episode -- and in this instance -- really were appropriate. "People generally think of forgiveness as the flipside of contrition, the obligatory response to an apology. It is not. To forgive is to answer the call of our better angels, and bear our wounds is the cost of doing business. It is that rarest of things, simple and pure. Transcendent, without strings."
-- The final touch, Marshall brings the door to the family, was a perfect coda.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
7-14-2008 @ 1:22PM
tspack said...
I loved this episode. Each episode is better than the previous one, which means the show is definitely going in the right direction. This has quickly become one of my favorite shows, and I hope it lasts a long time.
Reply
7-14-2008 @ 1:46PM
0megapart!cle said...
Yea, this was definitely a fantastic episode. The voiceovers really worked, and everything just flowed really well. I like that they don't shy away from unsympathetic good guys, as well, as the guy was such a jerk, but you could understand where he was coming from.
Reply
7-14-2008 @ 3:26PM
Chris said...
It's become a tradition for you to start each review with "this is the best episode yet..." Mostly, I agree. This one, however, I didn't buy the storyline. Perhaps I'm naive, but I don't buy that low life gangs as the one in this story has the proper resources to track down a family based on a brief glance of the girlfriend. The mob, yes. A gang, no. Should the family have moved? Sure. They could have restarted their life anywhere but LA and been fine. But I didn't feel like witness protection would have been necessary.
Other than that distraction, this was a great episode, with great acting and believable emotions.
Reply
7-14-2008 @ 3:54PM
buzmeg said...
"-- Marshall's so smart and observant. Bach on the piano, the measurements on the door. Mary's sensitive in her own way, hard though it is for her to show it. Marshall's heart is in the job, too. He also pegs Warren as all bluster and no balls."
The Marshall character is evolving nicely. His expanded roles have been and will be a big plus toward the success of the show. So far, for me, the only downside has been Mary's mother. She's got to go as she adds a BIG NOTHING!
I'm guessing sister Brandi will be the focal point in an upcoming episode when someone finds the coke suitcase.
Reply
7-15-2008 @ 9:21AM
Anita said...
Each week you say this is the best week ever, but this week I agree with you. This was actually the most cohesive episode. I like the minor flicker Marshal gave Mary at her anger towards the steward for assuming they weren't together. Also, Brandi actually fit into the episode, Raph's relationship with Mary seemed more tangible and the balance between Mary as lead and Marshal as sidekick was definitely better.
As a minority, I can see how the doctor feels working incredibly hard to gain all he has for his family, only to have it taken away. However, if my husband told me he wanted to abandon my daughter to resume his medical practice, I wouldn't have explained things as patiently as his wife had :)
But on the girl bit, I do see a Brandi-Raph relationship in the future. They can both give each other what they want (stability/support), but I wonder if Brandi is going after Raph (rather than finding another, because she wants what her sister has -
Reply
7-15-2008 @ 9:36AM
Anita said...
P.S. While allegedly Mary's an emotional hothead, I like that she knew her sister was interested in Raph and could see Raph's interest towards the end. However, instead of pointing it out (as he was oblivious), she took a breather -
7-15-2008 @ 12:11PM
fred said...
Yeah, I agree that this was the best episode so far. Great story, conflicted characters, Marshall a "real" character, and still humor all along.
And the bits with Brandi worked, and were funny too. They should really get ride of Mary's boss & mother, those two are simply useless.
One thing though:
"For her to see through the door that Mary and Raph were getting it on, and still knock on the door, was out of line. Geez, Mary's her sister! That's wrong."
I don't think she did see and could see anything, I think we were given that impression because of the way it was directed, from her looking in to Mary & Ralph, etc But they were downstairs, and we you look at the entire place I think she couldn't see nothing, she was probably more checking out her own reflection than anything.
Well, that's how I feel about it at least...
http://tvoholic.com/episode-reviews/in-plain-sight-iris-doesnt-live-here-anymore/
Reply
7-19-2008 @ 7:15AM
MERVE-THE-PERVE said...
I would have dumped the suitcase on a table and just buried my face in it. And we definitely need more of her sister walking around in her underwear.
Reply