(S02E09) "These bloody days have broken my heart. My lust, my youth do them depart. And blind desire of ambitious souls who haste to climb, seeks to revert. And about the throne, the thunder rolls." --Sir Thomas Wyatt (voiceover) This was a dark episode. As much as I disliked Anne during her ascension to the throne and sided with the steadfast and pious Queen Catherine, I hated seeing Anne's demise come to a head this episode. Somewhere along the way, Anne became the victim on this show. The Tudors, in my opinion, has done a good job of creating a multi-faceted character on the part of Anne Boleyn. Once a villain, she ended up a sacrifice to male-dominated political power play.
The angles of the religious men were great in this episode. I didn't expect either of their reactions: Brereton's agreeing with the charge and Cranmer's shock at the arrest of Anne. Directly after Brereton admitted to sleeping with queen (which we know, according to the show, is not true at all), I got it. Of course, he would want to martyr himself to kill a woman whom he believed to be a witch. But, I really didn't see it coming so I was pleasantly surprised. And Brereton got out of being tortured!
Then there's "Emo-Cranmer," less "emo" tonight than usual. I almost forgot about him. The archbishop was smart enough to catch himself in defending the queen to Cromwell. But, just moments later, we got a glimpse of the purity of his heart in wanting these reformations. I loved his expression when Cromwell charged him with finding a reason why Anne and Henry's marriage is null and void.
I haven't discussed Henry in awhile. Real historical happenings aside, Henry is a truly fascinating character. In one moment, I hate his immaturity and selfishness. And in the next, I feel bad for him because he is constantly pulled in different directions with really no one (save perhaps Charles Brandon) to trust or look to for counsel. For example, tonight I was appalled at how he fawned on Jane Seymour. He just wants to snap his fingers and marry someone else. And now, several people will have to die for it. However, later on, when he cried to the Duke of Suffolk--a scene I found immensely touching. It was clear that he loved Anne and felt betrayed by her.
It looks like next week we'll see Anne's beheading. But, of course, that can't take a whole hour (maybe on Showtime it can). So here's a wish list from me for the second season finale. First, I want to know what happens to Thomas Boleyn after his children are dead. Second, I want to see what happens to both Princess Elizabeth and Princess Mary (since presumably Elizabeth has lost all rights to the throne). I'm sure we'll get more of Jane Seymour, so I'm not even including her and her family on my list. However, my last wish list item is this: I want to know what becomes of King Francis and the Bull of Excommunication. That wasn't even touched on tonight.
What did you think of this episode? Are you ready for the finale of The Tudors?
Some other comments and questions:
- That was some torture that Mark Smeaton had to go through. Remember when I was thankful that they didn't show Bishop Fisher's or Thomas More's beheading? Yeah, I take it back after I had to watch Mark Smeaton get his eye popped out (or in, as it were). I have no stomach for that stuff.
- Best line of the night: "I'm the only one who's guilty." Sir Thomas Wyatt to Thomas Cromwell
- A close second for best line of the night: "In this slippery world, you represent for me all that is innocent, everything that is good, unsullied, uncorrupted." King Henry VIII to Jane Seymour
- Nick Dunning was brilliant tonight. He only had two scenes really (not counting the one with the Spanish Ambassador because it was just more of the same Thomas Boleyn) but he was compelling in both of them. What a dad too, right?
- I was surprised that they didn't show Anne's trial at all. I thought that was a bad move. I would have liked to see her speak to all the lords. I wanted to see them condemn her.
- Why was Thomas Boleyn imprisoned? Madge Shelton said that Lord Rochford had been in Anne's rooms during her confession but I never heard anything about his being arrested, charged or questioned.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-26-2008 @ 9:12AM
bcarter3 said...
"...seeing Anne's demise come to a head..."
This MUST have been intentional.
Reply
5-26-2008 @ 7:00PM
Kristin Sample said...
I wish I could say it was. I laughed when I got this comment in my inbox. It works okay though. I think I'll keep it. :)
5-26-2008 @ 9:49AM
mj said...
Anne was a victim from the start. She was in love, and wanted to marry, but Henry saw her and wanted her, so poof, no marriage. At her trial, Percy had to be one of the judges to condemn her. He suffered greatly over it. People were afraid of Henry, because he was so manic. I've always thought he was bipolar, because of his rapid mood swings. (explains a lot.) I also think he was a diabetic, which could explain a lot, too. I realize that they have fictionalized a lot of this, and it is really a shame, because the whole Tudor period is so full of drama, it doesn't NEED anything added.
Reply
5-26-2008 @ 7:00PM
Kristin Sample said...
I don't think that they touched on Henry Percy (Northumberland, right?) in season one of The Tudors. They made a big deal about Sir Thomas Wyatt. I'm a little surprised about that choice.
5-26-2008 @ 1:08PM
Matthew said...
Excellent episode. The build up is great. Is there going to be a Season 3?
Reply
5-26-2008 @ 7:00PM
Kristin Sample said...
Showtime ordered a season three awhile ago. They said they plan to follow Henry's wife through all his wives.
5-26-2008 @ 1:26PM
Jill said...
The scene with Mark Smeaton was lifted right out of
Anne of the Thousand Days which ran on Encore this weekend.
I've had some problems with the way the whole thing was done, actually...particularly Brereton and Norris. I know they've tried to make it look like Norris fell for Anne after deciding to court Madge Shelton, but if that was his aim from the beginning, it could have been done better. Norris and Anne were apparently closer friends than this would indicate. And the Brereton angle -- well, I guess they had no choice if they were going to turn him into an assassin.
What I do like about this series is how they're painting Jane Seymour as more than just a sweet, obedient little breeder cow. In her own way, she's as conniving as Anne. I realize that she's yet another pawn of ambitious male family members, but what on earth made her think she'd be different? Dying after birthing a son was her best career move.
Reply
5-26-2008 @ 7:15PM
Kristin Sample said...
I liked the Brereton angle myself. As for Norris, I think it could have been made more explicit that he was in love with Anne instead of Madge. I think they were trying to paint Anne as the victim (except for her questioning the king's virility). They just had a few scenes where she was innocent but her actions could've been misconstrued (i.e. with George, and when she hugs Mark after she finds out that the king is hurt).
As for Jane Seymour, I don't quite see her as manipulative. But, I think they are doing a good job of painting her as different from Anne yet not completely pure and innocent. You could tell she's very into the idea of being in love with a king.
Reply
5-28-2008 @ 12:56PM
Mimi said...
In reference to your last question - that bit had me mystified as well. I was trying to figure out why they had Thomas Boleyn in the Tower. If one wanted to be historically accurate, Thomas was never arrested and was actually part of the commission to investigate Anne.
Interestingly enough, of the men who were arrested, Mark Smeaton, Sir Henry Norris, Sir Francis Weston, William Brereton and Lord Rochford, only Rochford was beheaded because of his status of nobility. The rest were either disembowled or hanged. Thomas Boleyn had his titles taken away and died in a state of disgrace at Hever Castle.
In a truly ironic sense, Rochford's wife Jane was later beheaded during the downfall of Katherine Howard.
Reply
7-14-2008 @ 5:11PM
loz said...
no, they were all beheaded - they had their sentences commuted fortunately.
Am really enjoying the show even though it does depart from the actual events quite a bit.