Michael Emerson owns season four of Lost. Many of the season's best scenes have featured Ben Linus. From screwing with Locke to obsessing over Juliet, Ben has become one of the show's standout characters. Emerson took the complex role to an entirely new level in last week's episode, "The Shape of Things to Come." I'll be shocked (and furious) if he doesn't get an Emmy nomination this year.
Let's take a look at some of Ben's most unforgettable moments using the mastermind's own words. If we're lucky, Ben will give us a few more to add to the list by the season's end. Spoiler alert: If you're not caught up with Lost, stop reading now.
"I never entered the numbers. I never pressed the button." ("Dave") - Ben's manipulation of Locke began almost as soon as he became the 815ers' prisoner. He exploited the conflict between Jack and Locke, and tried to undermine Locke's faith. John questioned the purpose of the Swan station after Ben claimed that he didn't touch the button in the computer room. This ultimately led to one of the biggest moments of the season two finale, the hatch implosion. The electromagnetic event also got the attention of Penny's men at the Antarctic listening station, another significant revelation.
"We're the good guys, Michael." ("Live Together, Die Alone") - The Others kidnapped Walt and arranged for Michael to liberate Ben from the Swan station, which led to the deaths of Ana Lucia and Libby. They also abducted Hurley, Sawyer, Jack, and Kate. This scene marked the first time we saw Ben as the Others' leader, and the things he said revealed a lot about his mindset. Ben has an unwavering trust in his own wisdom and believes that all of his actions are for the greater good. He can justify anything: murder, abduction, even brainwashing.
"Hippity-hop. Hippity-hop. Hippity-hop." ("Every Man For Himself") - Poor bunny number eight. Ben gave us one of the show's most disturbing moments when he deliberately frightened a rabbit and made its heart explode. The scene, in which Ben rattled the rabbit's cage and shouted at it, seemed to go on forever. It was one of the few times that I've wanted to look away while watching Lost. Fortunately, it was all a con to prevent Sawyer from escaping from the Hydra station. Ben produced the rabbit, alive and well, before telling Sawyer that he was on a completely different island from his fellow castaways. Don't mess with a man who terrorizes innocent bunnies.
"Picture a box." ("The Man From Tallahassee") - In season three, Ben introduced the notion of the "magic box," a metaphor for the island's ability to bring you what you want. He used this capability to bring to the island the one person Locke most feared: Anthony Cooper, his father. Ben used Cooper's presence as a test. If John killed his father, he could remain with the Others and learn more about the island. Locke wasn't able to kill Cooper, but found someone who could. Fans had been waiting for a confrontation between island Sawyer and the original Sawyer, and they finally got it. Locke took credit for the murder, forcing Ben to reveal another major secret.
"That was Jacob." ("The Man Behind the Curtain") - We still don't know who or what Jacob is. Ben led Locke to an eerie cabin in the jungle to introduce John to the Others' mysterious leader. Locke didn't see Jacob, but he heard him whisper the words "Help me." Jealous of John's ability to hear Jacob, Ben lured Locke to the DHARMA grave and shot him. I'm worried for Hurley's safety now that Ben knows about Hurley's cabin sighting. Jacob's supernatural role on the island is still in play this season. Hurley, Ben, and Locke set off to visit Jacob in last week's episode. What will they find when they arrive?
"Because I have a man on their boat." ("Confirmed Dead") - Every so often Ben reminds everyone that he is always several steps ahead of them. When the freighties reached the island, he took another opportunity to show off his superior intellect. He knew exactly who the freighties were and what they wanted--him. We're usually lucky to get one big revelation per episode, but Ben's confession gave us an additional surprise. This statement also paved the way for Michael's return as Ben's spy.
"Good." ("The Economist") - Slightly more exciting than Sayid's future career as an assassin is the identity of his employer. Sayid despised Ben before the Oceanic Six were rescued; he equated trusting Ben with selling his soul in the exact same episode. The idea of them joining forces was confusing, but fascinating at the same time. We learned that revenge brought the men together in "The Shape of Things to Come." Ben was avenging Alex's death and Sayid was avenging Nadia's murder by a Widmore employee. I can't wait to see who they target next.
"How can you not possibly understand that you're mine? Take as much time as you need." ("The Other Woman") Ben and Juliet have a complicated history. Juliet's recent flashback revealed a jealous, possessive side to Ben Linus that we'd never seen before. Some men send flowers to get a woman's attention. He showed Juliet the rotting corpse of her lover, Goodwin. He responded to Juliet's grief with the tirade of an undermedicated stalker. In a few seconds, Ben went from a jealous rage to his usual creepy, calm demeanor. The transition was priceless.
"See you guys at dinner." ("The Other Woman") - You wouldn't expect Locke to trust Ben after he shot him last season, but Ben always finds away to get his attention. He's gotten out of several tough situations with the strategic disclosure of information. In this case, Ben won his freedom by telling Locke about Charles Widmore and the spy on the freighter. No prison can hold him if he can size up his captors quickly enough. At the end of "The Other Woman," Ben walked out of his basement cell and casually greeted Hurley and Sawyer. The look on his face, as though everything was going according to plan, gave us another reason to love Michael Emerson.
"So you do speak English." ("The Shape of Things to Come") - We've caught glimpses of Ben's violent actions: shooting Locke, killing his father and the DHARMA community, strangling Ana Lucia, etc. Last week's episode gave us a better idea of how deadly Mr. Linus can be. He took out two armed men in the Sahara desert with the kind of precision normally displayed by Sayid. Their shared action hero skills make them ideal partners in Ben's new revenge campaign.
"He changed the rules." ("The Shape of Things to Come") - Alex's death scene put me in the strange position of feeling sorry for Ben, a manipulator and murderer. I was already shocked that one of Ben's plans--sending Alex, Danielle, and Karl to safety--didn't work out. Things almost always work out for Ben. When Keamy shot Alex, Ben's grief was mixed with genuine surprise. The devastated father suddenly became more human and, for the first time, worthy of sympathy. This was Michael Emerson's Emmy moment.
"Sleep tight, Charles." ("The Shape of Things to Come") - Neither Ben Linus nor Charles Widmore appeared in Season One. Now all of the 815 survivors are stuck in the middle of a war between the two ruthless men. I thought that the writers would keep these characters apart for as long as possible, but Ben's first flash-forward brought him face-to-face with his daughter's killer. Ben rarely lets his friends or enemies know his true intentions. He made an exception for Widmore, however. He told Charles flat-out that he would avenge Alex by killing Widmore's daughter, Penny. I hope that this vow leads to a showdown between my two favorite Lost characters, Ben and Desmond.
Which moments would you add to the list?















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
4-30-2008 @ 12:27PM
DamnYankees said...
My favorite moment involving Ben was really more of a Sayid moment, when they come back from looking for his parachute in season. Sayid has that great line where he says "But still I did not believe it to be true." Ben's reaction to being exposed, the look on his face to end the episode before the LOST anvil hit - first time I got that 'Ben chill'.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 12:44PM
fred said...
"Jack with your permission I'd like to go with John!"
Screw the nomination, he's gotta win it!
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 4:39PM
Robert said...
Yeah, I'm gonna have to go with this one. I nearly died of laughter after that scene.
4-30-2008 @ 5:29PM
literaryluv said...
I agree! That was the best line ever!
4-30-2008 @ 1:39PM
Reuven said...
My favorite is still an earlier scene, when we still didn't know whether he was good or evil, as he calmly ate cereal in the hatch:
"Of course, if I was one of them -- these people that you seem to think are your enemies -- what would I do? Well, there'd be no balloon, so I'd draw a map to a real secluded place like a cave or some underbrush -- good place for a trap -- an ambush. And when your friends got there a bunch of my people would be waiting for them. Then they'd use them to trade for me. I guess it's a good thing I'm not one of them, huh?"
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 1:40PM
Reuven said...
Oops - left out the kicker -
"You guys got any milk?"
4-30-2008 @ 1:58PM
Chuck said...
I had forgotten some of these--thanks! Ben really is one of the great characters of modern television.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 2:36PM
erika said...
I think he's working up to being the greatest TV villian of all time!
4-30-2008 @ 3:55PM
MacGuffin said...
I AGREE! After last week, I am back in love with this show.
Ben (Michael Emerson) is one of the most intriguing characters I have ever seen. He makes this show far more interesting than a Gilligan's Island-theme (Will they get off the island? and how?) and into a much more dense mystery.
4-30-2008 @ 2:07PM
VtMom said...
I don't think Ben Linus is one of those characters you love to hate- I just love him period. I totally laughed when he gave Sawyer and Hurley that smarmy look and said "See you at dinner." LOVE him! But the milk line was priceless too. He's the best addition to that show, and I truly hope he does win an Emmy. His reaction to Alex's death was amazingly well acted.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 2:15PM
Danny said...
I really think that the "got milk" line is one of my favourite Lost moments of all time.
I can't believe this didn't make the list.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 4:10PM
Pete said...
For me, it's any quip that got him punched, beaten or slapped around by the 815'ers.
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 5:28PM
Sancty said...
Best Ben Moment Ever!
'No John, unfortunately we don't have a code for "there is a man in my closet holding a gun to my daughter's head", although we obviously should'
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 7:17PM
joe said...
my all time fav:
"you guys got any milk?"
Reply
4-30-2008 @ 10:20PM
jasahl said...
My favorite "line" was from Shape... and it wasn't even spoken.
The slight smile after turning away from Sayid at the end was priceless.
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 8:32AM
Mike said...
How about Ben's line ...."this rabbit didn't have a number on it, did it?" (As he eats the dinner John has prepared)
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 11:56AM
Jake said...
The best lines are not even spoken lines.There more his reaction to others speaking which makes him the best actor on tv right now.
Reply
5-01-2008 @ 4:00PM
freckles said...
what about ''kaaaaaaaaaaaarl''?
Reply
5-02-2008 @ 2:56AM
bobby said...
New here.
I always love Ben's moment.
The first and foremost shocking experiences to me is the "milk" line, creepy and funny.
Still wonder why Ben keeps lying to Locke to persuade him for not pushing the button, a great mystery, maybe want to kill Locke like shot him to death. However, if the hatch is really important for blocking communication, Ben would not plan such silly things to expose the island.
Another disappointing decision must be Alex, Ben should not let her go with him in Season 3 finale, Alex would well be in the temple with the Others safe. "Sigh" :]
Reply
5-04-2008 @ 8:35AM
tobe said...
I think the best Ben moment is when he asks Locke 'why do you let him make all the decisions?' when talking about Jack, and Locke replies that they make the decisions together. When Locke walks out the door he realises that Ben was right, and starts smashing things in anger. When Ben hears this he smiles in his creepy way, knowing that he got to Locke.
Reply