TVSquad

Yeah I'm with you. For a girl that's supposed to be squeaky clean, they have her draped in a satin sheet looking like a Lolita. I think Annie Leibovitz lost it this time. She's known for getting people naked, which has its own perils like I don't care to see John Lennon's skinny butt hugging Yoko whenever Leibovitz's names comes up in the news, but this is a 15 year old girl who shouldn't have been asked to pose topless, even with a sheet draped. 'Artistic' oldest line in the world! I'd have thought Leibovitz would have more common sense than to even propose it.

I'm not saying nude photos/art don't have a place, I'm quite the fan of the genre, in fact. But this was a young girl who has influence over millions of little girls out there.

Reply

I'm sorry, but celebrities are never alone on a shoot. There are always, ALWAYS publicists, managers, assistants, and in this case parents on set, watching every moment to control their client's image.

I don't believe Cyrus for a second... saying that she was taken advantage of.

Reply

Isn't this the same "girl" who gyrates her hips on stage at the Idol Gives Back show?

Yes, taken advantage of...*cough*bullshit*cough*

Reply

It's easy for everyone to make rash judgements - but to blame a 15 yr old kid is nonsense in my opinion.
And to the statement that Miley gyrates her hips too sexily while on stage - oh my - I wonder where she could have seen that before???
As for the photos - shame on her mother and her father period! And shame on Vanity Fair and mostly Liebovitz. Trusty me - those photos are designed to be artsy - their intent was to be controversial. Anne must be in for a big fat bonus. Shame on all of you !

Reply

Soo... while you're sitting there naked with only a blanket covering you... at no point does the thought cross your, or your parents, or your managers, or your yadda yadda yadda's minds that there would be someting objectionable about the resulting photos? More likely that did the shoot, had fun, then got wind that not everyone's going to appreciate the "artistic" value of the images that were shot. Now it's time to enter the Spin Zone to make sure the BILLION DOLLAR Hannah Montana Train doesn't get derailed.

Either that or Cyrus and her team really are ignorant, dumb ass hillbillies who got snookered by the big time city folk from Vanity Fair.

It's not up to Annie Leibovitz to uphold or enforce society's (current) standards. It's her job to create beautiful, lasting images. Let me apologize on her behalf for everyone out there who is greatly offended at being reminded that young folks have naked bodies underneath all those trendy clothes they waste their money on. What was God thinking?

Reply

What how could they do that to Miley!!!!!!!!

Reply

Funny,.. I was just telling my wife while we were watching Idol Gives Back, that Miley Cyrus was gonna crash hard. It's unfortunate, but she's already following the path that Britney and other similar stars have paved for her. The sad thing is that I don't blame Miley, but the press and papparatzi for the eventual downturn of this star. I'm not really a fan of hers, but good luck anyway girl. Your gonna need it.

Reply

Who could ever imagine that being shot by Annie Leibovitz in little more than a skimpy sheet would be inappropriate for a 15-year old?

I love how Miley feigns surprise.

Reply

Please don't blame the press for the actions of Miley and her handlers. After the suggestive photos of Vanessa Hudgens hit the web, Disney and Miley's family, should have put their foot down, regarding the image of her. Miley, continues to have photos of her leaked onto the web, and nothing is said, but now that people have spoken unfavorably about these pictures, the Cyrus's are backpeddling. Shame on Billy Ray Cyrus for pimping his daughter out there like he has. She's not a grown woman, she's 15yrs old, and it's about time she started acting like it.

Reply

On the one hand this is Vanity Fair, they have a tendancy to do risque photoshoots, Lindsay Lohan, being the latest example. On the other though, this is Miley Cyrus, why is "Vanity Fair" doing an interview and/or photoshoot with her anyways? Does "Vanity Fair" magazine really think a 15 year-old pop star is really the kind of topic thier readers want an article on? What kind of questions doe she get on a "Vanity Fair" interview? 'Does the blonde wig itch when you wear it?'

Reply

Much Ado About Nothing!

Reply

"There are always, ALWAYS publicists, managers, assistants, and in this case parents on set, watching every moment to control their client's image."

Exactly. That is 100% true.

This is a very unfortunate situation, but I feel more sorry for the young girls who look up to her.

Reply

This has nothing to do with being ashamed of nudity.

It has everything to do with her being 15 and the fact that most of her fans are in the 6-12 age range.

I absolutely ADORE Annie Leibovitz photography, but CLEARLY she goes for the artistic AND controversial and I do blame her.

Miley is 15. She is still a child and YES I can see how she could be manipulated. Is her family and handlers blameless? No. I even think this is a good lesson for her and she will/should know better next time, but she is still a child. A 15 year old child that has had a lot thrust on her.

It amazes me how people love to HATE these "stars." I find it soo strange that people can muster so much hatred and emotion toward someone they don't know.

Anyway, the pictures don't offend me, but I do feel bad for the fans and the parents who try so hard to have a wholesome image presented to their children.

Reply

My 7 year old daughter saw the photo on the news and was shocked that Mily had NO CLOTHES ON!!
Then she asked why would she do that and do I have to take pictures like that? All she ever wanted was to be like Mily.
I am so dissapionted in Billy Ray to allow this to happen.
I was truly hoping that Mily was the ONE to stay real and be a good role model for ALL the young girls out there.
I hope it's not all down hill from here.

Reply

This is so NOT an issue. Way to spin something way out of control, media. That apology should never have been necessary. Look at the photo... nothing is showing except her back. Nothing wrong about showing back in this society. Yeah, she happens to be covered by a sheet and doesn't happen to be wearing anything else, but she IS wearing the sheet and is therefore properly covered.

Calm down, world.

Terry, I recommend explaining to your daughter that she still covered up everything you're not supposed to show society.

Reply

It's amazing how much attention these pix are getting. At first I thought she had been caught in a Paris Hilton-like situation. There is an interesting photo gallery showing a backstage look at the now-infamous VF shoot here http://dish.fancast.com/2008/04/photos_backstage_a t_the_miley.html

Reply

I am sorry but to be blaming everyone but the child. Who is 15 yrs old and should have known better in the first place is just wrong. If she didnt want to do it then she should have spoke up. She never should have done it if she didnt want to, and if the parents or anyone else thought it was wrong they should have spoke up instead of letting her do it. But I have to disagree with the whole thing, why make a huge deal out of this. First off she isnt topless she isnt showing anything other then her back. To me the pics are tasteful and I dont see anything wrong with them. Why is is that now a days everyone thinks its ok to point their fingers at everyone else and not the person who they should be pointing them at. Stop blaming the parents and everyone else, blame Miley, if she did something wrong. The girl is growing up and she has to shed the Disney Channel imagine and this is the way to do it. Its not like she got pregnant(Jamie Spears) or anything like that. How about stop making a big deal out her pics and make a bigger deal out of Jamie Spears belly bump instead of showing that on TV like its nothing.

Reply