(S01E12) What the hell? Did I really just see what I thought I saw on Eli Stone? The entire episode was predicated on Eli having a vision that if it were to come true, would be catastrophic. He sees the Golden Gate Bridge destroyed when an earthquake hits San Francisco. This isn't the first time he's seen this kind of destruction, but the last time nothing happened. So, then, what are we to make of the fact that this time around, it really does! Like I said, is this really real? Tune in next week for more of the thrilling days of Eli Stone...Seriously, what happened in this episode suggests that this is the penultimate moment for Eli Stone, the character and the series. Everything is building to Eli having the surgery to remove the aneurysm that's supposedly causing all his sensory hallucinations next week. Eli meets with the surgeon and is advised to get his affairs in order. With just a 50-50 chance of surviving or becoming a vegetable, Eli asks Matt -- who now calls himself "The Dowd" -- to write his living will. When Taylor finds out and insists that nothing will happen to Eli, he tells her he doesn't want to be Terri Schiavo'ed, hence the documents. Patti learns that if Eli dies, she gets all his George Michael CDs.
Unable to get anyone to believe his visions, Eli turns to Dr. Chen. He alerts Eli to Dr. Daniel Foote -- played by the always-interesting John Billingsley -- who claims to have a machine that determines earthquakes. His forecast coincides with Eli's vision, so Eli takes Dr. Foote's claim to court to get the city to close the Golden Gate Bridge for that time of the quake. Eli winds up facing Marci Klein, Jordan's nemesis at W.P.K., who is determined to win in court and make Eli look ridiculous -- which in turn will prove to the partners that Jordan's faith in Eli is ruining the reputation of the firm. By getting Maggie, who was second chair with Marci, to testify against Eli, Ms. Klein wins in court. Before the partners, Jordan speaks eloquently about humanity and the need for an Eli Stone in every business. Still, when the votes are counted, Marci wins and Jordan is ousted as managing partner.
Even though the judge rules against Eli and Foote, a representative of the city tells them that the mayor is a believer. The bridge will be closed -- just in case. Eli pleads with his co-workers to have faith in him and leave the 22nd floor offices and go to Golden Gate Park where they will be most likely to survive The Big One. Some do, the partners don't, and just as Jordan gets the news that he's been trounced, the quake hits and glass shatters all around. A beam crashes to the conference table and he asks for a re-vote, having been proven right about Eli.
At Golden Gate Park, Eli, Nate, Patti, Dr. Chen and Maggie (plus her cute fiance, Scott), watch as the Golden Gate Bridge collapses in two! And that's that. This was a 6.8 quake on the Richter scale and all they showed was the bridge collapsing (thank you, CG effects) and some rubble in the office. Where was the devastation? Where was The Big One in Silver Terrace? For all the build-up, nobody's hair got mussed! I realize this is episodic TV, not a feature, but please -- if you're going to make it real, make it real. I was left with a big 'what the hell?' I guess we'll find out next week.
Other Points of Interest
-- There was no music in this episode. No joyful song. No clues in the lyrics. Nada. Zip. I missed it.
-- Why was there no connection to last week's messianic show? If you had a vision of a possible future where you're leading a cause, with the message to Live Brave beating in your head, wouldn't you be thinking about it? Eli didn't even bring it up.
-- There was carryover from last week in The Dowd and Taylor. He finally got a dinner date with her and proceeded to act like a jerk. It was fun to see Eli choose him to do the living will because he wanted a lawyer with an "utter lack of humanity."
-- Jordan really went to bat for Eli. He referred to himself as being "made of Kevlar." That appeared to be so after the earthquake left him unscathed. He also had a good scene with Eli, letting him know that Eli's weird cases have been allowed because of Jordan's good graces. He used the phrase, "at my pleasure," like Eli was his servant. Very imperious. Very Jordan.
-- When Eli speaks to his co-workers, he says of himself that he's the lawyer with the hole in his head and an inappropriate song in his heart.
-- Eli's feelings for Maggie are getting complicated. After giving her a frame as an engagement gift (Patti bought it), Maggie puts a picture of Scott in it and Eli recognizes that Scott was driving the cab in Eli's vision of the bridge collapse. After losing in court, Eli implores Maggie to believe his prediction of destruction and save herself and Scott. To convince her that he knows Scott's involved, he uses the pet name Scott has for Maggie -- "Macaroni."
-- I like Katey Sagal as Marci Klein, but she's really coming off as too much the Wicked Witch. She needs to have something else going for her besides proving Jordan wrong. Was she telling the truth about a past affair with him? Her manipulation of Maggie was predictable. Hell, Eli warned Maggie that Marci would use her against him, and Marci did.
-- Nate should have been with Eli when he met with the surgeon. I'd want my M.D. brother with me when I'm planning on having brain surgery.










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-14-2008 @ 8:17AM
La-Di-Dah said...
This episode was fun or me: I liked the "Dowd" and the "Jordan" moments. But it wasn't tight (in typical Eli fashion, actually). Events moved very fast. And the earthquake was not particularly shattering. Almost felt like a rushed script. I hope they are NOT cancelling this show because I am interested in them fumbling their way until they have a consistent show. Oh, and I was rooting NOT to meet Maggie's fiancee.
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 8:40AM
David said...
You wanted a song for the episode, Allison?
"Mag-aroni, the San Francisco treat"
Have fun getting that one out of your head today :-)
(Oh, and I'm with you. I was really surprised when they really had the earthquake. But since this is TV, any devastation beyond Silver Terrace will be minor plot point and within a week or two, they'll be back to showing exteriors of the WPK office building looking pristine.)
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 10:47AM
Mark said...
Two nitpiks:
1. The Golden Gate Bridge is not visible from Golden Gate Park.
2. The bridge isn't likely to be harmed in a 6.8 quake. It survived rather nicely the 6.9 Loma Prieta quake of 1989.
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 11:28AM
lucyfan62 said...
I think the bridge was damaged because the epicenter was closer to it (my guess). It's funny you mention Marci's one-note evilness. My other half said during the episode, "I thought she'd at least be a fun b***h." I thought it was weird that Nate didn't appear in this episode until the very end (unless I missed him somewhere), and the quake did seem to be a rather small affair to damage the bridge but not the building (that much). But Eli wouldn't be able to have his surgery in the next episode if the city had been totally devastated. It would have been nice to have had some news about Silver Terrace so Patti could have a "thank you" moment with Eli. A little disappointing in the end because I was expecting "The Big One," but I still love the show and hope it makes it back on ABC's schedule!
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 12:00PM
Gordon Werner said...
I had furniture and fixtures fall on me during the Seattle Earthquake in 2001. My hair didn't get mussed up either. And we didn't have widespread devastation.
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 12:30PM
martin nm said...
Eli Stone is one of the most enjoyable TV shows we have watched in a long time. Let's see, no violence, no murder, no reality, no sexual content. Just the type of show TV execs would drop. I hope they don't cancel it. I wrote ABC at abc.com and sent them an email. It is well written, funny, interesting, quirky, fun. Write ABC.
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 12:35PM
martin nm said...
You're right! The park is in the middle of SF. Maybe he should have said go to the Presidio.
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 3:07PM
Liz said...
Ack, I forgot they moved this to Sunday nights so I missed it!
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 3:33PM
martin nm said...
Liz, just go to abc.com and you can watch last night s ep.
4-14-2008 @ 3:53PM
clgbutterfly said...
YaY! DVR or I would have missed this. First let's clear up Allison's comment about the first vision of an earthquake being wrong. It wasn't wrong, he just didn't know when it would happened and assumed it would happen soon. By allowing the first vision to not have a date, Eli has a crisis of faith and learned how far he would go in his belief of a vision. Luckily he seems pretty grounded in knowing they are real, but is still going through with the surgey. I think this is Eli still being a bit selfish just wishing to have a normal life and not be a nut like his father. He still can't control the visions and tell a Lawyer they don't have control. It will drive them crazy. They always want all the cards. I really liked how they worked the scientist into proving his "mystical visions". I was also a little perturbed that last weeks episode (except for The Dowd) was completely glossed over. In fact I had forgotten I hadn't finished watching the "Live Brave" episode and found no need for it to watch it for this episode. The Live Brave episode was amazing and I am sure it will tie into future episodes. I really really hope they don't cancel the series. It's really good and alot better than I'd thought it would be. Keep it going!
Reply
4-14-2008 @ 3:54PM
Gwen said...
I loved this episode and it was the first one since the pilot that made me cry. No we didn't see Silver Terrace but I really didn't miss the lack.
I did miss the music but the Eli being with the car with the guy who turns out to be Maggie's boyfriend pretty much made up for it.
Also, I thought it was way cool that John Billingsley's character was a sort of homage to his character in the 9 - Eli Stone character Daniel Foote -- The Nine character Ethan Foote.
I agree that Katey's character needs more going for her than her Jordan vendetta. Hopefully, that will be fleshed out in subsequent episodes.
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 12:30PM
Jennifer said...
That cracked me up too. I kept waiting for Dr. Foote to have the same first name as well.
4-14-2008 @ 5:31PM
Gordon Werner said...
I really really hope that they pick this show up for more seasons
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 12:29PM
Jennifer said...
As a Bay Area native, I am all, "um, yeah, if a 6.8 quake goes off in SF, and if it's The Big One (and Eli doesn't know that), wouldn't a LOT MORE STUFF BE DESTROYED?!
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 7:36PM
David M. said...
I think that in the next episode's vision, the person who Eli sees and asks, "Are you God?," is going to be Dr. Chen. Think about it, Dr. Chen has guided him along the way and helped him decode the visions. In my opinion, they wont introduce a new character as God. I just hope they don't make it his father, that would just be cheesy.
Reply
4-15-2008 @ 10:15PM
Oreo said...
Yes! I voted correctly!
Here's a hint, you are mostly wrong.
Reply