Television has a long standing tradition of making its stars feel more popular than they really are. As somebody who used to be on TV, five nights a a week, I know what that feeling is like. Generally when that person leaves television, they go on to do movies or change professions and they often become even more popular. However, there is always that TV celebrity who overestimates how much people want to see them and when they leave their hit TV show, it ends up being the biggest mistake of their career.
David Caruso
Before Caruso became the star of the weakest part of the CSI franchise, he was the star of NYPD Blue. After playing numerous bit parts on TV and in film, he finally hit the big time. The critics and the public both agreed that he was a breath of fresh air in what had become a stale world of TV dramas. He was sexy and tough, just like his show and he fit in perfectly with his supporting characters. Then suddenly, Caruso decided he was too talented for the small screen and bailed on the show. His much talked-about departure allowed him to make unwatchable films like Jade and the remake of Kiss of Death that nobody asked for. Luckily, the ginger-haired tough guy was able to revive his career, but one can't help but wonder how different things would have been had he continued to be Detective John Kelly.
David Hartman
Most of you probably don't remember David Hartman but a quick Google search will reveal that he played a number of roles on TV and in movies. However, his career reached its peak when he was chosen as the host of a new AM news program called Good Morning America. With his affable style and natural charm he was the perfect choice to interview newsmakers and introduce the news. In fact, at one point, David Hartman was the highest-paid man on television. It would seem, however, that fame and riches were not Hartman's cup of tea. I really hope that he invested wisely because Hartman has been more or less MIA since he left the show.
Shelly Long
What can be said about Ms. Long's ill-advised decision to leave one of the highest-rated shows on TV to do films like Camp Beverly Hills and Irreconcilable Differences that hasn't already been said? The only mistake she hasn't made is trying to return to television in a serious role. Would it even be humanly possible to take her seriously after seeing The Money Pit?
McLean Stevenson
Most fans of classic television only remember McLean as Henry Blake on M*A*S*H. What few people know is that he left what would become one the most popular TV shows in history because CBS offered him a chance to star in his own show. He then succeeded in starring in a string of failures in between making appearances on various game shows. In fact, his sitcom Hello Larry is often referenced as one of the worst TV shows ever produced. The ultimate insult came right before his death when he was cast as Baby's father in the TV version of Dirty Dancing.
Suzanne Somers
Most people are well aware of what happened to Suzanne Somers when she overestimated her own personal worth to the success of Three's Company. The mistakes made by her and her husband/manager are legendary. Amazingly, Somers was able to rise above her embarrassing appearances on talk shows where she sang and read poetry to star in another successful sitcom. I suppose we should consider ourselves lucky that she never decided to star in a string of terrible movies.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
3-31-2008 @ 11:19AM
Vixen said...
I love your comments on Caruso...."Too sexy and Too talented". Sorry, I almost spilled my coffee...And the movies he made were amost all straight to video affairs. He is a tacky actor. Even today.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 4:06PM
tv junkie said...
agreed. can't stand him. had to change the channel whenever a glimpse of him popped up on screen.
3-31-2008 @ 12:01PM
C C said...
Wayne Rogers leaving MASH was just as big a mistake as McLean Stevenson leaving. If I recall correctly, Rogers left to do House Calls, which was a hit in it's first season, but then floundered. Although my parents and I did like Mike Farrell as BJ, we still wonder what MASH would have been like if Trapper had been in more seasons, even more so than Henry Blake.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 12:23PM
Melanie said...
Paul, while I agree with your choices above, please note that the movie Shelly Long was in was "Troop Beverly Hills", and not "Camp Beverly Hills"...which by the way is one of my favorite movies of all time..a guilty pleasure if you will...
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 11:30PM
Phish said...
that was one of your fav movies of all time? Holy Cow! the idiocracy has truly begun!
anyways, those people left those shows for various reasons that we dont completely know or understand.
it is said that hindsight is 20/20, and to live a life full of regrets is very sad indeed.
however, its not like the left a show just before it EXPLODED, or turned down a role on a show that became huge!
they were just moving on. you cant say any of them are pete best!
3-31-2008 @ 12:53PM
0megapart!cle said...
Oh, I think CSI:NY is undoubtedly the worst of the CSI spawn. CSI:Miami is occasionally watchable if it is late night and I am desperate to watch some TV. Gary Sinise is not, although I like many of his movies.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 2:19PM
Smitty Werbenjaegermanjensen said...
Amen to that comment.
I stopped watching CSI:NY after season two, because it was so bad. I really tried to like it, but it just sucks.
3-31-2008 @ 12:57PM
Adam said...
M*A*S*H Seasons 1 - 3 were tons better than 4 - 11. And a lot of that had to do with both McLean Stevenson and Wayne Rogers. To me, Rogers and Alda had more connection that Alda and Farrell. But then again, the same goes for Larry Linville when compared to Stiers. Nothing beats the original TV M*A*S*H cast.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 12:57PM
rex said...
One of my favorite scenes in a recent movie is in the "40 Year Old Virgin" when Seth Rogen gives Steve Carrell advice on talking to the girl working at the book store.
-Be David Caruso in "Jade."
- Oh, ok, I know exactly what you're talking about.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 1:19PM
Bebop said...
Can we preemptively add Katherine Heigl to the list if she leaves 'Grey's Anatomy'?
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 1:22PM
David said...
You're forgetting Harry Hamlin, leaving L.A. Law at its finest to forge a career in movies. Until his wife showed up on DWTS 20 years later, we never saw him again.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 4:08PM
xbxtv said...
That's probably because you didn't watch "Veronica Mars"...
3-31-2008 @ 1:25PM
Johari said...
Being on the most popular show in the world must be the biggest mistake Caruso has ever made.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 1:35PM
Vixen said...
CSI Miami can't compete qualitywise with NYPD Blue. CSI Miami may be the most watched show. But the writing and acting is crap....and Caruso is responsible for 95% of the bad acting on that show
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 1:45PM
BartmanDK said...
Well i like CSI: Miami a lot because of the over-the-top-acting and story-lines.. Caruso's one-liners are just pure gold for me
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 1:48PM
MERVE-THE-PERVE said...
I dont even have time to add all the snl failures here, jimmy fallon seems like a good starting place.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 2:48PM
J said...
How about Denise Crosby who played Tasha Yar on Star Trek: The Next Generation? Possibly not as mainstream as the others posted here, she left a very successful show early on to pursue a film career that never materialized.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 7:10PM
BStu said...
Her reasons weren't as simple as wanting to do bigger and better things, though. As I understand it, she wasn't happy with her portrayal and work on the show. She wasn't the only one, after all. Gates McFadden left after season 1, too. The key thing is that she didn't leave the show to do something else. She left the show because she wasn't happy with the show. All things considered, I'd say her career was at least as successful as it would have been had she stayed on the show. I mean, its not like Gates or Sirtis have become household names. Crosby has acted steadily and even made up with the folks at Star Trek and was able to define her role as something genuinely iconic in the show's cannon.
3-31-2008 @ 2:57PM
Whitecat said...
People crap on CSI: Miami because they are trying to compare it to the original CSI. They were not trying to do a "copycat" of that show set in Miami. They were trying to do a highly stylized version of the show.
Reply
3-31-2008 @ 2:57PM
sam said...
CSI Miami - "weakest part of the franchise"? Not exactly. Usually in the Top 10, always ahead of CSI NY. As for Caruso, I don't think he considers leaving NYPD Blue the "biggest mistake" in retrospect. It became a huge learning experience for him. More power to those who learn from their failures. Little is learned from success.
Reply