(S33E06) Let me preface this entire review by saying that I've seen Juno multiple times and greatly enjoyed each viewing. I think Ellen Page is a talented actress and Juno would not have been as successful without her. I'm saying this because I'm worried that my review of this episode might make it look like I'm part of the online Juno backlash. Man, this was a terrible episode. The writing was weak, but Page's awkward performance(s) didn't help the situation. I found myself almost instantly annoyed with Page's voice. "There's going to be another hour and fifteen minutes of this?!" I thought during the monologue. It's like Page can't help but talk like a rough-around-the-edges teen in skinny jeans all the time. It makes me wonder if that's all she's going to be able to play in films. Perhaps she was just really nervous and it made he scream a lot. Either way, it totally made my ears want to bust out of my skull, home skillet. Honest to blog. Obviously.
Cold Open: First off, Brian Williams never struck me as the imitable type, but Will Forte's impression totally proved me wrong. Granted, it was a little wacky, but the overall inflection was spot-on. Darrell Hammond's eyebrows, however, were definitely not spot-on. I know Tim Russert has some expressive eyebrows, but it looked like Hammond accidentally burned off his eyebrows a few seconds before the sketch and had to hastily draw them back on with a grease marker before going on-camera. Also, Fred Armisen's Barack Obama impression (which has stirred up a bit of Internet controversy) changed dramatically from last time. In the Tina Fey episode, his Obama looked a little grumpy and had a fairly deep voice. This time he was borderline Spongebob Squarepants' Patrick. To make this sketch even more wacky, Vincent D'Onofrio showed up to do a few Law & Order sound gags. No, I have no idea why he was on the show either.
The real Hillary Clinton then popped up to comment on the Cold Open, which was quite lovely. She did a nice job, especially towards the end. I guess it's only fair that she get a bit of this attention since Obama made his appearance a few months ago. Now, if only someone could get either Clinton or Obama to host. Hey, McCain did it!
Monologue: Ellen Page looked super nervous as she was giving her monologue and her voice went crackly often enough to make it difficult for me to ignore. Thank goodness Andy Samberg showed up as Diablo Cody to distract me. I was eagerly anticipating some jokes about Cody's dreadful "hip" writing that made the first ten minutes of Juno absolute torture. The final "I was a stripper!" was beautiful as well.
"The Dakota Fanning Show": Miley Cyrus' voice is painful to listen to, but Page portraying her made everything even worse. It was like she couldn't control her inflection and volume. Anyway, the interaction between Amy Poehler's Dakota Fanning and Kenan Thompson's Reggie are always incredibly simple and almost formulaic, but Thompson's reactions are usually good enough for me to laugh along. I must also encourage someone out there to actually create a band called Wanda Rwanda and record an album called "A Jam Sesh Called Wanda". Perfect.
"Saturday TV Funhouse: The Obama Files": Holy crap! When was the last time the Funhouse dog ripped the SNL bumper in a way that maintained the "Saturday" (the way it should be done, so as to show the "Saturday" in "Saturday TV Funhouse")? The nitpicker in me is happy. This piece was funny, but seemed really different from Robert Smigel's usual contributions to the show. It was like an outrageously elaborate skit that would have been too expensive/difficult to produce with real actors, as opposed to a humorous manipulation of old audio or something. Even the "X-Presidents" weren't this driven by a well-rounded story. I would also like to remind everyone that "c'mon, Reverend, lions are cool".
"College for Excellence": Tacky late-night college ad. Pretty straightforward.
"The Other Boleyn Girls": Ellen Page, her voice! Why did she have to shout everything? That goes for most of her performances that night, actually. Anyway, this sketch was worth a few chuckles, but nothing more.
"An SNL Digital Short: The Mirror": The absolute bizarre surreality of this piece was awesome. I mean, they really pushed the weirdness on this one. If they had held back at all, it would have fallen on its face, but I think they succeeded. The quick cut from the werewolf to Dracula in bed was awesome.
"Weekend Update": Rudy Giuliani felt the need to make an appearance. Good for him and Mike Huckabee, making fun of themselves like that. Fred Armisen reprised his Nicolas Fehn political comedian character, which is always beautifully played. It's so natural, I sometimes wonder if Armisen really does it off the top of his head. As for the rest of WU, the jokes were all right. My favorite was German napping.
"Shopping with Virginiaca": I'm usually okay with Virginiaca, despite its formulaic format. I guess I'm a sucker for when Kenan Thompson's characters pronounce things incorrectly (see: Virginiaca's "nuggrets" and Charles Barkley's "Ohh, Bork!") Ellen Page continued to scream, but this time with a white girl 'fro and occasional booty shake. The subtle reference to Juno at the very, very end was cute.
"The Continuing Adventures of Peter Pan": I absolutely loved that Bill Hader, super master of voice disguise, used such a boring speaking voice for Captain Hook. Beautiful touch, I must say. Will Forte's enthusiasm was also perfect.
"Post-Ethridge": As if to purposely fuel the online speculation of Page's sexuality, this skit was all about a guy's girlfriend going gay at a Melissa Ethridge concert. The writing was really funny in this, but, geez, it had the worst ending EVER. Seriously.
Next time: Amy Adams and Vampire Weekend! I wonder if Amy Adams is going to be one of those celebrities that sing during their monologues.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
3-02-2008 @ 10:22AM
Peanut said...
That TV Funhouse went from "This is going to be good" to "This has gone on too long" in record time.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 10:34AM
Fred said...
"The Mirror" seemed sort of reminiscent of the Kids in the Hall's skit "The Pear Dream." (Maybe crossed with a little Jessica-Alba-in-The-Eye spoof.) Overall, a pretty disappointing episode.
Reply
4-06-2008 @ 12:37AM
MessyMom said...
I thought it reminded me of something from the kids in the hall. I searched all over trying to find a comment about it and found yours. Thanks for reminding me what KITH skit it was.
3-02-2008 @ 10:51AM
Ryan said...
Things I liked:
- The Mirror
- Wilco
- The Other Boleyn Girls
- Hillary Clinton
- Diablo Cody
Everything else, including Ellen Page as host, ranged from dull to excruciatingly bad. And I *love* Ellen Page.
Page shockingly disappointed. I have high hopes for Amy Adams.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 10:52AM
Galley said...
That mirror skit was horrible. I guess I haven't missed anything in the past 13 years. Mad TV gives me all the funny I need.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 11:05AM
fishpatrol said...
Wilco played my two least favorite songs off of Sky Blue Sky, but how upset can I be when they look so silly-happy to be playing? They looked like they'd jumped on stage on a dare and then couldn't believe that the cameras went live anyway. If they'd just chosen...anything else to play, I would have enjoyed it so much more.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 11:06AM
Thomas said...
Why is this show on the air? Honestly, each week, at best half of the show is OK, the rest is dire, if we're lucky we get one or two good bits. Why does the show have to be the length it is? Why not cut it down to an hour and try and make something really high quality?
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 11:26AM
Oreo said...
I agree, it would be a lot better at an hour. They have the opening and such that takes 15 minutes, two songs ten minutes, and some commercials, they still have plenty of time to do at least 3, if not 5 skits.
The thing is that people watch and with it being 90 minutes they have 30 extra minutes for commercials.
3-02-2008 @ 11:22AM
lucyfan62 said...
The opening with the real Hillary, the Digital Short (brilliant!) and WU were the only watchable parts of the show. I'm not on the Ellen Page bandwagon and this certainly won't help put me there (I haven't seen JUNO and now I don't think I can). She basically has one blank expression and one of the most grating, monotone voices I've ever heard. I fear her acting shelf life will expire long before anyone expects it to.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 11:28AM
David said...
Nothing in this show made me laugh harder than Armisen's inspired performance as Nicholas Fehn. I honestly don't know how he does it. "Look... I have two cousins..." I pity the guy over at SNL Transcripts that has to write it all down.
But yeah, I agree -- Ms. Page seemed as awkward here as she does in the formal dress on the cover of Vanity Fair. I felt that she was at her best, oddly enough, in the dramatic parts of "The Mirror," which I thought was beautifully directed and cut.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 12:03PM
Jimmy said...
In the space of seven days, SNL went from one of the best episodes in years to one of the worst of all time. The only parts that were even in the neighborhood of funny were Samberg's Diablo Cody and Armisen's Nicholas Fehn, which went on a little too long.
Ellen Page was horrible and will undoubtedly be a one-hit wonder with "Juno."
P.S. You misspelled Etheridge.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 2:38PM
Argus said...
Really? Out of all the shows SNL has ever done you thought that Tina Fey's hosting job was one of the best ever? There have been soo many better episodes than that in recent years. Alec Baldwin and Steve Martin's last episodes both come to mind. I would put this and the Tina Fey episode on par with each other, in that I thought they both had really nice parts and really bad parts.
The Mirror was fantastic though, and I really liked the Peter Pan sketch as well.
I don't know exactly whether I should blame "Yellen' Page" on the directors, the writers, or herself. I doubt they're just told to go on stage and wing is so I can't see the problems with that not being caused by someone since the yelling was so blatant that anyone who didn't like it would have caught it.
3-02-2008 @ 4:38PM
Jimmy said...
Read carefully, Argus: I said Tina's show was one of the best "in years," not "ever."
Last week, like you, I compared her show to recent episodes hosted by Alec Baldwin -- and I would add Justin Timberlake's and Jack Black's too.
3-02-2008 @ 4:49PM
Paul said...
Ellen Page is already more than a one-hit wonder, having gained huge acclaim for her role in "Hard Candy" a couple years ago. And of course, even though her part wasn't one of the major characters, she was in the third "X-Men" movie, which hardly counts as an unknown film or role.
3-02-2008 @ 12:28PM
Usama said...
I love Ellen Page, and I don't think she's a one-hit wonder, but yeah she wasn't her best at all on SNL. SNL Digital Short had me laughing.
Man, Tina Fey, Ellen Page, and now Amy Adams? I'm pretty happy about the hosts (although admittedly Page let us down).
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 12:49PM
Craig said...
I thought Armistead's Obama impression was better this week. He had more of his vocal cadence down. On the other hand, whoever did Obama in the Funhouse skit was good. Get that guy.
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 1:42PM
mal said...
Does anyone know the first Wilco song they played last night with the lyric" I hate it when your gone"?
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 5:00PM
yatesy said...
The first Wilco song was called "Hate It Here".
3-02-2008 @ 2:00PM
Diego M said...
Wow, that show was awul. the opening was okay and the monologue was okay, but it jus got awful fast
Reply
3-02-2008 @ 2:33PM
ac said...
When I saw Page on Letterman she seemed very nervous so I'm chalking her performance up to being nervous. I guess she's not used to all this. I think she will have a great career though.
Cold Open: Was the same as last week basically. The L&O cameo made me laugh. Hilary didnt really.
Monolougue: She looked nervous and was worried until Sanburg came in.
Dakota Fanning: I actually found her Miley Cirrus to be spot on cause she was annoying.
College Ad: sucked
TV Funhouse: Started out funny and dragged.
The Other Boylen Girls: At first I thought it was going to be one of those innuendo filled ones, but sadly it wasn't.
Mirror: Best part of the show tonight.
WU: Tune in next week for Mit Romney (seriously)
Virginica: Annoying
Peter Pan: Second funniest of the night.
Post Ethridge: Did Ellen Page just come out of the closet?
Reply