(S07E10) Looks like Idol's getting an early start with the cheesy blatant endorsements. They opened this episode with an incredibly corny Jumper intro featuring Hayden Christensen and Ryan Seacrest. But tonight is all about about the chair and final judgment for the contestants. No more singing; no more chances to prove themselves. It's simply a matter of sitting down and hearing if they're in the Top 24 or headed home.
It's amazing that what on paper looks like it has to be one of the most interminably boring hours on television still manages to be compelling and taut with suspense. Ronald Hodge, who I don't remember having ever seen before is the first to take the chair, and the first to get cut. I might feel more sympathetic about this if I knew who the hell he was. That string continued as I said "Huh?" and "Who?" while Nina Shaw, Mycale Guyton and Lisa Aukerman all heard that their journeys had ended as well.
 |
|
Need more American Idol? Get an inside look at Season 7's contestants and think back to these scathing (and hilarious) Simon Cowell quotes.
Also: Find out which Idols have been named the Biggest Idol flops! |
The rockers represented in Hollywood. For David Cook, he knew he hadn't impressed Simon with his guitar work, but he still made the Top 24. The judges were worried if American Idol was the right place for Amanda Overmyer, but ultimately decided it was. The news wasn't as good for Brandon Green, Amanda Hawkins and Buck Smith, who get a very sympathetic "Who the hell are those people?" from me. Sorry to see you for the first time as you're leaving. Shaun Barrowes, Lorena Pinot, Drew Poppelreiter and Natasha Blach (sp?) joined the list of people we barely know or don't know at all and now say goodbye to.
I was equally as sorry to be seeing for the first time, or damned well might as well have been, Jason Castro, Luke Menard, Garrett Haley, Jason Yeager, Alexandrea Lushington and David Hernandez. They all made it into the Top 24, but who are they? When did we get to see them shine on stage and understand how they made it? It really bothers me what a disadvantage Idol gives some of their Top 24 contestants. Here we are ten episodes in and I've never seen these guys sing, that I can recall.
Star Search winner David Archuleta certainly got plenty of screen time throughout the first nine episodes. And he'll get plenty more as part of The Top 24. Kristy Lee Cook, Brooke White, and Danny Noriega, Ramiele Malubay and Michael Johns made it through as well, though these names got so much air-time and praise throughout, I can't say I was surprised by any of them.
Syesha Mercado lost her voice in Hollywood, but still managed to pull out a strong performance in the end. I wasn't as confident that she'd make it, as I felt she oversang some of her songs. But she did and joins Robbie Carrico, Kady Malloy, Chikezie Eze, Amy Davis, Asia'H Epperson and Alaina Whitaker in the Top 24
Plenty of time was also spent on homeless Brit-sounding Josiah Leming, who was called overconfident by Simon at the end of Hollywood week. And he took up way too much of my TV time again here.We got to see him talk about how his gut told him he would make the Top 24. And then after he got a "No" served with a nice big slice of humble pie, we got to see him break down and hug all the other contestants. Hell, he even got his own background music for his rejection. I have to wonder, considering all this attention, if he's not set up as an alternate, that way if someone posed topless on an internet site four years ago and they have to kick them out, they can call on Josiah. Of course, then it'd have to be a guy who did that ... Chikezie?
In the end, as always, the Idol loves to bring it down to two contestants on each side who go up together, so they can reject one at the exact same time they put the other one through to the Top 24. This creates one of those awesomely uncomfortable and awkward moment. Ecstasy side-by-side with anguish. Ah, sweet anguish! Zoom that camera in! See how she's trying to pretend she's happy for the other girl? Oh yeah! She wants to stab her right now. This is pure gold, right here! Pure gold!
For the guys, they put Colton Berry up against future politician Kyle Ensley. Neither decision was unanimous, but in the end it's good news for Colton and the end of the road for Kyle. Simon disagreed with this decision and thought Kyle should have made it, no disrespect intended to Colton. Kyle got a lot of praise and support and encouragement to come back and try again.
Then it was the ladies turn, and Joanne Borgella and Cardin McKinney got to face off for the final slot. Wrapping up the Top 24 is plus-size model Joanne on a unanimous vote. So there you have it. An hour of television in which essentially nothing happened but hearing a bunch of people hear "Yes" or "No." Good stuff, huh? And without further adieu, here they are:
Top 12 Girls:
Joanne Borgella
Kristy Lee Cook
Amy Davis
Asia'H Epperson
Alexandrea Lushington
Ramiele Malubay
Kady Malloy
Syesha Mercado
Amanda Overmyer
Carly Smithson
Alaina Whitaker
Brooke White
Top 12 Boys:
David Archuleta
Colton Berry
Robbie Carrico
Jason Castro
David Cook
David Hernandez
Chikezie Eze
Garrett Haley
Michael Johns
Luke Menard
Danny Noriega
Jason Yeager
Those of you who read the spoilers will find this list a little less than exciting, and more than a bit familiar. Those of you who don't can now go back and look at our "spoiler" posts, because not only do they feature plenty of video from the audition rounds, but other video and audio from outside of American Idol for many of the contestants as well. Brush up and pick out your favorites before the competition begins for real next week!
The Upfronts: FOX
Carter Bays of How I Met Your Mother: The TV Squad Interview
The Upfronts: CBS
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
2-13-2008 @ 11:19PM
SD said...
I don't know why but I'm really worried about Josiah (the homeless guy). I really felt like he was very lonely, vulnerable and lacked self-confidence. I kept thinking - he has nobody to talk to and no home to go to after this. Who's going to look out for him? I hope he can handle this rejection and doesn't get depressed.
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 3:07AM
vacelts said...
He has a home. He choses not to go there.
In the first audition, he talked about how he took off and didn't tell his parents that he was living in his car.
2-13-2008 @ 11:37PM
Oreo said...
Was the leaked list correct?
Reply
2-13-2008 @ 11:54PM
mrkorb said...
Yes.
2-13-2008 @ 11:44PM
dave said...
Josiah was the only reason to watch the show this year. Do you know how many rock stars lived in their cars before making it big? he needed the bump and a chance to grow. My family and I were all pulling for Josiah. We won't be watching Idol this season. ALL FLUFF....NO STUFF
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 12:30AM
stacey said...
I was crying when Josiah didn't make it. I wanted him to make it so bad. He has a great smile and is very talented. As a Mom I just wish I could adopt him and help him acheive his goals in music. He is the reason I watched tonight and I probably won't watch again until the end now. Josiah my thoughts are with you be strong.
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 1:13AM
Brian said...
Did anyone notice the HP ad that was embedded WITHIN an ad for Jumper. Then you have to see a stupid bottom third several times during the show advertising Jumper. ENOUGH WITH JUMPER! Even if critics said it was the best movie ever made, I wouldn't see it, just because I'm sick of seeing all the ads for it.
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 1:23AM
bbrown said...
I don't mean to sound rude or anything because I did feel sorry to see Josiah go but I can't help but think that if he had made it through even if he did really crappy he would just get so many sympathy votes that it almost wouldn't be fair to the other contestants. I wish him the best of luck and hope that something opens up for him after this and in the least is no longer homeless but I think the competition will be a little bit more fair this way at least.
Reply
2-15-2008 @ 2:05PM
ORKMommy said...
If you think Josiah would have gotten sympathy votes, how about Asia'H? Her dad died 2 days before her first audition!!
I loved Josiah, but he chose to live in his car and be on the road. Asia'H didn't choose to have her dad die in a car accident!
2-14-2008 @ 2:01AM
Giza said...
BBrown #7
While I can understand you sentiments, I would much rather a homeless kid following his dream got a chance (symapthy vote and all) than people who have had a chance and failed.
I know a lot of people feel he was an emotional wreck but anyone would be who lived in a car. It just left a bad taste and I couldn't even be happy for the ones who got through.
My daughter was very, very upset and I know that adults think teenagers voting ruined the show last year, but it is a talent show and it's teens who spend money.
I think I, like a couple of others here, just won't be watching this season.
The last few choices America has made have disapeared into the ether and I'm not sure that I saw any contestant tonight that would prompt my kids to watch. That to me is sad because we had a lot of fun previously watching the show.
I wish Simon would just have a show that concentrated on the teenage audience (with teen singers) then everyone who had apoplectic fits about Sanjaya last year could settle in watch AI and pick another predictable singer to win.
The teenagers (and many more, no doubt) could then watch a show that reflected their tastes and identities without being blamed for the downfall of Western society.
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 2:32AM
bbrown said...
I have to say I can not really disagree with you there. Sanjaya was about the worst thing that has happened to AI in my opinion. It's also a reason why I sometimes don't like them going into someones back story. If we hadn't known that he was homeless we would have just felt bad for the sweet kid who didn't quite cut it. I just really have a feeling that this won't be the last of anything for him and something will happen but that could just be optimism and hope that that he will have a Cinderella story as well.
2-14-2008 @ 3:10AM
vacelts said...
I was expected a truly boring hour and was pleasantly surprised. I even teared up on a few of them.
I will say that I think the way Paula draws it out is complete torture.
There seems to be an awful lot of talent in this group.
http://redlightnaps.wordpress.com/2008/02/14/american-idol-7-top-12-men/
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 3:10AM
Will said...
Can an non-Idol watcher comment here? OK, I watch sometimes but never until the top 24. I can't stand the audition and 'awful' singers they always make a couple shows out of. I know most people enjoy the auditions, but I don't. That said, I did enjoy the seasons that produced Carrie Underwood and Katherine McPhee. Last season was not very good, though. But, I may have to watch this season, if only because there's a girl from the very town I live in, and it's a relatively small town (10,-15000) population. Not that I know her or anything, but I am interested in seeing how she does.
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 6:32AM
domino said...
i have been watching idol since it started,, and that kid josiah was by far the most talent i have seen in any of these kids,,.. i think its sad that they didnt put him trough,, and he wouldnt of gottin sympathy votes, he would of got real voted from real fans,, anyways,, i was looking forward to watching this season for that kid,, but now,, who cares about it,,, i think simon was a little jelous that this kid would of became just as famous as he is after this season,,and simon wouldnt be able to live with that,, and randy, i never hate on no one,, but come on ''dog'',, like you know how to sing..lmfao,, even better,, you know how to dance right randy,,,what ever ,, i wish that kid luck and cowell and randy,, well,, just way way over paid for picking such untalented singers,..
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 7:27AM
shelli said...
I think I was a little shocked Josiah didn't make it, even though he did blow his last audition in Hollywood. He had talent and potential. Maybe next season?? I just HATE that people make it to the top 24 and I don't remember who they are. Why when editing did they not show us any of their auditions? They did with most of the others. Idol you have been on tv long enough to get this stuff right! I'll be watching this season for sure because I think this is a very talented group. I'm ready to start voting!!
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 8:38AM
Cougar Feather said...
This Josiah guy was just an imitation of all the music he likes. I saw nothing original. The British accent thing , total poser. It also became obvious he can't work with a band, and didn't even realize he wasn't keeping in time. He sings ok, nothing great. And his weird shoulder crunching thing gets old within 30 seconds.
He really need to get some help, he may be bi-polar or something. His parents should really track him down...if that story is even true or he just made it up to get the sympathy vote since he has heard stories of people making it big after living out of their car.
Reply
2-15-2008 @ 2:08PM
ORKMommy said...
It's not that he couldn't work with the band, he didn't get enough time to rehearse with the band! That's why he dismissed them. Get your facts straight before you go on a rant please!
2-14-2008 @ 9:14AM
Philip said...
This is not the first time we've seen Alexandrea Lushington or David Hernandez. She was featured at the Atlanta auditions, where she brought her whole family including great-grandmother ("Don't make me cry; they're taking pictures."). He was prominently featured on the first day of Hollywood week, where the judges praised his version of "Love the One You're With."
The others you mention, though, I don't recall seeing either. I think the producers do this because they need some fodder to get eliminated before they move to the top 12, so the REAL favourites have a better chance of making it.
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 9:28AM
Charlie Conner said...
two of the top 24 from Tulsa?
w00t!
Reply
2-14-2008 @ 9:47AM
Wintermute said...
I really liked what we saw of Josiah, but his "That took guts" comment was just bone-headed because it was a lie. He wasn't prepared and blew it. If I were one of the judges, that comment is what I would have remembered and would have prompted a "no" from me. Had he not made the comment, who knows? I think he needs to come back when he has a bit more experience.
Right now, Michael Johns is my favorite. His "Bohemian Rhapsody" was the best performance I think I've ever seen on Idol, and it's still auditions. I just hope he didn't peak too soon.
'mute
Reply