
(S04E02) Watching "Confirmed Dead" was like watching my dream episode of Lost. People asked direct questions for once, some of which were answered within the hour! This episode was all about the Freighties--their lives back on the mainland, their connections to Oceanic 815, and, to borrow a phrase, their "primary objective."
Flashback: The Freighties
Daniel Faraday
Naomi wasn't lying about the plane wreckage being discovered. We got to see it firsthand. The crew of the Christiane I found an Oceanic plane in the Sunda Trench, off the coast of Bali. Back in Essex, Massachusetts, Daniel Faraday cried and shook as he watched a news report about the discovery. A woman (she was wearing a wedding ring, so she could be his wife) asked him why he was so upset, and Daniel had no idea. I'm not sure which is more disturbing: the fact that someone might have staged the 815 wreckage, or that Daniel was so freaked out about the news footage. Moments before landing on the island, the Freighties' helicopter was out of control, and Miles threw a terrified Daniel out of the chopper.
Miles Straume
Apparently Miles was the go-to guy for ghostbusting in the Inglewood, California area. Like Daniel and the other Freighties, he took an interest in the Oceanic 815 story. Miles stayed in the car to hear the rest of a radio broadcast about 815 before going to his next house call. An elderly woman named Mrs. Gardner hired him to cleanse her home of her murdered grandson's spirit. After doubling his fee because of the cause of death, Miles and his completely bogus device went to work in the grandson's room. His gear was fake, but his supernatural gifts were legit. Miles has the ability to communicate with the dead, but he does so for a profit. The grandson's ghost led him to a paper bag filled with cash, which Miles pocketed. After forcing himself to say that the spirit was "at peace," he returned part of his fee to Mrs. Gardner. A selfish con man with a heart? That sounds familiar.
Charlotte Lewis
Charlotte's back story began in Medenine, Tunisia. The anthropologist was also fascinated by 815 news; she couldn't stop reading newspaper articles about the discovery. A very different discovery brought Charlotte to a dig out in the desert. Another group found the skeleton of a polar bear. After bribing a man to let her check out the remains, she found the bear's leather collar. The prominently-displayed DHARMA Hydra Station logo put a cryptic smile on her face.
Frank Lapidus
Before he flew the Freighties' helicopter, Frank was working for a tour company on Eleuthera in the Bahamas. A phone call to the NTSB Oceanic hotline revealed that Frank had a personal interest in the 815 discovery. He was positive that the body found in the cockpit of the wreckage was not Seth Norris (who we all saw get killed by the monster). Seth Norris always wore his wedding ring, and the body in the Sunda Trench didn't have one. Frank knew about Norris because he was supposed to be the pilot on Oceanic 815. We know Frank's Oceanic connection, but what about the rest of the Freighties? Why were they so affected by the 815 story? Perhaps we'll learn more in future episodes.
Naomi Dorrit and Matthew Abaddon
Is Matthew Abaddon the Ben Linus of the Freighties? He organized the Freighties' trip to the island, and Naomi was the designated team leader. She was less than impressed with her soon-to-be colleagues, whom she called a headcase, a ghostbuster, and anthropologist, and a drunk. Abaddon told her that the team members were selected for a reason, but didn't elaborate. Naomi's other major concern was the possibility of finding 815 survivors. Matthew angrily insisted that there were no survivors. Her job was to get in, get out, and make sure that no one got killed. I guess she dropped the ball on that last one.
Team Jack
Jack and Kate's first encounter with the Freighties wasn't very informative. Daniel "Mumbles" Faraday did everything he could to avoid giving the survivors a straight answer. He used Naomi's old satellite phone to contact Minkowski, who quickly asked to be taken off the speaker. Faraday told Jack and Kate about the Freighties' GPS transponders, but was not forthcoming about their biohazard equipment or the gun that he had. Before he could evade Jack's question about their mission, the phone picked up Miles' signal.
The trio found Miles on a rocky part of the island. He pretended to be unconscious until Jack got close, then he pulled a gun on him. Kate tried to grab Daniel's gun during the chaos, but got caught in the act. Remember when Naomi asked George to tell her sister she loved her? That was Freightie code; Naomi totally tipped them off about the survivors. Miles was convinced that the 815ers killed Naomi and demanded to see her body.
While Miles did his ghost whispering, Faraday was busying himself with more important matters, like how the light on the island didn't scatter properly. Thrilled to have another man on which to use her feminine wiles, Kate attempted to convince Daniel to put down his gun. Jack calmly told Kate to let things play out, which should have been enough of a signal. Miles was in for an unpleasant surprise. He ordered Jack and Kate to help them find Charlotte, but was ambushed by Sayid and Juliet instead.
Juliet and Sayid were worried when their leader didn't return to the beach, and turned up in the jungle just in time. Naturally, Kate was jealous that she wasn't in on the plan. Way to see the big picture, Kate. Meanwhile, Sayid put his interrogation skills to use. Miles was smart enough to lie about his profession, but Daniel willingly told Sayid that he was a physicist. A socially awkward physicist? I didn't know they existed. Funniest moment of the night goes to Miles, who feigned astonishment when Sayid asked him why he wasn't surprised to see 815 survivors. Suddenly, the phone picked up Charlotte's signal running toward them. It was really Vincent; Locke had put Charlotte's tracking device around the dog's neck.
Finally, the group caught up with Frank the helicopter pilot, still processing his run-in with the DHARMA cow. He told Miles that he successfully landed the chopper, which was welcome news for the 815ers. After yet another tense conversation, Miles got the satellite phone from Jack. I thought it was strange--and suspicious--that Regina (was that Zoe Bell?) answered and told Miles that Minkowski was unavailable. Why can Miles only talk to Minkowski? As Juliet was patching up Frank's head wound, he asked for her name. He instantly knew that Juliet was not an Oceanic 815 survivor. Suddenly, Juliet had all of the Freighties' attention. Miles charged over to Juliet and asked her where "he" was. They came to the island for one person: Benjamin Linus.
Team Locke
Locke decided to take a little detour on the way to the Barracks. The itinerary included at stop at Jacob's cabin, which confused Hurley. He thought the cabin was back in the other direction. I'm worried about Hurley's safety now. Both Ben and Locke gave Hurley the crazy eye after he said that. Locke explained to Sawyer that he's taking orders from Walt now. At least he looked like Walt--only taller. Sawyer's response: "Taller? What, like a giant?" When Walt saved John's life back in last season's finale, he told him to stop Naomi and the Freighties from coming to the island. Sawyer's equally funny response: "You didn't ask any follow-up questions?" Locke explained that Ben had just shot him, so he was a bit disoriented. Luckily, John's traumatic past worked in his favor. The bullet passed through his body; he'd be dead if his father hadn't stolen his kidney all those years ago.
If Ben kills anyone this season, please let it be Karl. Karl foolishly tried to intimidate Ben with a gun when he tried to speak to Alex. Talk about sending a boy to do a man's job. Ben looked almost bored when he was messing with him. He got a more challenging target when Sawyer stepped in to subdue Karl. He told James that he'd never compare to Jack in the real world, and tried to make him jealous of Kate's alliance with Jack. Fed up with Ben's manipulation, Sawyer asked Locke why they were keeping him alive. Locke admitted that he needed Ben's knowledge of the island, and that apart from his mouth he wasn't dangerous. Say what? Sawyer knew better: he said that Ben probably had a plan to get rid of Team Locke, and that a double-cross was inevitable.
The group found Charlotte after she freed herself from her parachute and fell into a pond. It took her a long time to catch on to the 815ers' cold reaction to being rescued. Locke finally spelled things out for her: the Freighties' "rescue efforts" were unwelcome. Charlotte became angry when the survivors prevented her from following Frank's flare. She insisted on leaving, but Ben had other ideas. He stole Karl's gun and shot her in the chest. Someone just lost their gun privileges. I thought it was pretty hard core of the writers to give a character an flashback and kill her off in the same episode, but it was not to be. Charlotte was wearing a bulletproof vest.
This didn't stop Sawyer from wanting to kill Ben on the spot. Locke was ready to kill him too but wanted to question Ben first. He asked him straight out: "What is the monster?" If anyone knows the answer to this, it's Ben, but he was willing to take that secret his grave. He turned things around on everyone, though, when he recited Charlotte's name, profession, and personal history. He told Locke that he knows the Freighties' identities for two reasons: they came here for him, and he has a man on their boat. Well played, Mr. Linus.
I liked this episode even more than the season premiere. There were so many big revelations, and I loved watching Ben gain the upper hand--again. Jeff Fahey has already won me over--Frank is my favorite Freightie so far. Kudos to the writers for being brave enough to introduce new characters after the whole Nikki and Paulo thing. I'm already eager to learn more about the island's newest batch of villains.
Other questions/points of interest:
-
The Christiane I and the Sunda Trench were both mentioned on the Find 815 website.
-
The name Rick Lapidus appears in the Exposé script.
-
"Eleuthera" is Greek for "free."
-
Taller Ghost Walt is my next fantasy team name.
-
In Daniel's flashback, why didn't they show the woman's face? It's odd that they would cast the character and not show her face. Will we learn her identity at some point?
-
Sawyer might have competition for the job of island nickname-giver. Miles called Daniel Faraday "Genius" when he tossed him out of the helicopter, and called Jack "Handsome" when he pulled a gun on him.
-
Why did Naomi have a photo of Desmond while Miles had one of Ben? What does Desmond have to do with their mission?
-
I could kiss Locke for asking Ben about the monster.
-
My favorite evasive comment from Daniel Faraday: "I'm not in charge of packing."
-
TV Guide's Ausiello thought the episode was brought down by two things: Claire's lack of grief over Charlie and Jack's failure to follow up with Faraday about why the Freighties were there (they were interrupted by the phone call). Are these fair criticisms?
-
Another Lost-Star Wars connection: the Tatooine scenes from Episode IV: A New Hope were filmed in the Tunisian desert.
Next week--another member of the Oceanic Six is revealed. In the meantime, feel free to check out AOL's Lost coverage.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
2-08-2008 @ 12:24AM
Ryan said...
I'm a little bit in love with this episode for everything you said and just because the new characters ARE so interesting. I feel like I know (and care for them) already! THIS is the way to introduce new characters.
This season is going to be epic if this keeps up.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 12:27AM
froggirl said...
wow, Great episode!
I loved Dan's lame responses to all the info Jack was trying to get out of him. And why did he freak out so much on hearing about the plane being found? Does he have some special psychic ability like Miles?
Taller Ghost Walt. Awesome.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 12:30AM
Caroline said...
I really don't think Ben knew about the monster. Locke asked him the one question about the island that he couldn't answer. Remember when the monster chased Juliet and Kate in "Left Behind?" Juliet had never seen it before (not that she's been on the island that long anyway) and it kind of scanned her with some light which it had never done before? Not really sure what that meant but I think the others have never seen it before.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 1:51AM
SImpression said...
Yes Juliet said that, but later when she orders Kate to get behind the Sonar fence she says "We don't know what it is, but we know it doesn't like our fences" implying that she HAD seen it before or atleast knew about.
The producers have also hinted that Juliet might not have been letting on about how much she knew (which she did ALL episode).
I think the Others know more about it than they say (especially when you consider the fact that they traveled all over the island to terroize our Losties in the first few seasons, they were bound to find it atleast once.)
2-08-2008 @ 12:51PM
Clint said...
Could Ben's "man on the boat" be Michael? I know it was possible he could return this season, and didn't Ben tell him when he left the island to go a certain direction and he would find a ship?
Someone refresh my memory.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 12:37AM
Oreo said...
Ben doesn't know what the smoke monster is because the writers don't. :)
And did they come up with a deal in the writers strike yet?
Awesome episodes. Episodes like this I don't care that we got no real answers.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 2:05AM
SImpression said...
I think Ben was just covering up.
And i think it was for obvious reasons, he was hoping for Locke to ask him about the freighties so he could show how much he knew about them, so he could get people to believe him more. This is why after Locke is disappointed about the Black Monster not being revealed, Ben just spills out details about Charlotte.
I'm pretty sure the writers know though, i mean, i am one of those people who thinks that they don't just "make things up" all the time. They would think out the Monster well before they put it in. But hmm... and here i was hoping that we would see it! With the way Hurley said it in the episode it made me think that they DID pass by it on their way to Jacob's Cabin we just didn't get to see it, tis a shame. I miss old smokey!
2-08-2008 @ 12:49AM
Chuck said...
Was it just me, or did the woman talking to Daniel in his apartment call him "Sam?"
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 1:52AM
SImpression said...
oh my god. I thought i was the ONLY one who thought this too! I thought she called him Sam too and i was like "Is he supposed to be Sam Thomas? (from Find815)" I think i need to rewatch the episode!
2-08-2008 @ 2:50AM
Steve said...
Just rewatched the episode - she says "Dan" :)
2-08-2008 @ 1:03AM
Noah said...
AMAZING - The hydra logo in the desert, Hurley mentioning he saw the cabin, Patchy's cow, and Sayid + Juliet surprise attack - This episode was a classic suspense filled puppy - I agree with Oreo, with episodes like this we don't have to get answers to be entertained
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 1:19AM
hope salazar said...
im curious to know who kate was talking about when she said he will be wondering where im at when her and jack where at air base.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 1:29AM
Jake said...
So, here are some elephant in the room questions?
How do these people know 815 even crashed on the Island?
Why are these people concerned (Naomi included) about the 815ers being on the Island if they are in fact there to find Ben Linus?
Why are these particular people going to the island instead of some kick ass swat team comprised of all Naomi types?
Why do these people have a seemingly emotional interest in Flight 815 if they are all there to find/capture Ben?
Were the gas masks for the "sickness" on the Island or were they planning to gas Ben and the others if they found them?
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 1:59AM
SImpression said...
My Guesses to your questions (sorry i'm in a posting mood!)
-Because Jack told them so? lol. I believe that this is all a big cover up, and that they really do want the island (and Ben i suppose). Since they knew that the flight was lost maybe they just assumed? OR (my guess) is that Michael went back and told them about the crash, and then they went to go there. Just guessing though.
-Most likely because they (or their superiors) covered up Oceanic Flight 815 to keep people away from the island. Thus they are worried about the survivors because if they brought them back it would mean that their fake-out was indeed... fake. And it would be a problem.
-Same reason that Locke said that the island brought them (the survivors) to the island? Fate? But other than that wild guess, i have no clue. I suppose we will find out once the story unfolds more.
-Maybe people they knew were on the plane (not such a stress) and while they are there for Ben, they were told that it was the real crash site? No idea, but it is compelling no?
-I'm definitely going towards them gassing the island or what not. I mean if it really was "the sickness" (which i think was just a hoax, like Quarantine was and like Desmond said) they would have been in more of a rush to strap on one of those babies. So i'm guessing gasing :O
What are your personal thoughts/guesses to your question?
2-08-2008 @ 1:46AM
Dan Buckley said...
We know that the freighties are not with Penny. Charlotte Lewis knows something of/about DHARMA. I think that the freighties might be connected with DHARMA. We haven't heard of any contact from them since the purge. Perhaps they have been trying to find the island since then and have been unable to until the button wasn't pushed and the fail safe was activated enabling Penny to see the island and perhaps DHARMA also. So DHARMA through Matthew Abaddon has hired these people to go in and get Ben because of his role in the purge.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 2:01AM
SImpression said...
But Ben wasn't the only DHARMA person that crossed over, so you'd think that they would be looking for more than just him?
But hmm, maybe that is so. Though i dont know if i like the idea of them being DHARMA, but it does make sense... Hmm. Well.... yeah.... next ep, woot!
2-08-2008 @ 2:10PM
ac said...
I agree I had the Dharma theory as well. Why else would someone want to get at Ben so bad? He let the Natives in and kill everyone in their base.
Oh and to the reviewer killing a character off after her flashback would've been hardcare if Lost didn't do every freakin time someone dies!
Great episode too bad there wasn't a Lost live chat on here for this one. MUCH better than the premire which I felt was dragging the whole time.
2-08-2008 @ 1:49AM
Ryan said...
Anyone catch Charlotte's full name: Charlotte Staples Lewis. Reference to Clive Staples Lewis, better known as CS Lewis, author of The Chronicles of Narnia series and noted Christian apologist.
Reply
2-08-2008 @ 2:06AM
SImpression said...
Yup. But i actually knew about that before the episode aired so i guess it doesn't really count, lol.
2-08-2008 @ 2:17AM
bruce said...
There was more than gasmasks in that crate, there was dangerous stuff with biohazard warning labels on it. Gasmasks are not biohazards, they protect from biohazards. Clearly these people are planning on releasing chemical/biological weapons to kill others/Others and Ben. Actually it's not clear if they want ben dead or alive, though when Abaddon asked Hurley "is he still alive?" it seems clear he was referring to Ben Linus, and wanted assurances that Ben was dead. He wasn't upset that they didn't have him in their custody, so far as I could tell.
Reply