TVSquad

These have really disturbed me... I think if they were more tastefully done they would have a better result... it's like i'm watching public tv's version of Saw.

Reply

We need to see these ! We need to be more aware of safety measures, not only on the job, but also at home.

Reply

These ads are just stupid.

The reality is that people become careless at work because they get complacent to the point where they are willing to take a risk. But that doesn't mean they forget that bad things can happen or that they don't know what specific bad things can happen.

Since they already know the bad things that can happen and just choose to take the chance out of laziness there's no point in being gratuitous in showing it.

Don’t get me wrong, I have no problem with reminding people to be careful but the idea that making it a horror show is going to do any good is just ridiculous. Further, this type of thing could easily give little kids nightmares which is all the more reason not to show them on public TV.

Reply

These ads are excellent and there should be more like them.

Tom, kids are the focus of these ads. You show them a talking apple and they'll roll their eyes, but if you show them this, not only are they going to remember it, they're going to tell their friends to watch it too.

MSN lists were buzzing when the Soup Chef ad hit Youtube. It was gross and horrifying and EFFECTIVE.

I dont want to see cartoon animals on skateboards. That's stupid. And so is anyone that thinks that longwinded lectures are going to get through to anyone.

30 seconds. Make your point. Make people talk. These PSAs are perfect.

Reply

Tim,

Kids aren't the focus of these ads. Workers are the focus. Most of these situations a kid wouldn't even find themselves in since they are all dealing with the workplace environment.

If they were kid focused, they would have someone with a bleeding head and twisted bike explaining why he should have worn a helmet or some other situation a kid would find him/herself in.


Tom-

The ads seem to evenly place blame on both worker complacency and employer negligence. Whether one finds these ads morbid or morbidly humorous, they are getting attention and people are talking about them.

Reply

All I gotta say is... Damn! I need to show these to my co-workers in my next training class.

Reply

If nothing else, I can definitely see the ads making workers more willing to question the safety of jobs they're asked to do, even if it's just to have someone else on hand to help them out.

Reply

These ads are important. Workers and employers become lazy, complacent, and damn near reckless. Unfortunately small violations become big accidents. Do accidents happen all the time? No, however prevention is never a bad thing.

Reply

Oo, those are pretty brutal.

I wonder how effective they are with multiple viewings, however?

Reply

I think that the last two are more disturbing (and thus more effective) because the actors talk about the "accident" they're going to be in just before it happens -- and indeed their words are interrupted by their being killed.

Reply

I've been seeing these ads on a regular basis for months now. At first they were shocking and some what disturbing but now not so much. I don't think children should be seeing theses ads, as it might give them nightmares.

Reply

Forget about KIDS getting nightmares - I'm a 32-year-old man and these ads scare the heck out of me. I've only seen the disgusting one with the chef getting burned by the oil once, but that was more than enough for me. Now whenever I'm watching TV and one of these ads come on, I can't switch the channel fast enough.

It's not quite as easy to escape the ubiquitous print ads everywhere, though, including graphic images of dead bodies in newspapers ads, in posters in bus shelters, etc. Enough already!

Reply

I personally prefer the Nova Scotian one's better. They're all clever with the whole "first we show them just talking, and then the camera zooms out and Surprise! They're about to die or one of there limbs has been chopped off or they're being crushed under something!"

But yes, I've noticed that here in Canada we have more "darkness" in our adverts, but we also have less aggression in them than the "United Statesians" do, so I guess its sort of a trade off.

Reply

The grease fryer one was the most disturbing!

Reply

That one with the chef was, excuse my language, fucked up. There is no other way to describe it.

Reply

I'm all for allowing these commercials and think they are important. I do evaluations (psych) on people following work related injuries and it is a hard world to work in.

I have to admit though the oil commercial made my stomach curl. But having been around after the fact on these people need to start thinking twice about things. I actually cleaned up a spill in my own home a bit faster the other day as a result!

I appreciate that they show them after 9pm here though to avoid children from seeing them.

Reply

Only in Canada could they show such brutality on TV...

Reply

I'm a bit surprised by the reaction to these on TVSquad. While they may not be appropriate, relevant, or informative, I can't stop laughing. I know I'm pretty messed up, but I thought they were hilarious. Regardless, I don't see those ads succeeding at anything.

Reply