(S14E10) "If we keep this thing cranking, we could hit 300. That's quite a milestone." -- Dr. Archie Morris
So, 300 episodes.
No clip show, no big fanfare, no super-humongo guest star (even though Peter Fonda is fairly big). Other than the promos mentioning that it was ER's 300th episode there really wasn't much differing it from episode 159, episode 52, or episode 1.
There were still patients that made us cry a little, doctors that made us laugh, and continuing dramas that, hopefully, came to an end so we didn't end up reaching into the screen and strangling the person causing all of the drama in the first place because she had a chip on her shoulder the size of Mt. Rushmore! Ahem. Like I said...business as usual at County General.
Let's begin with drama queen Abby. My Lord, she was totally pissing me off with her holier than thou attitude against everyone. I just could not take it anymore. It's one thing to have a drinking problem, but it's another to yell at a friend concerned about your drinking problem in the apartment that she pays rent on. Abby had no right to do that, even if she was angry at herself for the way she acted.
I was so glad that Julia's little story finally put a chink into Abby's armor big enough to finally admit to Luka that she had a problem. And, once she opened up she really opened up. I was quite surprised that she let her little one-nighter with Moretti come out, even if it wasn't spoken to Luka. It was pretty much implied that she was unfaithful to her husband.
Now, she is off to a rehab center to get better. What this means for her character I'm unsure about. Maura Tierney has said in previous interviews that this season of ER would be her last. To me, this seemed like her swan song. This wouldn't be shocking to me since the show has let go of plenty of characters without a huge send-off. Frankly, I think I need more closure to the whole Abby-Luka-Joe story. However, if this was Tierney's last episode I'd be okay with it.
That's because the rest of the cast can hold up on its own without Abby's actions. All of the main characters -- Archie, Sam, Greg, Tony, Frank, Neela -- have done just fine without Abby and Luka hogging up the screen. I don't feel that anything is missing when neither of them are there, unlike when Ross or Susan or Greene left the show. If anything, Abby and Luka's absences have allowed the other characters to grow a good bit.
Take Sam, for instance. This season Ms. Taggart has taken quite a leap in her adulthood, becoming more responsible and ambitious. Being part of the transfer program and learning all of those new skills has really given her some new found respect in the eyes of her colleagues. Now, all she needs to do is bring home her son. You remember him, don't you? He's the pyromaniac who's holed up in a boarding school.
Another example is Tony. Since his journey into ICU, Gates has become a better emergency room doctor. Yes, he still has a tendency to knock people down to the ground, like he did this week, but those instances are few and far between. That could also be the result of Julia as well as Sarah.
Speaking about Julia, I had mixed feelings about her memorial ceremony. At first, I found the whole story a bit hokey and a ploy just to get the character more screen time. However, as the patient memorial progressed, and the memories of past patients flashed across the doctor's minds, I found the scene touching. I kind of wished that some of the original cast were there in the break room to see what patient they were influenced by the most. I'm guessing that Greene's would have been the pregnant lady who he pretty much killed in the first season, while Susan's would have been Ben Hollander (Bob Newhart).
The big story this week featured guest star Peter Fonda, who definitely looks a bit like his father. Honestly, I didn't find his performance that enthralling. In fact, I found his acting a bit dull. I think you could have hired any number of other actors who could have done a better job. On the other hand, the boy who played Lowell was very good in his portrayal of a son who gained one parent and lost another.
Well, another show ends for 2007. If the writers' strike continues through the winter we may only have a few more new episodes until ER runs dry in February. So, until that time, have a happy non-denominational holiday season.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-07-2007 @ 7:05AM
Larue said...
I liked the understated performance of everyone. I was expecting...heh...NEEDING....a hug or something from Abby/Luka though. That was sad. Agreed about Peter Fonda, but his character had already come to terms with the wife's DNR status. Maybe a little more shock or something when encountering his son for the first time?? Also agreed that the memorial thing was better than I expected it to be. Nice way to reaffirm our doctors.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 9:17AM
Junyo said...
Other than being Henry Fonda's son, Bridget's dad and "Easy Rider", is Peter Fonda known for being a great actor?
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 11:00AM
max said...
I was pleased to see Abby's character so well written. Typical alcoholic behaviour and not the fairy tale that is so often portrayed. It's painful, rude, surly and attacking someone who is trying to help you with something so cruel is just par for the course. The fact that the reviewer doesn't know this also quite wonderful.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 12:54PM
Mrtine said...
are you kidding ER without Abby? Well it would be just crap. Neela is good; Sam? Just another Abby wanting to become better, why can't a nurse just want to be a nurse? ER needs a newer idea
12-07-2007 @ 2:28PM
ORKMommy said...
Abby became a doctor & Sam wants to get into medical transport. Why is it so horrible that these nurses want to further their careers and become something other than nurses? Nobody says anything when a peon wants to get into management...or a software tester wants to get into programming. There's nothing wrong with being a nurse, but sometimes a career change is just what a person needs to bring some spice back into their life.
p.s. Carol Hathaway remained a nurse until the very end.
12-07-2007 @ 1:08PM
Robobagins said...
I felt cheated by this episode, where were the 300 patients? They started the episode off at what, 148? I was expecting Country General to be swamped, you know a train accident, plane crash, something! But it was a business as usual it seemed. An okay episode, but not worth the build up.
Reply
12-12-2007 @ 12:57PM
ven said...
I've watched off and on over the years, but I was struck by the actor who played Peter Fonda's son. He seemed to put out more emotion, with as few words, as Mr. Fonda.
It's nice to see someone so abled to do the job, without getting an actor of regular ability to play the role.
Good for ER!!
Reply
12-19-2007 @ 11:19AM
nymphetamine girl said...
hahaa
i really love this episode
its want of the best.......
Luby its really cooL..
i also like sam´s participation, was great when she hits the poor man.
i think she and gates are going to have a relationship in the future..
Reply