
(S02E09) "You've gone native. Are you kidding me?" Noah Bennet to Mohinder Suresh.
Just when you thought Mohinder couldn't get any stupider, he goes and shoots Noah Bennet in the eye. He is really in too deep with this company. And lately, he is making Matt Parkman look like a genius. (Wait, did Parkman just make me say that? Dumb joke, I know.) More on this after the jump because it basically took up the whole episode.
But before I go through all the storylines for this week, let me just say that I was so relieved that those ridiculous mascara-plague twins were absent from this week's Heroes. And just so I don't get too excited about it, I put a picture of them in the post to remind me that they are still on the show. (However, they are the vehicle to get the devilish Sylar back in the states so I suppose I forgive them on some level.)
Claire Bennet, Noah Bennet (H.R.G.), and West
We begin in Costa Verde, CA. We spend most of the episode there in fact. The Bennets are getting ready to skip town but as Claire told her father before, she's not going with them. Citing West as an example, she confronts her father about the bad things he did as a soldier of the company. This conversation could have benefited from a rewrite, I think. When Noah picks up the tape like he's going to tie Claire up, I thought, that's a little over the top.
Claire leaves to find West (by spelling out S-O-R-R-Y with rocks). She tells him about the fight and how she's staying in Costa Verde for him but he doesn't believe her (teen drama alert!). West leaves because he says he needs time to figure things out. He thinks Claire and her father are working together.
Meanwhile, Noah has some explaining to do to his wife who witnessed the verbal altercation (duct tape and all). He shows his wife the future paintings. She doesn't really get it--no big surprise there. Then he leaves to go find Claire and West sweeps him into the air. This air assault was a cool Heroes moment I must admit (a great shot right before a commercial).
West interrogates Noah in the air to find out about Claire's involvement with him. I liked how they ended up working together to save Claire. I like West's character. I know lots of people hate him but I don't see why. He's not that annoying (not like those twins).
Mohinder Suresh, Bob & Elle
Mohinder, Bob and Elle go to Southern California for two reasons: to get Claire's blood and to kill Noah Bennet. Bob tries to convince Mohinder that Noah is a threat and should be "taken out" but Mohinder is skeptical about killing him (always wanting to do the right thing and the least harm). He does agree that Claire's blood is needed to cure Niki though.
Elle always wants to kill Noah (two reasons again: it's the logical thing to do from her and her father's perspective and she's slightly unhinged so she takes pleasure in killing people). But Mohinder persuades them both to follow his plan. After Noah calls looking for Molly's help to find West, Mohinder calls back with a fake location. Of course, Noah is with West at the time so he's knows it's a bluff.
While Mohinder and Elle go to meet Noah (and West), Bob goes to abduct Claire. Did he really fudge her name when he spoke to her on the football field? I couldn't tell if that was an honest mistake only because Bob doesn't look like the kind of guy that makes mistakes. Either way, Bob follows Claire home and kidnaps her at gunpoint.
Mohinder thinks that he's got Noah under control (and if he doesn't Elle will zap him). But, it's a bird, it's a plane, it's a flying teenager come to clothesline the electricity girl. By the way, West is getting good at swooping people off the ground.
Noah vs. Bob, The Showdown
Now Bob has Claire and Noah has Elle. Was it just me or did you kind of enjoy Elle getting a taste of the pain she so easily inflicts on everyone else? What an easy way to contain her too. Why didn't they just keep her clothes and hair wet for the exchange? A dry Elle is a super-charged, super-pissed off Elle.
The exchange is going pretty smoothly when Elle zaps West (who is holding Claire) out of the air. Noah then shoots Elle in the arm. I thought he was a better shot than that. Noah is about to shoot Bob but Mohinder shoots him in the eyeball. Right in the eyeball. And when did the genetics doctor learn how to aim a gun?
I actually thought they were going to kill someone off for real this time. But no, Noah is back by virtue of Claire's blood with a new eyeball. I wonder if he will still need glasses?
Parkman & Molly
Matt Parkman is becoming his father. I was wondering if they were going to draw out this transition for another episode but I guess not. Parkman first uses his powers to persuade Molly to be a normal girl after she offers to help him find the rest of the people in the picture. The look on his face shows that he's a little surprised with and even scared of his new, improved ability.
Then he uses his power on his boss and sees that it can be very advantageous to control other people's thoughts. What would Professor Xavier think? A little unethical if you ask me. Ethics aside, he gets more time to investigate Kaito Nakamura's death and interview Angela Petrelli.
Parkman then has a battle of the mind powers with Angela who accuses him of turning into his father and scolds him for meddling in the business of her generation. After suffering a Parkman headache and a bloody nose, she gives up the last name in the picture.
I wonder if Parkman will turn into a villain with his evolved power. I think it's cliche to have him turn into his dad. However, the "new nightmare man" could make for an interesting situation with Molly. But, from what we know of Parkman's character (meek, righteous, caring, not so sharp), I don't think it makes sense for him to exploit his power the way his father did.
Hiro
It was nice to see Hiro get some closure and a new mission this episode. We first see him at his father's funeral but he refuses to give the eulogy and tells Ando he is going back in time to save his father. However, when he gets there, Kaito Nakamura, a man who believes in fate, turns down the opportunity to save his own life.
In an effort to convince his father to live, Hiro takes him back to the funeral of his wife/Hiro's mother. I thought maybe Kaito would concede and allow his son to alter time to rescue him at this point. But, alas, no, he is really dead (maybe they will bring him back...like D.L. and then kill him again...like D.L.).
Hiro talks to his younger self and in effect teaches himself his father's lesson. Finally, his father's words make sense to Hiro: "We have the power of the gods. That doesn't mean we can play God." While Hiro doesn't "play God" and save his father, he does use his power to uncover who murdered him: Kensei. I like that Hiro's vendetta against Kensei will create trouble in his relationship with Peter Petrelli. They have worked on the same side before but how will Adam/Kensei affect things?
Final Thoughts:
* Everyone saw it coming but I like that it's confirmed that Claire's blood can heal people. I can't wait for more showdown scenes with her and Elle next week.
* I know this is completely nerdy but did anyone catch the title of the episode's reference to The Canterbury Tales? I haven't given it much thought other than that they sound awfully similar. Nothing in the episode struck me as particularly Chaucerian though.
* Where was Peter? I need a little Petrelli each episode (and Mama Petrelli just won't do). Even the elder Petrelli would have done just fine. All we got was a reference to him by Claire's mother. She said that girls always look for their father in their boyfriends. Noah alluded to the coincidence of Nathan and West both being able to fly.
* I liked Hiro's eulogy at the end and how his speech correlated to shots of different characters (i.e. Mohinder looking at the gun and probably thinking about what his father would think of what happened; Elle looking at Bob with the new information about what he did to her as a young girl).










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
11-20-2007 @ 10:15AM
Adam said...
This was a ridiculously good episode, and now I really am sad about the writers' strike. The pacing was good and for once West actually served a purpose. I also loved the fact they both killed and kept HRG. I hated the character in season 1, but his moral ambiguity has made him the most bad ass character on the show.
In response to the poll question, its gotta be Micah. He could just access DARPA an go to work on entire nations!!
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:19AM
vacelts said...
Where was the Haitian during the whole Bennett/Company showdow? He disappears at the most inopportune moments. His powers could have been useful to suppress Elle, although I liked the bucket of water myself. It gave her a taste of her own medicine.
http://redlightnaps.wordpress.com/2007/11/20/heroes-cautionary-tales/
Could we finally have a power where we seen the holder in a moral dilemma about how and when to use. I mean first Matt uses the power to get Molly to eat her cereal – innocent enough. Then he uses it to make his boss give him more time on the Kaito case. And finally he uses it to withdraw secrets from Angela’s mind. Has Matt crossed a line?
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:22AM
JT said...
What? Nothing about the contrast between Hiro's story and HRG's? With how Hiro learned it's not good to use the power to become like gods and bring people back from the dead, while HRG was then brought back from death?
And who brought him back, anyway? Was it Bob and/or Mohinder using Claire's blood? Or did Adam somehow follow what was going on, and use his own blood to revive him? My money is on Adam, since he's the immortal one playing god here.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:31AM
Kevinc said...
Why are you assuming it is Claire blood? I figured it was Adam's. Why would the company kill Noah, then bring him back? Claire has no idea her blood works for other people! Did I miss something?
Why did they bring Noah back last night and not wait for the next episode? Seemed rushed.
Peter is by far the most powerful. Then Hiro, unless/until Sylar gets the timetravel power.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:40AM
LR said...
I'm really disliking the character of Elle, and I place the blame on the person they cast. She's all wrong for the part. I'm not totally sure if it's a thankless role or she simply can't act. Smiling through your scenes in NOT acting.
The only scene in the entire series so far, involving Elle that I liked, was when she was tied up, and had her feet in water, when she tried to shock someone else.
As far as Heroes, this episode did little for me until the very end. Several of my friends have given up on the show, but I'm willing to let this season play out before I make up my mind.
For one, Claire was acting like a brat in the beginning and not using any common sense. ...We have to leave because we've been compromised , but first, go to school. The whole storyline with the boyfriend seems a little forced.
HRG continues to intrigue. There's something about him that's oddly compelling. Just like Parkman, as he gains new ability.
I'm not sure where they're going with Suresh, but his whole storyline has become dull and seems totally out of character. Outside of Elle, I'm hoping his character leaves she show along with the twins. Maybe they can all take a roadtrip with Sylar.
What's up with Parkman's mother? I'm kinda interested in what she knows.
And Hiro, I'm just glad he's back.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:42AM
Will said...
The best episode of last season was an HRG episode (Company Man). Looks like it could be the same way this season.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:45AM
Shaun said...
I would assume it's Claire blood, because I am sure that she would be much more willing to cooperate when she sees that her blood brought back her dear old daddy.
While I thought, it was pretty clear that Noah would be saved, I agree that they should have kept some suspense for the audience. Maybe they wanted to have the harken back to the end of a Season 1 episode where Claire wakes up on the autopsy table.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:50AM
Cody said...
I didn't so much like the development with HRG being brought back to life. The writers of this show have now pretty much made it canon that no character can ever be permanently dead now. I don't like the fact that the Heroes universe now has a way to bring back any character they want for any reason.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 10:53AM
Monica said...
I couldn't stand last night's episode! I was yelling at the tv, pleading with it to end!
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:02AM
Murwynn said...
I thought that during the first noah vs elle showdown that we were about to find out if noah has some power of his own. It almost seemed as if elle paused/hesitated and had a somewhat confused look on her face ... it was long enough that it gave west a chance to tackle her...
anyhow ... kristen bell's character has not lived up to my expectations ... i think i like her a lot better as veronica mars ... will some other network PLEASE pick up that frackin' show!
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:08AM
rob said...
I liked that they brought Noah back. My bet is that Bob revived Noah with Claire's blood so that Bob can gain some trust alliance with Noah for the future. It seems Bob is kinda legit in his motivations. At least he's consistent. And Noah is strong. Bob could use Noah.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:09AM
Kevin Conroy said...
WHY DIDN'T YOU PUT THE SPOILERS BELOW THE FOLD WITH A WARNING?!?!
There's this magical device called TiVo that a few of us have, and we'd prefer not to know things like, oh say, who shots HRG before we've seen the episode.
You guys are really close to getting pulled from my blog roll if you keep up this sort of crap.
Thank you.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:10AM
RCP said...
I never saw Mrs. Petrelli give Parkman the final name--in fact, it appeared to me as if Parkman gave up and still didn't have the final name at the end of the episode.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:24AM
Cody said...
@13 RCP: the final name was on a postit attached to the photo he was looking at near the end, leading me to believe that he had gotten it from Angela. It was something "Pratt" I think.
@12 Kevin Conroy: not your blog roll! Anything but that!
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:25AM
khamel said...
EASILY the best episode of the season. HRG is the best character (power or no power) so there was no way he would be killed off. the twins are going to be a vehicle for the virus spreading as well. just putting that out there. there is no other reason for them to exist. somehow the girl will get the virus in her, go all black eyes and "transmit" it to everyone else. sylar will kill the brother (i hope) and after she starts the spread she will die but sylar will still have the power her power but not his.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:27AM
Fred Mertz said...
Parkman had the name written on the photo at the end of the episode. Also -- Mr. Conroy, the entire site is filled with spoiler reviews. They show already aired -- don't read a review if you don't want a spoiler. This isn't the movies.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:33AM
Oneiroi said...
I keep waiting for Mohinder to be a worthwhile character, to do one simple good thing...and all he seems to do is mess up or fail. It's been two seasons of this.
I originally expected him to band everyone together like a team of xmen, but instead...he just seems to be a wasted character.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:35AM
Ron Whitlock said...
I like the episode. Period. But, I have to add, I am glad they are wrapping up this story line in a few episodes. Waiting for the strike to end to get to the "finale" would be murder.
Mr. Conroy: if you don't want to hear any spoilers, then don't read an article about a show you like until you watch your TIVO'd version.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:41AM
Kristin Sample said...
@Conroy: Sorry the post spoiled anything for you but all the episode reviews here assume that the readers have seen the show. We have "Spoilers Anonymous" which is exactly that and does take care to put all spoilers after the jump.
@everyone else: The name on the post-it note was Victoria Pratt. I apologize for not putting this in the post itself.
Reply
11-20-2007 @ 11:44AM
John Howard said...
When I don't watch something on time, I figure it's up to me to avoid spoilers, not up to the rest of the world to avoid talking about things that it's perfectly reasonable for them to be talking about. But I guess that's just me.
Reply