(S15E09) Whatever you do, don't eat the apple. Eat the fried chicken, the mashed potatoes, the cheeseburgers, and the fries. You can even quaff the beer. But you know what happens when you eat the apple.As expected, the biblical words of wisdom came from James. But to whom was he referring? A lot must be happening behind the scenes with the quasi-couplings going on. Must we be like the Letterman question?
"Was there any hanky-panky going on?"
I didn't find this the most exciting of episodes although the challenges weren't reruns of previous seasons. There were the typical after Tribal Council rumblings. Denise felt blindsided by the vote to oust Jean-Robert. Courtney and Amanda knew she felt blindsided. Denise tried to work her way back in with James. James made the decision he'll never go to Tribal Council again without his treasured immunity idols. After all, he got three votes he didn't expect. He should expect that people will come gunning for him sooner or later.
James, in a way, isn't doing much to help his own case. Peih-Gee tried to talk to him and he went on the defensive a bit too much. Now, if I were in his shoes (which so wouldn't fit), I think I'd just nod my head a lot at her. While she made a dirty move with the kidnapping and throwing the challenge in Zhan Hu, you never know. Why deliberately be so argumentative? Why not only burn the bridge, but dynamite it as well? I like James, but he's getting way too smug. That can bite him in the butt if he doesn't watch it. I see Todd sees it.
Tree mail came with a drum and it was a foretelling of the rewards challenge. Instead of banging the drum slowly, it was walk and bounce a ball on it while going through obstacles slowly.It was yet another schoolyard pick followed by rock, paper, scissors to decide which team would go first. Jeff appointed Erik and Peih-Gee as the "captains" and gave them first pick. I was so glad that Courtney was the last pick instead of Denise once again. I hate schoolyard picks.
Peih-Gee jumped right on James despite their words. She had told us in confessional how much she wanted to win something ... anything.
Ah, but it was not to be. The yellow team of Erik, Frosti, Amanda and Courtney really got a rhythm going with the bouncing ball. Or, should I say Erik and Frosti did as they did most of the work. The red team -- Peih-Gee, James, Todd, and Denise really never caught any kind of rhythm with the ball at all.
Although Peih-Gee later lit into James claiming he threw the challenge and I saw him laughing and lagging as they had to keep returning to the start, I don't think he threw it. They were so bad at the challenge that it was laughable and it was pretty obvious at one point that they wouldn't be able to catch up with the other team.At least that's the way it seemed to me. I don't think James was taking the challenge too seriously, but deliberately throwing it? I don't think that's his style, not at all. I think the larger problem was that Frosti and Erik were so good at it. Frosti reminded me of a border collie -- his eyes never came off that bouncing ball.
But it gave us more opportunity for another Peih-Gee and James showdown. Okay, we get it. Oil and vinegar, those two. And we also get you haven't won anything, Peih-Gee. But it wasn't all James' fault. Peih-Gee dropped the ball more than he did and Denise was practically useless in the challenge.
Then James told us something that they didn't show us before. Why, Courtney is all over Frosti! That brought about the line used as the title. Plus, it was Frosti, Courtney, Amanda, and Erik who won the reward -- an overnight cruise with dinner.
The castaways might have enjoyed the food and the break from the game as much as the scenery, but I found the scenery absolutely stunning. Maybe if I had Frosti rubbing my shoulders, I'd feel differently. Wait ... with the age difference, that would just be weird. I'd be totally taken in with the scenery anyway.The cruise gave us the opportunity to find out that Erik may have spent too much time with farm animals.
When they saw some goats along the bank of the river, I thought it was the goats making the little goat noises. Nope, it was Erik. Strange, but he really has the goat call down pat. No one asked him why he learned to do that and some things might be better left unasked.
As for the apple, it's not just Courtney and Frosti. Amanda's pretty interested in Erik, goat noises and all.
When they returned to camp, they lied and told the others that they had Chinese food. In actuality, they had a huge feast of fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and cold drinks. Keep in mind that Courtney ate and she ate very well. Amanda thought it best to lie to them about the type of food so the non-eaters wouldn't hold it against them. That was probably a smart decision.
Todd told all four who were on the cruise about Peih-Gee going after James and accusing him of throwing the challenge. Of course, after what she did to him, she really shouldn't say boo to anyone about what they do or don't do in challenges. Both Erik and Frosti were relieved that Peih-Gee is more of a target than they are. They're already worried about each other in the pick off standings.
But things can change with a single immunity challenge, can't they? I couldn't believe that Todd, Denise, and Courtney were so darned sure they were safe that they went for the bribe of cheeseburgers and fries and gave up a chance to win immunity! James knows he has two idols and can save himself in a moment if the thinks he's in danger, but the others? Plus, Courtney had just pigged out! Yeah, she's skinny, but ...! She's not all that well-liked by all and should be worried!
Or, in hindsight, perhaps not. But foresight might be a better strategy than hindsight, right?
The immunity challenge wasn't a thrill a minute, but it was different. Other than using the Chinese zodiac signs once again, it was different. The four who played for immunity -- Amanda, Eric, Frosti, and Peih-Gee -- had to remember a small list of signs Jeff told them, then stab the signs from a board in the correct order. To me, it didn't seem so hard. I didn't have my knife nearby, but easily remembered the order.In the end, it was down to Frosti and Peih-Gee. Both of them were freaking out, certain that they made an error. Finally, Frosti did.
Much to the dismay of all, the sure target for being voted out this week, Peih-Gee won individual immunity. James almost choked on his seventh cheeseburger. Todd sat with a shocked look on his face. Courtney just shoved as much of a burger as she could in her mouth.
So, it threw all the best-laid plans of mice, men, and skinny waitress girls with smart mouths aside. Even though they voted Jean-Robert out and he was one of their own, there were reasons. It's back to Fei Long casting Zhan Hu out with the tide. Or down the river, so to speak.
The targets were Frosti and Erik. Frosti may have made more friends or better friends, but he's a lot better at challenges, thus a larger threat. Todd asked Courtney if she could vote out Frosti and she said she didn't know.
In Jeff's interrogation at Tribal Council, it was very obvious that Frosti and Erik were the most worried. Neither campaigned against each other, but they each ended up voting for each other. That was the only vote Erik would get. The others unanimously (even Peih-Gee) voted out Frosti. Zhan Hu is down to two. Unless they win immunity, they have two weeks and both will surely be gone. It's Pagong all over again. Jean-Robert was an aberration.
Then something odd happened. After Frosti left, Jeff told them it wasn't over, they weren't going back to camp and still had more business. Then it cut to the credits. The promo for next week supplied no clues. Hmmm ... wonder what's up?
I'll miss Frosti. I liked the kid. I didn't think he'd win it all, but he tried his best. As he said during Jeff's interrogation, had he taken the food it wouldn't have been doing everything he could to stay in the game. And I loved his closing comment -- "I was beat by a tiny flight attendant, a sassy waitress, and a woman with a mullet." Heh.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-16-2007 @ 2:11AM
keepitreal said...
if i were amanda (who looked like angelina jolie during some close ups early in the ep), i'd be pissed at those in her alliance. giving those with targets a higher % chance to survive is bad news. i realize they would have 2 to pick from with pg, erik, or frosti, but what if frosti goes on a sick immunity run (he was proving to be a well rounded threat in every type of challenge) and this was the one chance to snipe him.
plus, any time i've ever eaten ridiculous amounts of greasy food, i've always felt like hell soon after. im sure it was still worth it, but i'd be rubbing my belly for 24 hours straight.
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 8:43AM
Caroline said...
I'm not sure I understand comment #1. They voted Frosti out. He can't go on an immunity run. Did you mean James and not Frosti? Confusing.
Anyway, I'm very sorry that PG won immunity, I was really hoping she'd go home this week. Wonder what Jeff meant by their not finished at tribal council yet? If they're voting another person out, then we already know 4 people it's not because they were in the preview for next week, so that would suck. I hope it's something more creative than that. I'm getting a little tired of James' attitude. Some of his points are correct, but he's not expressing them in a non-confrontational manner and it's going to get him in hot water. He'll end up taking the focus off PG and Erik, not that I'd mind looking at Erik for a few more weeks though. :-)
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 9:04AM
I miss my stars! said...
What's the point of giving a massage to a skeleton. It hurts me to look at Courtney now. No muscle tone, no shape, just skin pulled over bones.
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 9:06AM
laura said...
Frosti Calling Courtney Hot...he obviously had a brain lesion, or bacterial infection causing sudden blindness, its good he went home or he might of started massaging denise next.
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 9:16AM
No1Dad said...
Excellent recap. Very well written. Nice job.
Yeah, unfortunately James has done a 180 since he 'found' the two immunity idols. I really miss the big quiet guy from the early episodes. At the very least he should offer Todd one of his idols back, but with a million bucks on the line it's doubtful that'll happen which begs the question:
At what point does the rest of the tribe begin voting against James strategically, simply to remove his two idols from play? Todd and Amanda are too smart to let him skate for much longer (Courtney just seems oblivious to the fact that there is even a game being played for a million dollars).
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 10:57AM
12 said...
Todd was wearing an orange buff in the previews. I think there's some kind of tribal rearrangement again.
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 11:37AM
David said...
Yes, excellent job on the recap Jackie. I've been displeased with some of the recap formats lately, but yours was excellent.
After the show went to credits, the crowd I was with talked about what might be happening. I think we all agreed it was going to be a re-vote. But one person thought that if it's a re-vote, Pie-Geeh was not entitled to individual immunity, and if that's the case, there was no reason to do a cliffhanger, since the conclusion was foregone. If she is entitled to retain individual immunity in a re-vote, then the next episode (WHICH DOESNT AIR FOR WEEKS! ARGH!) will be a nailbiter for the first few minutes. :)
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 11:38AM
David said...
(For clarity, by "re-vote" I mean a second vote at tribal council, to eliminate another Survivor. I do not mean a re-vote, in which Frosti might be able to return.)
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 12:45PM
Peanuts said...
To continue with the catty remarks others have made about Skeletora-aka Courtney-It DID look painful when he was rubbing her back. Ewwww!
Continuing on with the cattiness...
-Has anyone commented on how much PG looks like a monkey? I simply cannot stand her from the start and looking at those ears and ugly face...I have to speed over her parts.
-The mullet lady. I cant remember her name. I find it amazing that she never seems to be on the radar! She is soooo sneaking by.
-The food thing. Do they have tp? I always wondered where they go to the bathroom. Because all that greasy food inside a persons belly that has had zero fat or much food in it will be a MESS! Painful and messy!
Reply
11-16-2007 @ 12:51PM
keepitreal said...
caroline,
i mean frosti. im saying that clearly the majority wanted frosti gone seeing as he was voted out (maybe he was the second choice but still one of the top two). by only giving him 3 opponents for a chance at the immunity idol, he has at worst a 25% of winning (i say much higher cuz obviously some of the others sucked at the challenge).
but since the merge, (prior to this challenge) he won immunity once (in a MEMORY game), got second once, was very good at a team reward challenge involving a new trait of dexterity, and is probably the #2 physical challenge threat behind james. all this adds up to not wanting to give him a chance to keep winning immunity (if he happened to have won the knife memory game). but by having 4 people skip the challenge, it makes it more likely that if he had won, he could have gone on a sick over the following weeks. and in a final 3 vote, he's a big threat to win.
does that make sense?
Reply
11-17-2007 @ 6:28AM
Mel said...
I'm glad PG won. Even if I don't like the player, I do like it when someone pulls out a win when it counts.
Frosti annoys me. He acts like a 12 year old girl. Ever sine he ingratiated himself in and horned in on Todd's immunity find, he was nothing but pathetic. Good challenger though.
Are we even sure Todd has asked for the immunity back? Maybe he's biding his time to ask for it back.
Reply
11-18-2007 @ 7:31PM
LKB said...
Why would James give the immunity idol back? Really, why?
As he says, The purpose of the game is to win the million dollars - not gain friends, or be honorable, or any of that stuff. Although James isn't the best strategist, I think he's got the best intuitive understanding of what is really happening in the Survivor game.
That being said... there are 7 people left. That means there are three or four tribal councils left where James could use his idols. So I would suspect, he's got to start burning through those idols now... he's got to figure that he's got a good shot at winning one immunity challenge, so that should mean he's going to get himself to the final four.
Reply