TVSquad

I thought it was a good show, and really was glad that they showed Teyla being exasperated at Dr. Keller's fear and squeamishness. Although, I couldn't have walked across that bridge,either, nor could I have eaten that stuff from that thing!
The lollipop stick in the bad guy's mouth was hilarious, as was the arrow conversation. And yes, we all know that R. L. is/was pregnant. We didn't need the "we need to talk" line - she just should have said it and ended with Teyla having a dreamy look on her face, more determined than ever to find her missing lover.
But, it was a good episode, but I am glad that next week Samantha will be back in it, along with everyone else.

Reply

Yeah, every episode can't be a "Tabula Rosa." I also liked the addition of this new "race," and I firmly believe it isn't the last we will see of them. What I'm hoping though, is that it doesn't turn out to be that the Bola Kai are actually nice people who are just misunderstood or something, I hope it is more complicated than that, because it wouldn't work well with both the way and how quickly Teyla (and Ronon) reacted to their presence.

I too will never complain about too much Jewel Staite. Oh and I loved that reference to "Sateda," the image of McKay screaming, "This is not happening!" popped into my head and it got a good laugh.

Reply

This is easily the worst episode of the season. The Doctor has become the most annoying character on the show, she used to only be the most boring. This new group was pointless, hell the whole episode was pointless except that it will obviously lead to things down the road.

Sadly I'll bet anyone that this week's event's are mostly, or more likely completely, forgotten by next week's episode.

Reply

Oreo: It's fine if you're annoyed by the doctor, but even if you didn't like what happened on the show (acting, writing, whatever), it is hard to argue that the episode was pointless.

2 rather important things happened, that as you said will have consequences "down the road.":
1. We have a new race/group of people.
2. Teyla's group is missing

It's hard to argue this new group was pointless because other than this episode we don't know their story. Now if in a year or two they never mention these people again then hell yes I'll agree with you.

2 pieces of character development:
1. the doctor overall (but I know you don't care)
2. Teyla (someone in her life, lost her people, baby?)

So It wasn't a must-see episode, if I missed it I could have just as easily read a short summary and been fine. My point is with most shows looking at the bigger picture sometimes episodes, like this one, serve as a setup.

Reply

Yay for giving Teyla something to do! And how cool was her leather coat?

I wish there had been more Danny Trejo, too.

Reply

I enjoyed seeing Keller do Rodney's usual bits and, at the rescue, seeing Ronon take off with the women, Shepard following them and RODNEY bringing up the rear firing into the bad guys!

Reply

Making the Athosians disappear, where they're alive or not, was a very stupid idea. Having her people around to visit and care about made her character deeper, getting rid of them this way just made Teyla into a cliché. "Oh no, I've lost what I cared about! I must go on a quest to save them!" (if they're alive)

I thought this show had better writers than that. I guess not.

Reply

Now THIS episode is my favorite so far in Season Four. And Missing is definitely in my top ten of SGA episodes. Kudos to Carl Binder on the script and director Andy Mikita.

What a fantastic episode!

Teyla was amazing, spectacular...and very Jack O'Neillish...

Her determination and strength is admirable.

And her actions regarding the Bola Kai -- hunting down the runner, killing the survivor -- were correct for the situation.

I was glad that Teyla let Keller tend to the "Genii" -- that is also something Jack O'Neill would have done.

When the lollipops were introduced, I kept wondering how Teyla was going to turn one of those into a weapon. I wasn't expecting one of the Bola Kai to eat one! LOL!

I LOVE Keller! Jewel Staite is fabulous. (Okay, I'm going to have to look for my Thesaurus now...) Keller tackling the guy was great, and she knew exactly where to shoot him to get the best results.

And you couldn't get me to cross that rope bridge either! Yikes!

I wonder why Keller didn't use one of the fallen Bola Kai's weapons to defend herself instead of that scalpel?

Nice character development. Teyla was having a "date" with Kanan, and they've been friends since childhood. Keller is from Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin (yeah!), and the only family she has is her dad. I was surprised that Keller didn't invite Teyla to come home with her on her visit.

Wished we could have seen more of Danny Trejo (the Bola Kai leader) but the few minutes we had with him were more than convincing. If anyone can portray a cold-blooded killer, it's him!

The music was lovely; I loved the Stargate arrival on New Athos with Keller and Teyla; and way cool to see Rodney, Shep and Ronon exit the cloaking field of the puddle jumper.

Truly marvelous to see the powerful women of SGA in this episode.

Out of ten, I'd rate this episode with 12 lollipops!

:)

Morjana

Reply

I am a big Jewel Staite fan from her days on Firefly, but I find her character very annoying. I understand she is not a fighter but she is too whiny. I found myself raising my voice to the TV several times in annoyance. On the plus side I enjoying the Teyla centric episode. She is a joy to watch. Stargate fan for 11 years.

Reply

This episode is pointless, there was no story. What was the plot? There was none. I doubt we will see this group again, and it was a waste of an hour they could have been leading to something. In the end we don't have any answers, and next week seems to ignore the fact that the people are missing.

There are better ways to introduce a race and to have a story build up. Look at "The Travelers", that story had a plot, finished that plot in 60 minutes (well 44) and still gave questions to the next time we will see them. This episode did one of those, and came off as a huge failure.

Maybe Teyla's people will be like Weir and Ford, we will see them / talk about them once and then forget they were ever around.

Reply

The point of this episode was to build you up for further episodes. Tayla will be told that she is pregnant (since she had a baby in real life) so you will see how that is worked into the show. You will also see more of Nabal and the Athosians and the Bala Kai.

I don't agree with Oreo - the epi was not a complete failure. It had some good tense moments and it was needed for further plot development. Sometimes you have to have a "so-so" epi in order to have the big bang ones later on!

Reply

I didn't like the episode yet it was a good one. There were twists and turns. The writing was good. There was plot development short and long-term.

Yet it felt meh for me.

The reason is simple:the only part I liked was when the team was back in action at the end, with the weapons being fired. That's the kind of action I like.

Still this one was better than any DS9 Ferengi episode. They pulled at least three of those out of their asses every season and I hated them all.

Reply

First of all, how hot was Rachel in that outfit? Anyone with me on this one?

Anyway, was I the only one to notice several Firefly/Serenity references in this episode? First, the Bola Kai initially appeared very Reaver-like (rumored to be cannibals, use primitive weapons, alter the appearance of their faces, etc.), Second, when Teyla fights a group of them, the camera angles and moves used almost mirror those used by River in Serenity. Thirdly, Teyla eventually ends up fighting them with, what else, a blade and an axe. Finally, do my eyes deceive me, or was Teyla wearing a large BROWN coat for nearly the entire episode.

Reply

DataDroid! I caught most of those, except the Bola Kai being Reaverlike. Well I mean I did think they were Reaverlike at first because of the face paint and the reputation they had (Teyla said something along the lines of nothing being left to find if you're caught by a Bola Kai), but then when they took the two as prisoners and questioned them and all that I was like, okay maybe they're not straight up Reavers. But still, you're right. Did you catch who wrote this one?

p.s. - Rachel is always hot, but yes she looked especially nice in the coat.

Reply

I liked the episode, but I don't buy the Bola kai for a second. In this galaxy, this race of people is completely implausible. Here's why: you have a completely primitive race of people, right? Yet everyone seems to know who they are, right? (At least, Teyla and Ronin both knew quickly). Such a primitive tribe wouldn't be capable of space-flight, so it stands to reason that that would've been their home planet. So the Athosians should have known that before settling there.

And if you can assume that the Bola Kai have also spread out through the galaxy because of the stargate, then don't you think at some point they'd try and get better technology than bows and arrows? I don't buy it.

Reply

Regarding Chuck's complaint: "Such a primitive tribe wouldn't be capable of space-flight, so it stands to reason that that would've been their home planet. And if you can assume that the Bola Kai have also spread out through the galaxy because of the stargate, then don't you think at some point they'd try and get better technology than bows and arrows? I don't buy it."

Just because the Bola Kai know how to use the Stargate to travel from planet to planet, doesn't necessarily mean they would also upgrade their weapon technology -- and there could be several reasons for having primitive weapons, including:

1) Perhaps the Bola Kai tribal religion prescibes not only the cannibalism, but also the manner on how their prey is killed -- with primitive weapons.

2) The firearms that the Genii have (projective weapons) require bullets to work. Whereas the Bola Kai can acquire the actual weapons, they don't have the knowledge/skills to manufacture the bullets. And perhaps their homeworld doesn't have a sporting goods store franchise.

3) And if Ronon's weapon also requires to be reloaded, then again, they run into the same problem with manufacturing the ammunition.

4) We don't have a clue as to how the Wraith weapons work, but I'm guessing they're similar to the Goa'uld weapons, and in that they too require a renewable energy source. In the Goa'uld weapons, it was liquid naquada. So again, the Bola Kai could acquire the weapons, but what do they do to in finding replacement energy sources?

Morjana

Reply

I've got a much easier explanation of the Bola Kai and their technology level.

They are a warrior tribe that is always on the run from the Wraith. They don't stick around long enough to learn new tech or master found tech. Their simple weapons serve them well to survive.

Reply

Usually I hate these episodes (All Teal'c/Jaffa or Ronin/Satedans storylines bore me to tears). But I found this was pretty interesting character development.

I'm a Jewel Staite fan, but her character was such a wuss. I like the extreme contrast between the Dr. and Teyla. And I'm glad Dr. didn't turn into Linda Hamilton at the end of the episode.

But another primitive race of KISS cavemen? BOR-RING. I'd love to see another advanced race like Aschens.

Reply

Oh, and just exactly WHY is Amanda Tapping in the show? She looks tired... and puffy. She's barely used (if at all). Did the producers throw a bunch of money at her? Is she burned out after 10 years? (I'd be)

I feel like her scant apperances are ruining my good memories of Sam in SG1.

Reply

I must have missed some key points prior to this episode. When Atlantis left Atlantia in the season three finale, did the Athosians, who were on the mainland, come aboard for the ride? And then got resettled to this planet? Plus, last I remember, there were a lot of Athosians....why then were there just a handfull of tents in the village? Shouldn't there be several settlements???

Reply