
(S05E14) The hosts of Dancing With The Stars were doing some major damage control in the wake of Sabrina's elimination. Viewers were warned at least a dozen times to remember to vote for their favorite celebrities. Personally, I think it's sad that people need to be reminded of the basic principles of this show, but oh well. The competition has changed now that Sabrina is gone--it's a battle of the fan bases! This week, the remaining dancers performed two dances, one in the Ballroom style and one in the Latin style. I'm always excited when we reach this point. You get a much better idea of who can handle the pressure and difficulty of learning two routines. As always there were some fun surprises and a few flubs.
Helio Castroneves and Julianne Hough (Tango) - Helio and Julianne started off the Ballroom round with a Tango, performed to "The Jean Genie" by David Bowie. You can add this to the list of bizarre song-performance match-ups. I found the song choice to be a bit distracting. Helio was nervous about the challenge of learning two dances, so Julianne gave him a touching video message from his parents. You can certainly see where Helio gets his big smile! The performance itself was decent, and Helio looked very comfortable, but it wasn't very exciting. Helio's personality and enthusiasm came through, but it felt like more of the same.
Len declared that this point marks start of the race to the finals. He acknowledged that the routine had drive and attack, but there were some technical shortcomings. There were no heel leads, Helio's arm was too far out, and he needed a better hold. Bruno compared Julianne and Helio to thunder and lightning, and added that he wanted their performances to be more polished. Details will be crucial to making it to the finals. Carrie Ann thought that their "twist" on the Tango suited them well, but there were a few balance issues. Backstage, Samantha took viewers to task, telling them that fans were responsible for Sabrina's elimination. Tom quickly lightened the mood by adding that global warming is the viewers' fault, too. Score: 25 (9, 8, 8)
Marie Osmond and Jonathan Roberts (Quickstep) - Marie looked very worried when she found out that she and Jane were performing the same dances. She joked that she was trying to make her hip movements more girly, like Jonathan's. We also got a look at her dozens and dozens of children (OK, she only has eight kids, but it looked like an entire third grade class in there). The couple did a lively Quickstep to the tune of "Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy." Now that was an appropriate song choice! Everything about this routine showcased Marie's strengths: her personality, energy, and her technical abilities. She may not be as flexible as Jane or the younger ladies, but her footwork was great. Even her brother got in on the action (and almost knocked her down) after the performance.
Bruno called the routine a "morale booster," and said that when Marie gets it right, she gets it right. Carrie Ann was pleased that the Quickstep was camp-free, and praised her footwork and posture. Len joked that entertainment flows though Marie's veins like Chianti does with Bruno's. He thought that she brought a wonderful twist to the dance. I guess that kiss at the end of the routine paid off! Marie sweetly dedicated the dance to her parents. Score: 28 (10, 9, 9)
Melanie Brown and Maksim Chmerkovskiy (Foxtrot) - Melanie's Spice Girls work was taking its toll in practices. In addition to learning two routines for the show, she was learning 20 songs and dance routines for her tour. Maksim mentioned that although Melanie learns routines quickly, "picking things up" wouldn't be enough to stay in the competition. Mel and Maks danced to "Jimmy Mack," by Martha and the Vandellas. The routine was charming, but wasn't as impressive as last week's 30-pointer. To be fair, it's tough to deliver two incredible routines back-to-back. They did a wonderful job with this performance, but it just wasn't a show-stopper.
Carrie Ann noticed that Mel and Maks were out of sync with their footwork and the size of their steps. Len had issues with the couple's footwork as well, but thought that Mel's arms were lovely. Bruno wanted to see more finesse from Melanie, but didn't think the routine was horrible. Score: 24 (8, 8, 8). Melanie was pleased with the scores, but Maks bragged that their second dance would kick some serious butt. Samantha's second guilt trip included her acknowledgment that most viewers tune her out at this point in the show. Naturally, the camera cut to Tom, examining his fingernails. Ha!
Jane Seymour and Tony Dovolani (Quickstep) - Jane compared last week's sudden illness to the pain of having twins. She recovered in time to take on both routines, fortunately. She dedicated her first dance, the Quickstep, to Johnny Cash. I didn't know that Jane and her husband were friends with Johnny Cash and June Carter Cash; it's hard to picture them all hanging out. Their routine, performed to "Walk The Line," was very light and cute. As with Helio, I felt like we were getting another version of routines that we had seen from Jane before. Jane is the most naturally graceful of all the performers, and it's always a pleasure to watch her. I'm afraid that she might not have any new moves left, though.
Len commended Jane on her usual elegance and terrific posture, but disliked the total lack of body contact in the routine. Bruno mentioned that with the standards getting tougher, the expectations get higher. Jane needed to work on the details of her performance. Carrie Ann loved Jane's technique, but told her to excite the fans and be outstanding. Jennie Garth got a similar criticism several weeks ago, and this could be a sign that Jane isn't progressing in the way the judges expect her to. Score: 24 (8, 8, 8)
Jennie Garth and Derek Hough (Viennese Waltz) - Jennie was terrified of doing two dances, especially two such different styles of dance. She was the only one who performed the Waltz, which isn't as much of a crowd-pleaser. I was glad she set herself apart from the rest of the dancers, though. The Quickstep was done to death. The end result ("Runaway," The Corrs) was lovely. Jennie appeared to be more graceful and flexible than ever. This is where I think Sabrina might have missed out on votes. For me, it's far more entertaining to watch a celebrity grow and improve over the course of the show. Jennie's time on the show has featured both highs and lows, which makes for a more exciting journey.
Bruno felt that, at times, Jennie's movements were very fluid and nymph-like. She's close to being perfect, but needs to sustain that perfection throughout the dance. Carrie Ann thought that Jennie had moved backwards, and saw several broken lines. She believed that Jennie was building up a momentum and needed to get much better to continue to the finals. Len thought the dance had a "lovely musical lilt," but wanted to see more Viennese Waltz elements. He mainly took Derek to task for his choreography and left Jennie out of his remarks. Score: 25 (8, 8, 9). When compared with the earlier dances, I thought Derek and Jennie deserved a slightly higher score.
Cameron Mathison and Edyta Sliwinska (Quickstep) - Cameron's schedule interfered with rehearsals again this week. We got a rundown of what Cameron's average week is like, and I don't envy him one bit. He wanted to step it up after being in the Bottom Two, and said that this week was his most important week. Cameron and Edyta's high-energy Quickstep ("Why Can't I Be You?" -The Cure) seemed much more fast-paced than the other Quicksteps, which didn't seem like a good thing. There were several tough moves, and Cameron has the advantage of never looking awkward or uncomfortable with any style of dance.
Carrie Ann asked if Cameron drank a Red Bull before the performance. She called the routine "wild" and "out of control." Len told the couple to calm down, and warned them to focus more on the basics of the dance and less on the fun stuff. On a positive note, he mentioned that ,when they were in the proper hold, they looked great. Bruno believed that Cameron forgot the steps during his rushed performance. Score: 24 (8, 8, 8). I'm getting the impression that the judges want to make the scoring fairly even in order to give the voters more power. They were probably upset that their mid-level scores for Sabrina contributed to her elimination.
Helio Castroneves and Julianne Hough (Samba) - This dance was Helio at his finest. He brought his biggest smile and his hottest hip-swivel. The couple's routine ("Ay Candela," Ibrahim Ferrer) was far more difficult on a technical level and way more fun than their Tango. I think a lot of the couples wisely saved their best moves and energy for the Latin dances, since they are the biggest crowd-pleasers.
Bruno told Helio that those are the kind of dances that he likes to see from him, and that "the boy from Brazil has gone bananas." Carrie Ann agreed (minus the bananas comment). She thought that Latin dances flowed through Helio's body more naturally, and that he should stick with those in the future. Len remarked that you cannot assume a Brazilian will be a good dancer, just as you can't assume that a Texan will be a good president. This got a huge reaction from the crowd, and not a positive one. I didn't know that the Dancing With the Stars audience was so conservative! Bruno made a hilarious joke about Len losing his Visa. Tom's joke was easily the funniest: "You only annoyed 33% of the people." Score: 27 (9, 9, 9); 52 points combined.
Marie Osmond and Jonathan Roberts (Cha Cha Cha) - Marie began the dance wrapped in a feather boa. I wonder how many of those are in the DWTS wardrobe? We probably see between five and ten of those per season. Marie and Jonathan performed their Cha Cha Cha to "Venus," by Shocking Blue. Once again, Marie's superb command of the stage came through and made her performance a winner. I think it's great that she's comfortable doing solos and being onstage alone, as she was at the start of the routine. This dance was probably a little low on the technical elements, but the attitude and entertainment value were amazing.
Carrie Ann said that she was afraid that the boa would make the dance too campy, but Marie nailed the tone of the dance perfectly. She was hoping for more content, though. Len appreciated the effort and the Cha Cha Cha elements that were present, but thought the couple "messed around" too much. Bruno loved the character of the dance and thought that she peaked with the first dance. Score: 24 (8, 8, 8); 52 points combined.
Melanie Brown and Maksim Chmerkovskiy (Paso Doble) - Melanie was incredibly sexy in her black leather ensemble, and Maks was probably thrilled to be in a black leather vest without a shirt. The crowd and judges loved the routine ("Free Your Mind," En Vogue), but it wasn't my favorite. Perhaps Carrie Ann's comment about Cameron's dance being too wild influenced my opinion of this dance. I loved the attitude, but thought Mel's movements were too frenzied. It was still much better than the majority of the other Latin routines, though. With Sabrina gone, Mel has to make it to the finals.
Len said that the dance had it all: passion, turns, and aggression. He absolutely loved it. Bruno called Mel "an adrenaline-charged dominatrix," and said that his jaw was on the judges' desk. Carrie Ann seconded Maksim's earlier comment about the routine kicking butt. Backstage, Maks showed off a tattoo of a cheetah's pawprint, which was a sweet tribute to Sabrina. There were a few signs of Sabrina-love in this episode: it looked like Helio was wearing a Sabrina T-shirt, and Julianne pointed to a tattoo on her arm during the opening segment. Score: 30 (10, 10, 10); 54 combined. I guess I'll have to go back and watch that routine again!
Jane Seymour and Tony Dovolani (Cha Cha Cha) - The couple's routine ("The Shoop Shoop Song (It's In His Kiss),") was fantastic in terms of technique, but Carrie Ann's comments influenced my viewing again. I can see what she meant when she said that Jane doesn't provide the wow factor. She's clearly a gifted dancer, but entertainment is a major part of getting votes. It could be Jane's turn to go home this week. She's a polite and ladylike dancer, but doesn't bring the sexiness that some of the other dancers do.
Bruno dubbed Jane a "golden icon," and thought the routine was well-executed. He also praised Jane's hip movements. Carrie Ann thought she did very well, and thought Jane looked amazing in her dress. She wanted more than Jane's usual daintiness, though. Len was looking for fireworks, and told Jane to bring more than the basic technique to the dance. I think the judges are expecting Jane to be eliminated, and softened their remarks a little. Score: 26 (8, 9, 9); 50 points combined.
Jennie Garth and Derek Hough (Rumba) - In her earlier training footage, Jennie was concerned about getting the lovers' element of the dance down. She shouldn't have worried. Derek and Jennie's Rumba ("Fallen," Lauren Wood) was slow, sexy, and hot. Despite the age difference, they played the part of a couple in love very well. Jennie has done a great job of conveying the tone of each dance over the last few weeks. I might have liked this routine better than her performance last week.
Carrie Ann loved it, and praised Jennie for recovering from her difficult first dance. Len told Jennie that she's the only person who isn't convinced that she's a good dancer. He thought her routine was great. Bruno simply called the dance "satisfying." Enough said. Score: 28 (9, 9, 10); 53 combined. Wow, Jennie won Bruno over! With two judges eating out of her hand, she could go far.
Cameron Mathison and Edyta Sliwinska (Jive) - Cameron and Edyta were able to simmer down in time for their Jive ("The Boy From New York City"). The routine was much lighter and less intense then the couple's Quickstep. There were still plenty of fun elements, though. Cameron jumped over Edyta's shoulders at one point. John Ratzenberger certainly looked impressed.
Len informed us that the Jive normally suits short, compact dancers, but that Cameron did a fantastic job. Bruno said that there were "more kicks than a rodeo" and loved Cameron's performance as well. Carrie Ann added that Cameron began the competition as the good-looking guy who could "kinda" move, but developed into a great dancer. Tom appeased the Sabrina fans by advertising the DWTS tour, which Sabrina will be a part of. Score: 27 (9, 9, 9); 51 points combined.
The final leaderboard put Mel and Maks ahead of the pack, with Jane and Tony in last place. I've always loved watching Jane dance, but I'm guessing that she'll be sent home tomorrow. The other competitors are just too strong and have shown more improvement. She'll be missed!
Tuesday's Results Show will feature performances by Michael Flatley, LeAnn Rimes, and the return of DanceCenter! At last! Until then, check out AOL's extensive Dancing With The Stars coverage, which includes photo galleries, a live chat (Mondays & Tuesdays, 7:30pm ET), and the chance to support your favorite couple by voting in AOL's poll!















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
11-06-2007 @ 1:19AM
mamadoe said...
I think Jennie is doing absolutely fantastic. Her arms are outstanding, and she does great kicks and fancy footwork. Add into the equation that she is not a natural on-stage performer and is nervous as can be, and you've got to give the girl a big chance.
Mel is the new Sabrina but, of course, she is used to performing on stage even if the Spice Girls routines are not exactly ballroom dancing. Still, it would be nice to see sexy-but-arrogant Maks be a winning partner for once, he and Edyta are two big bridesmaids in this competition.
I think Helio deserved slightly higher marks, as usual, I mean, he has no performing experience, I hope he makes it to the finals but, at this point, you just never know. Cameron is running on fumes but his enthusiasm and desire are infectious. Marie was very good this week. It's time for Jane to go, I'm afraid. I do hope she goes and not a better dancer because then all of Samantha's guilt tripping will go to waste!
As for the Jane-Johnny Cash connection, I knew that James Keach was the producer of 'Walk the Line' and said he was a friend of Johnny and June's, but I had no idea he was a godfather to one of the twins. I think just about anyone could have hung out with Johnny and June, they were the real deal.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 1:43AM
Stacie23 said...
If Jane doesn't go home this week then something is going on, she was definetly better than many of the performers in the past, not Sabrina, but better than Mark Cuban, and the 2 models, but at this point the remaining celebrites are far more impressive and exciting. She did well, but she got an extra week to live because of Sabrina's departure. There is no other celebrity that deserves to go home. Even Marie Osmond had a great dance tonight. I give Jane alot of credit for getting this far but it is time to go.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 2:10AM
Cindy Gibson said...
This was a great show tonight. I think Mel and Max did a great job on the Paso. It had all the content the dance requires plus the Love/hate thing was done perfectly.
I agree that Jane should be the next to go. Whatever Dance she has all look the same now. She has nowhere else to go. Helio did a much better job than his scores showed in my opinion. I enjoyed both his dances. Of course the latin dance was really great. I feel that his scores should reflect that he has no dance experience compared to the others and is doing as good a job as
any of them. Hopefully everyone will take the hints were hit over the head with and vote so we won't get any more big shocks.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 4:02AM
D Colin said...
Loved Jennie Garth and Derek's rumba tonight-- thought they had the best dance of the night. She really has gotten better over the weeks -- and I love her training segments.
Plus huge 90210 fan and I gotta have Kelly Taylor in the finals!
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 7:52AM
Dee said...
I loved Marie's quick step...it really showcased her entertainment background with her smile, her movements and her audience connection. I hope Jane is the person to go home; I've appreciated her efforts, but think of those remaining she is the one who is not moving on.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 8:18AM
MH said...
Last week, I thought it might be time for Marie to go home, but I hope she sticks around for another week. She did really well last night and I especially enjoyed her first dance. Gosh, she looks happier than I've seen her for a long time. The show has been great for her.
I wish I could give Jennie a big shot of confidence. I'm glad she's doing well and would like to see her project to the audience when she dances. She probably is terrified and tries not to look at the people who are there watching her, but it would add so much to her performances and really put her over the top.
I know Helio isn't an entertainer by occupation, but his dances all seem to mesh together in my mind. Maybe it's just me but all of his dances seem the same and he hasn't really progressed and improved from his first performance. What was really good the first week now doesn't seem so swell when significant improvement is expected. I'm still scratching my head over Julianne's costume in the samba. It was really distracting me. It looked like she was wearing a shrub! LOL I finally realized it was feathers when the dance was over and Tom made some comment about the feathers.
For many reasons, I hope Jane gets the ax tonight. I don't really think she is improving either and her footwork and body movements just don't "pop" on the Latin dances (or the faster-paced ballroom dances, either). Truth be told, I have issues with her personality, as well. She's made some catty comments about other competitors and is spending a lot of time on entertainment news shows telling all of her harrowing tales. I do sympathize with her over the loss of her mother and think maybe she needs to get out of the spotlight and regroup after all of the drama of the past couple of months. It's easy for the press to take things out of context in interviews, etc. but from what I've seen, she's coming across as a bit of a poor sport. I don't enjoy watching her now.
At any rate, tonight will be interesting. Hope everybody enjoys the show.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 8:24AM
Katherine Paniello said...
What a loss - Sabrina was most definitely the best dancer - right out of the gate she earned a 9-9-9. Her fan base must have been near to nothing. I think that demands that the powers that be should re-think the value of the fans vs pros opinions. Up to Sabrina's departure, I agreed with those voted off. They had the worst scores from the judges.
I have watched every show of every season. I usually understand what's happening. Exception: The very first season, why was there a re-match. The General Hospital girl won the contest fair and square. To give that smiling, white-haired comic another chance was unfair to the true winner. He was like a kid crying because he wanted to win.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 8:28AM
CeCe said...
I thought the funniest line tonight was when Cam was reviewing his schedule. He mentioned going thru the routine for camera blocking. DWTS is terrible with camera shots. How many times did we see cam guys running thru the scene? I love this show but after this many seasons you'd think it would be better at the camera work.
Go Mel and Maks!
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 8:34AM
grumpyoldman said...
When Jane Seymour ran over and kissed her husband after her first dance, I told my wife there's the second luckiest guy on earth. ( I am of course the first).
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 8:46AM
David said...
Stacie: Jane will go home if enough viewers vote for other celebrities in the bottom half of the standings, and not for Jane. If Jane has good fan support, she definitely won't be going home, and it won't be due to any conspiracy.
CeCe: live TV is the hardest kind of television to pull off well. Worse, DWTS uses dozens of pre-arranged camera movements ("shotsheets") which each of the cameramen must follow perfectly, the director must call perfectly, and the technical director must switch to perfectly. It's as much of a dance as the dancing it's shooting. In a long format of 1-2 hours, it's amazing how well the production crew of DWTS pulls off this complex choreography as well as they do. The DWTS production staff is one of the best in the business, and though I'm biased, each year I grade it better than the American Idol production staff, which has an easier show to shoot (less movement, more predictability).
Katherine: I disagree entirely. I'm happy it's 50/50 judges/fans, because it means the best dancers each week don't go home (as measured by the judges). Sabrina went home because she was in the bottom half of the scoreboard, and of course had poor fan support (beacuse none of us know what a Cheetah Girl is). Had Sabrina performed the way she was capable of every week, she would still be on the show. Remember: if you're at (or near) the top of the scoreboard, it's impossible to go home, because even if you have the least amount of fan votes, you still finish in the middle of the pack. The math works out well, in my opinion.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 9:33AM
RonP said...
First-time commenter. Erin, your combination of substance and style is excellent. Your blog is exceptional! Though I too was surprised by the audience reaction to Len's Bush analogy after Helio and Julianne's routine, I was both shocked and pissed at AOL's Home Page setup. "Nasty"? Come on now!! I imagine, as the fine writer you are, you too must be sick and tired of the "yellow" journalistic style AOL has developed recently. Keep up the fine work. RonP, founder http://www.DearDemocrat.com
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 10:35AM
Mai_Tai said...
HELIO! HELIO!
Ok, so I'm biased! I am a huge Helio fan to begin with and find him fun, funny, and loaded with charisma. Of all the Indy car drivers, he was the best choice to represent the sport. Go Helio - our Brazilian boy gone Bananas!
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 10:09AM
DMC25 said...
DWTS has gone downhill, I started watching with my girlfriend and even went to the tour show with her. But tonight was horrible, the judges are people hypercritical of Helio and letting Marie slide through the finals, after watching Helio's first dance and seeing his low scores, then watching Marie's first dance and getting no comments about missed steps I can see the fix is in to slide Marie to the finals(which I will not watch out of spite for how unbalanced the judging has been this season).
Also I find it ridiculous how Marie's brother Donny is in my opinion throwing the vote. You have him going on ET and complaining about Sabrina being a "professional dancer" then last night running on the floor to make a scene with his sister. You don't see anyone else getting this fluff publicity to help one couple win.
I started this season thinking it would be okay, then the competition got a lot harder, Sabrina, Helio, and Mel were clearly the leaders. But now its just a publicity contest where celebrities happen to dance also.
Like many before, if Jane and Marie aren't the next off the show, its lost another fan.
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 10:56AM
fitnesinst said...
I definately think that Erin needs to rewatch Mel & Maks's Paso. It definately kicked *&^&. Wow - my jaw was on the floor. I'm rooting for them. Maks is a great choreographer and Mel is definately bringing it to the floor.
Jennie was awesome. She really came through this week in both dances.
I liked Helio early in the season, but now I find that his facial expressions are distracting. He either looks goofy or in pain.
Marie - well, I wanted her to go home last week and was in complete shock that Sabrina went home instead. Can you believe that? Marie's small army of eight kids must have 7 email addresses each. Crazy. Anyway, I enjoyed her Quickstep & sorta felt bad about wishing her away, but after her cha-cha I wasn't feeling bad anymore. She needs to go home. She isn't consistent. She has dances she can pull off and others she just looks bizarre doing.
Jane - she doesn't wow me. Other than she's in her fifties and looks fabulous, I don't go WOW! when I watch her dance. Do you think her and Tony could pull off a dominatrix number????? :)
Cameron - he's the underdog & I enjoy watching him. His jive was very entertaining. It's been neat watching how much he has improved. I wish Albert was still on the show. Maks, Cameron and Albert all in one night - wow!!!
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 11:05AM
PB said...
I *loved* Mel & Max's dance! I watched it 3 times. Mel's kicks were high, with toe pointed and spot on. OK, OK ... it doesn't hurt that Max was in the vest ;-) Seriously, though, that was an awesome dance. The only thing I saw slightly off was when they both lifted their legs to do a sort of leg twirl (akin to a bull pawing the ground, I guess) ... the timing was off BUT Max choreographed that well, because I don't think the judges could see Mel's leg from their position in the ballroom. I agree ... let Max go to the finals. He deserves it. I wasn't a huge Mel fan, but she's really ratched up her game and I'm pegging her for the finals.
I have to admit, the one I just don't get is Jennie. The whole "poor me, I can't deal with live TV stress" is starting to wear as thin as Cam's "I work so hard every week" spiel. I really like Derek and think his choreography is on par with Julieanne's, but Jennie just doesn't seem to really be into it, from my perspective. I don't ever feel that *wow* factor when I watch her dance, whereas I do with some other dancers. I suppose we'll find out in a few weeks how right/wrong we all are! :-)
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 12:22PM
Dee said...
Marie's father has passed away. So sorry for her. I remember him as a man who taught his kids that "the show must go on" but she said recently that his passing would be harder for her than her mother's a few years ago...she was born on his birthday. Either she'll be like Jane and dance next week (if kept on) as a tribute or maybe she'll bow out if it's too much?
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 12:43PM
Joann said...
PEOPLE. this is a "dance contest" not a "popularity contest". Sabrina, was the best dancer this season. Maybe, people in charge should turn it over to the judges to decide. What do you think?
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 12:33PM
ORKMommy said...
HOLY CRAP! I missed the Paso with Mel & Maks on TV last night and just watched it on YouTube! Those two were SMOKIN'!! I'm really pulling for them because Mel is a fabulous dancer and Maks is a great choreographer. I can only think of a few dances where I said "Huh...". Most of the time his choice of music really suits the dance and those moves! YIKES!!
p.s. It helps that he's totally hot!
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 12:43PM
DancingLady1933 said...
I was so happy to see Sabrina go home. I guess it's too much to expect such happiness two weeks in a row. Mel is way overrated. So she struts her legs and points her toes...so what? She is just doing a pale imitation of the dance she is supposed to do. If anyone's moves are boilerplate reused with different music, they are Mel's. Mel did not deserve three 10s. It is she the judges are trying to keep in by giving her such undeserved high marks. I may work, it may not.
Jane is doing very well. I don't understand why Len is so harsh regarding her. But I have a theory: Perhaps they met at some point in her past and he tried to date her, with Jane turning him down flat. He never got over it.
It's as though DWTS is trying to put obstacles in the path of Helio and Julianne. The costumes they give to Helio are pretty bad, but they also give them the worst music matches to the dance. It's not a surprise Helio is nervous, given the obvious barriers put in his path...I cast all my votes for H&J.
Well, here's hoping Mel's out tonight...
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 1:33PM
David said...
Joann, for five seasons this has been both a dance and a popularity contest. The best dancers (that is, those who perform the best in any given week) are safe from elimination. The dancers who aren't the best can only be saved by the viewers. Sabrina did not enjoy any fan support, and therefore the week where she did badly (she was tied for 4th out of 7 total dancers) she was voted off by the viewers. It's only at the very end where the show become less about dance and more about popularity. In most seasons, the couples are virtually tied at the finals or semifinals, so the viewers' votes are everything.
Reply