TVSquad

I've been a fan of Survivor from the start, but honestly, are any of the cast members from these seasons "All Stars" in the way some prior seasons were?

Reply

Yeah... All-stars? Not so much. I've been a huge Survivor fan since the first series (with the exception of Vanuatu, when I took a break), but half of these names I can't even picture.

And why "boo" to Parvati and a swipe at Courtney? I think they're great (and looking forward to seeing more of Courtney in the current season!). It's Jonathan from Cook Islands that I was hoping to never see again.

Reply

Parvati!

I was rooting for her.

Reply

Yeah, this is hardly an "All-Stars" cast. Terry, Ozzy and Yao-Man yes, but that's about it. It's dumb if they are really limiting it to season 9-15.

Reply

its only limited to seasons 9-15 cuz they already did an allstars with seasons 1-8....thats why ! check out the new SPOILERS for the episode tonight !! see who goes home and so much more:

http://www.realitytvspoiler.com/

theres even a picture of Courtney after the show...and it looks like she might have even gained a pound or two....well mmmmaybe not but at least we know that she survives the jungle ....

Reply

Hmmm

if it isn't Rupert, Richard Hatch or that woman with the foul mouth......or even Johnny Fairplay... I just can't remember any of these other survivors. I've seen all the shows ...but they all blend and meld together.....

Anyone else starting to find they all seem to fall into one great big melting pot of survivor..

Hell, I would watch just to see Rupert... of course he's not coming back on again to win another million..but for some reason I remember him clear as a bell.

Dan
southern cali

Reply

The inclusion of Parvati and Courtney guarantees I won't watch this season.

Reply

Cirie is definitely an All-Star, as is Terry.

Reply

I notice there's no winners listed, which is an interesting choice. It has to be deliberate, otherwise Tom from season 10 would have been there for sure.

And if there really are no winners in this new All-Stars, I guess that's a spoiler for Courtney and James, eh?

Reply

No previous winners? Are you kidding me? Tom is the greatest Survivor ever. Some of the names listed are some of the worst Survivors ever. Definitely not Survivor All-Stars. More like Survivor Rerun.

Reply

"its only limited to seasons 9-15 cuz they already did an allstars with seasons 1-8....thats why"

Ya. No kidding. It's a dumb idea. There just aren't enough "All-Star" caliber players to choose from in the more recent seasons. At least not for the casual viewer to recognize.

Reply

cirie!!

I agree that all stars should NOT be limited to only those who have been on since the previous all stars. OR, it should be something much more interesting. I'd like to see a version starring ONLY each and every second place winner, or, even better...each and every person who was voted out first from each season! Now that we're approaching 16 seasons, it seems like it would be so easy to have one and only one person from each season. And more exciting.

Also, didn't I read somewhere that the previous all star's psychologist said that this game should NOT be played by people with a pre-existing relationship? That was years ago but it stuck in my head. Especially after that whole thing with Kathy and that tattooed guy. (So long ago...it was mid season and there was a lot of crying.)

Reply

u ppl r so stupid, apparently u don watch the show much or are not diehard fans, if this was a real list, which im sorry but i dont think it is, johnny fairplay is most likely gonna b there, but u ppl shud realize tht list is a great list, every1 one of them worked hard to get where they got, so screw yall, they made entertainment, yea lydia was boring, but gud ppl can b boring, i love her, she has a gud heart. im a real survivor fan and every1 of them are all stars to me

Reply

Ummmm, if that indeed is the real cast I will be highly disappointed. I have watched Survivor from season 1. I get that nobody from 1-8 can come back. And No winners, which is good. But I think Stephenie LaGrossa by far DESERVES to be there over half of them. As well as Rafe from season 11. Who came up with this cast? I really hope its not right.If I was going to cast All stars 2 it would be 9-There 3 they picked just add Twila.10-Replace Ian with Bobby Jon, Quitters dont get a second chance.11-Replace Lydia with Stephenie, Rafe and Cindy.12-Perfect!13-Add Becky.14-Replace Michelle add Dreamz.15-Replace Courtney with Amanda(if she dont win) if so which I hope then fill her with Jaime. There is no way in hell I would do All Stars without Stephenie. Take Ian, Lydia, Michelle and Courtney out of there-even Julie Berry is kinda questionable. Im keeping my fingers crossed for Steph.

Reply

No way Terry is on allstars 2, he's writing blog now on survivor 15's cbs blog

See.. I wish some of the casts are right, but jonathan, katie, n lydia, i don't wish them back on the show. On the other hand, twila deserves a second chance.

Reply

That list is bogus. Just saw one on the list yesterday (Nov 7) and spoke to one last weekend. Unless they allow them to bring their cellphones to the Island this time ha.

Reply

It's great to hear that there's another All-Stars season coming out, but really, what's up with this cast list? Even if it's not definite yet, I personally can't see why some of these people are coming back (no offense if any of them happen to read this). It's just a personal opinion here, but CBS seems to be bringing back ALL of the jerks and tag-alongs that weren't in the first All-Stars list. Really - Judd and Shane, and then Lydia...Well, I love that Ian, Ozzy and Yau-Man hold a good possibility of coming back, at least.

Too bad Rafe's not on that list; he was my favorite survivor ever. But hey, that list might not be final. I can hope.

Reply

I'm actually a fan of the list, although I doubt it is close to being a final draft.

Stephanie and Bobby Jon have already played the game twice (Palau and Guatamala) so I think they've had enough oppertunities. None of the original All Stars deserve to return because, frankly, many of them played the game terribly for the second time (Richard Hatch, Colby, Ethan to mention a few. And Rupert and Tom came across as a self righteous babies their second go around!)

The only swap I would make would be add Sarge or Rory(?) from Vanuatu at the expense of Gary (Guatamala).By the way Iam from Palau kicks butt.

Reply

Cirie ! Cirie! Cirie!

Reply

YEAH JAMES!!!! I AM SOOO GLAD HE WON THE 100,000 AT THE FINALE AND THAT HE IS GOING TO BE ON THE ALLSTARS SURVIVOR----GO JAMES!!!!!

Reply