TVSquad

I feel pretty much the same as most of AOL's grades... I'd knock down Heroes and Caveman a grade. Is no one watching Criminal Minds anymore? This season has started pretty awesome...

Reply

I'm a big fan of Life. I tried to watch the Reaper pilot but it seemed too juvenile for me.

Reply

A little annoying how they allow themselves the pluses and minuses and not the rest of us. But still, I'm largely in agreement with the handful of shows I've seen (or not far off). This has been a season mostly of sort of okay shows, more than a few I enjoy watching...but I'm not sure I enjoy enough to keep coming back. The only real standouts so far, for me, have been "House" among the old and "Pushing Daisies" among the new. Lots of other decent programs, and a few really dreadful ones, but not the most exciting season of television thus far.

Reply

I'll play. Here are my grades:

Heroes B+ - I like most of the new characters, because A, they are all connected to the established characters, and B, better to kill them off than the ones from season 1. If it weren't for the lame powers that Maya and Alejandro possessed i'd bump up heroes to an A-. I think the new Monica character is awesome and so are the new older heroes. West is the only other character I don't care for. So that's 3 out of the new 7-8. Sometimes critics don't know what they're talking about.

HIMYM - A- Great show, getting back to the mother part and focusing on Marshall and Lilly is AWESOME.

30 Rock - B+ - It'd be an A if 30 Rock hadn't whored itself out to the now unfunny Jerry Seinfeld and his stupid B movie. (pun intended).

Ugly Betty - A- - Love triangles are dumb. Betty writers fell for the overused plot device.

Bionic Woman - C - I expected more from David Eick. I guess Ron Moore is the real creative force behind Battlestar because Bionic's dialgue is silly, the main character is not as interesting as the "evil" bionic woman, and Alias did the whole keeping secrets from friends thing a whole lot better.

Pushing Daisies - B - I like the concept, but Chuck is sort of annoying at times and the longevity of the show is questionable.

Chuck - B+ - I like the show and its growing on me every episode.

Prison Break - F. Couldn't get through the first episode of the season and dropped it.

Grey's - D - Burke is gone. George character is dumb. Callie character is dumb, Meridith character is dumb. Izzie character is dumb. etc. etc.

The Office - (1 hours - B) (1/2 Hours - A). The show is better as a half hour. I don't think it is as bad as the critics made it out to be.

I don't care about the rest of the shows they graded. At least not enough to agree or disagree with what AOL gave them.

Reply

I think it's been a pretty good season so far for new shows. What new shows I'm watching and enjoying: CHUCK; ALIENS IN AMERICA; JOURNEYMAN; SAMANTHA WHO?; CAVEMEN (it's really not that bad); CARPOOLERS; REAPER; PUSHING DAISIES (my favorite new show); DIRTY SEXY MONEY; BIG SHOTS; MOONLIGHT (yeah, I'm liking this one too). The one show I hated and didn't watch after episode 1 was BACK TO YOU (Patricia Heaton is so annoying). BIONIC WOMAN is a disappointment but I'm sticking with it to see what happens with the new show runner (FEMBOTS NOW!).

Returning shows I'm still with: THE SIMPSONS; DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES; BROTHERS & SISTERS; DANCING WITH THE STARS; PRISON BREAK (even in its tediousness - but looking forward to the proposed women in prison spinoff...PRISONER: CELL BLOCK H anyone?); EVERYBODY HATES CHRIS (so far not as funny as last season); HEROES (a little sluggish so far); BEAUTY AND THE GEEK; THE BIGGEST LOSER (although now that people are playing it to win money instead of improve their lives has taken some of the interest out of it); UGLY BETTY; SURVIVOR; SMALLVILLE; SUPERNATURAL; 30 ROCK; SCRUBS.

There's a lot of good stuff on off-network channels I like too: AMERICA'S MOST SMARTEST MODEL; TORCHWOOD; MEGA DISASTERS; GHOST HUNTERS; SOUTH PARK; PAGEANT PLACE; THE SOUP.

Now there's just that long wait for 24; LOST and JERICHO. Yeah, I watch a lot of TV but I actually do have a life as well!

Reply

I forgot GOSSIP GIRL! What a guilty pleasure that has turned out to be!

Reply

I'm sorry but any list that doesn't include Bones isn't worth my time.

Bones is probably the best hour long show on TV.

Reply

I watched the first 10 minutes of Pushing Daisies and was more annoyed than anything else. I love quirk, but this show just does nothing for me. Ditto for Reaper. I'm bummed that Bionic Woman didn't get a better review, Journeyman, too. Was Life even on that list, I don't think so?

Reply

They are spot on with Desperate Housewives, it has really come back into the swing of things this season and remains one of my favorite shows on tv.

Reply

I hated Pushing Daisies too, but the last 2 episodes have been quirky and not as terrible as the first few.

Reply

I think that Moonlight is one of the best new shows of the fall season! The cast is terrific and they really have a chemistry on-screen. It is actually the only show that I look forward to watching each week and classify as a "can't miss" series. In my book, it gets an "A+" grade!

Other new shows that I like are Chuck, Life, and Journeyman (although I am not sure how long this premise can last without getting redundant with him popping in and out randomly).

Reply

I don't disagree with the Heroes assessment. I've been kind of bored with this season. It's slowly getting better, but feels so scatterbrained right now. They need to get the Heroes all back on the same continent, for bleep sake.

Pushing Daisies is still very good, but I'm not as in love with it as I first was. Grey's is also still somewhat good, but is definitely losing me as the weeks go on.

The Office and Friday Night Lights have me as hooked as ever. 30 Rock is consistently great. Chuck has been a very nice surprise, as has Reaper and The Big Bang Theory. I can't believe I'm actually watching a CBS show again.

There's a few shows I'm disappointed they left off, however, I'm sure they were left off because they're not on basic cable. Regardless, It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia and South Park are having amazing seasons, once again. Sunny is just flat out excellent, there's no two ways about it. South Park continues to stretch the limits, and hit a home run with Imaginationland.

However, Life is a network show, yet it was inexplicably left off the list. Why, I don't know, because it's one of my favorite new shows of the year, and really gets better every week.

Reply

I tried to watch Back To You once and was sorely disappointed. Big Bang Theory, on the other hand, is pretty cliched but highly entertaining. To me, it's the biggest surprise of the year.

The other shows I watch/graded: 30 Rock, A; Chuck, B.

Reply

Oh yeah, and The Office gets a C from me.

Reply

Last word from me, I promise: Anyone who didn't catch Mad Men on AMC this summer missed out on something very special. A+.

Reply

I love this show. The actors are very handsome. Seems one of them has posted his personal ad to a celebrities dating site for several months. That site called http://searchingmillionaire.com. I just visited his profile page yesterday, seems he has not logged in recently.

Reply

The show I'm most disappointed in is Reaper, it's not the worst but I had high hopes for it. Someone previously mentioned how they thought it was juvenile, personally I don't think it's juvenile enough. I think it needs to embrace how absurd the premise is and amp up the funny. I had hopes that it would be very view-askew-esque (especially with Kevin Smith directing) but so far it isn't very funny and the hunting of the souls is predictable.

I've commented previously how I see Ghostbusters as being a good template for how Reaper could work and I think it holds true. The scenes where they kitted themselves out in the gear from their work really reminded it of me and I'd personally like to see things be a bit more "wacky" (for want of a better word), the devil is a great character but I feel they could make more of him, have him toy with Sam more.

Reply

I have enjoyed "Private Practice" more and more lately. "Pushing Daisies" had me hooked but I don't think it will last because of the premise; it's visual quality is new and different. It's only been on for 3 episodes but "Samantha Who?" has been fun to watch. I'm a little disappointed with "Back to You" and "Bionic Woman" but only because of the hype. I think BTY is a decent show; it has a good pedigree but it needs to find its legs. BW seems to meander and it has an outstanding supporting cast but the lead part may be it's downfall (no offense to Ms. Ryan.)
I choose to grade only the recurring shows that I watch because I have something to compare it to:

30 Rock A+
The Office A
ER B+ (This show is still, surprisingly, really good!)
Desperate Housewives B+ (Wow what a turnaround.)
Boston Legal B+
Brothers & Sisters B
Grey's Anatomy C (This show has lost its magic.)
Heroes D (I'm done with this one.)

Reply

Three words...Big Bang Theory. It is consistently one of the funniest shows on tv right now. Watch this people it really needs to return next year.

The 4 guys in that show are very, very funny.

Reply

I really love Life and Dirty Sexy Money (although I hate the title of the latter, they couldn't come up with something better for this show?). Two great new shows. I refuse to even watch 30 seconds of the extended Geiko Insurance commercial that is Cavemen. Big Bang Theory is entertaining, the two nerds are done very well and have a unique chemistry. I sure hope Life and DSM stick around.

Prison Break has been destroyed solely due to Sarah Wayne Callie's decision to get knocked up and leave the show to be a full time mommy. Unlike every other actress, she apparently can't afford a nanny to take care of her baby (either at home or in her on-set trailer) while she does her scenes. Traylor Howard didn't quit Monk when she got pregnant. She didn't even take a leave of absence. I don't see why they don't have mandatory abortion clauses in the contracts of TV show actresses (who voluntarily accept their roles, keep in mind).

30 Rock is still great (except for the Bee Movie crap, I agree, I'm sick of Seinfeld whoring himself out for this idiotic crap). Ugly Betty is still really good, too.

I think Private Practice is fairly decent, although very derivative of Grey's Anatomy, though maybe that's their goal. Addison has always been one of my favorite chars on GA, and I find myself entertained during the hour of PP, though the show certainly has its flaws (primarily in some of the characters).

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia has been great so far this season. By far the edgiest, funniest show on TV (with 30 Rock far but directly behind it).

Chuck has been good so far, though it is in serious danger of getting old real quick. The next episode sounds like it may break the monotony, though.

Reply