TVSquad

one thing that always bothers me is that when the gold star recipient goes to call their parents, there's a camera crew at their parents' house. Huh? suposedly the council has just made the decision and the winner has just run off to make the call. What is that, like 5 minutes top between the council making their decision and the phone call. It just so blatently defies the "reality" of the show that it makes me want to shut it off.

Reply

@ plinstrot

Think about how long they have already been in production. That gives them quite a bit of time to track these people down. if they aren't already on call...

Reply

The green captain's lips have been bothering me since the second episode, it's out of control.

Reply

Depending on when they filmed the show, Cody could actually have been in third grade. I was more than a little disturbed by the fact that part of his girlfriend's letter was censored - what are 9-year-olds writing about? (When they showed a close-up I realized it was her address but for a moment I had a horrible flash of a Lifetime movie in the pipeline.

Laurel's the only person who seems to deserve her spot on the council. Taylor's a brat, Mike's more interested in making sure no one ignores him or is mean to him than he is in the welfare of the town and Anjay's just too passive to do much leading. He spends most of the decision making meetings with a scared look on his face.

Maybe it would be for the best if they all were replaced. My picks? Sophia for the green, Greg for the blue, Jared for the red and Zach for the yellow. (Anything that gets more screentime for Jared is OK with me, Sophia v Greg would be hilarious and Zach is probably the only person on the yellow team who gives a rats rear about the town.)

Reply

I had the same concerns about the chapped lips; when was this filmed? The children are bundled up most of the time and look cold, so it must have been in winter, and they got some snow as well. So, maybe the chapped lips are from cold exposure, or maybe just not used to the New Mexico sun? In any case, I am surprised this is not being taken care of, chapstick with sunscreen anyone? And if this was filmed in winter, how did the kids get out of school for this long?

I too was amused that when the gold star kid calls home a film crew is at the house; maybe there is a camera crew on call in every kids town.

I thought this show would be really good; kids given a chance to make decisions, with some thoughtful guidance, but instead we have adults forcing the kids into groups and manipulating the kids into difficult situations, and watching their reactions; what is to be gained from this?

I doubt if kids would have divided the town into color groups and a caste system; in fact, I bet the kids would have chosen the best cooks to be the cooks, it would have been nice to see what they would have done.

Religion: Tonight's show was the best so far; the kids handled a difficult situation very well. Manipulated? Probably parts of it, like the argument about Jews and Christians, but I'd like to think the prayers were sincere. Zack's prayer, sung in Hebrew, was especially touching, and the other kids respected him. Kids tend to be tolerant of others, maybe not because of a noble nature, perhaps only because they want to fit in with the group. Children speak what they hear their parents say and when the see the result of their words, it has an effect, their own minds are still formulating their characters. Maybe that's part of what we saw tonight; kids arguing about religion and then coming together in prayer. We could all learn from this.

Mike, the council leader: He's all of 11 years old, give the child a break. He really does care, he's sensitive and passionate, he tends to shout because he is insecure in being a leader of older kids. I see in Mike a boy who will defend his friends, stand up for what's right, and cry with someone who's hurting. A good kid overwhelmed by his position. Zack is a better leader, but Mike's passion makes him a good council member, a voice from the heart.

Reply

Being addicted to chapstick myself :), it does pain me to see that those kids need some chapstick. Maybe that could be a reward? Or they could sell it in the store.

I personally don't like Taylor, and I am hoping she gets replaced. I also really like Jared one-liners.

Next episode has snow, so I would guess it was filmed during the winter.

Reply

I love this show. Only one I can actually watch with my kids. Do I think all of it is unplanned by adults? Of course not! But I love the kids and their confessionals and the kids tend to make the right decisions for everyone. Imagine that!

Reply

I've been waiting for this moment, ever since the show aired. Beautiful!. My hat goes off to whomever is responsible for this show. If I had my way, every child in this world would have to go through this, before graduating from school. I would cover all bets, to say that if all children, went through this, it would be a better world. This is what it takes to live in this world, instead of all the games, etc. "Nothing like hard knocks, to knock some sense into some one".

Reply

Nobody mentioned the one kid taking the survey of what religion everyone was. He knew more about religious denominations than I do!

Reply

yeah anyone who is mystified on how they get a camera crew to the parents house so quickly needs to get a clue. For those who dont know CBS is a large company with many different local affiliates [/sarcasm]. Its not like they have to send an official member of the "KIDNATION PRODUCTION TEAM" out to the house. They just send out one of the camera guys from the local news team and probably get the whole thing done in 15-30 minutes.
What makes us think that they do the phone call exactly when they are presenting it to us either?

Another thing i dont understand is how/why people are so up in arms over the journal. Going into this show did people really thing it was gonna be a lord of the flies, free for all? I mean if this television show was going to work at all they were going to need direction from adults.

"Tune into next weeks kidnation when some of the kids play duck,duck,goose and all the others just kinda lay around."

That is the type of riveting entertainemnt we would be seeing if the producers didnt try to get some type of controversy brewing. Now i am not going to give the producers a 100% pass on some the other stuff though. For instance, do we really believe that this bonfire service was 100% morgans idea. If they were letting these kids play with fire, build bonfires, dont we all think that (the one who looks like cody, got in the bull stare down last week), greg, and/or blaine would be out there every night building one.

The final thing i anted to touch on, and was very surprised it wasnt touched on earlier was the strong anti-jew feelings that came from many of the kids on the show. Im sure there was more than one parent that had to have a long sit down chat with their child on what can/cant/should/shouldnt be said about others and their beliefs (and hopefully they also told that one girl to stop picking at what ever that was on the left side of her face).

Reply

whoops wanted to add two more quick thoughts...

1)was it just me or did anyone else not understand why there was such blind fury to the leaders idea of a group celebration compared to the celebration that came with morgans invite.

I also found it interesting that the kids who were raising the biggest stink about the group service were not saying that they would be offended but they thought "others would start fighting". From where I sat you guys (i wont mention their religion) were the only ones who had a problem with it.


2) the kid who was taking the survey... is it just me or do those dark glasses he wears make him look like a panda.

Reply

It just amazes me that grown people don't give children a chance to see what their failures or strengths are without adding so much of their own beliefs. Where do you think children get their racisism and judgements from? give them a chance. I would definetly have sent my child to this program. Just remember all experiences are learning experiences and helps one to grow-comon adults you were a child once-i enjoy kidnations..ty

Reply

Yeah. I've gotta admit that I was wondering too about the little angels with dirty faces. :-) They definitely need someone to tell them to clean their faces and moisturize. I mean, even that little evil beauty queen Taylor has a dirty face ! Is it because of the dust bowl? Right after the challenges or what?

Also, I definitely agree. Little Miss Taylor definitely has to be taken down a peg or two. Can't wait for that new election. I'd really like to see Sophia and maybe even Greg -- the older kids in on the action.

That Jared and the Asian kid with the one tooth are such cuties. Great one liner artists. But where was Jared's famous person quote of the week this past episode? I always have something to look forward to when he's on.

Well. That's my take. I love this show. And I'm really starting to love these kids -- even the ones who get on my nerves. They all seem to be doing the right thing each week -- putting many an adult to shame, I'm afraid.

Can't wait to see Greg finally get that Gold Star. I just hope he doesn't act out too much before he gets it as an excuse for the others to not give it to him -- exactly what Mike wants, I'm sure.

-- KNFan

Reply

From what i have seen on this show it is remindz of survivor....the 1st show was good but after that 19 more were made and now it is getting old. I think if they only make 1 show a year like this it will be good. Personally I think all reality shows are staged and the people are told what do when to do it to make the show apeal. I mean think about it.....ask anyone who has really been in a survival situation like survivor....they eat way to much and drink way to much...plus do u think the camera men eat nasty crap like they eat? No way...lol. Anywayz i like kid nation alot better than survivor... so thumbs up!!! for the time being.

Reply

i haven't watched this week's episode yet. But i really think Greg deserves the gold star. It irritates me that Mike won't give it to him just because he doesn't like him. If mike is truly a leader he will give it to the person who deserves it.

Reply

I think these kids are doing a great job. I would say they were chosen because they showed potential to do above average when placed in a situation where they have to use critical thinking skills. Greg does deserve to get a gold star based upon his work ethics, but he needs to keep his cool for a little while longer before it is issued. There are other kids on who haven't cussed anyone out. Maybe they should be considered first. Taylor definitely is not representing when it comes to "miss anything" contestants. The main concern I would have is food poisoning. The dishes need some HOT soapy water! Hats off to the ones trying to keep it clean. Tearjerker, yes, at times. The calls would be very boring if we could not see the parents response when their child received that gold star. I believe my kids could have done this when they were younger, but I am not so sure I would have survived! I loved it when they got the books and realized that Christianity is founded in the Jewish religion. They were reading and noticed, the "beginning" was almost the same. lol This was such a powerful step for unity.

Reply

Taylor and Mike NEED to be voted off the Town Council.

Taylor is garbage, she shouldn't even be on the show. She never wants to do anything. She definitely has to be off the Council.

Mike needs to go too. He's very annoying AND no matter what he hates Greg and has a huge bias against him.

I personally think Greg has been deserving the gold star for a long time and could really use it. I fear he will become a loser without that money to help pay for college, which he mentioned is why he wants it.

Also, am I the ONLY one bothered by how they drink root beer? Root beer is fine, but shot glasses? Chugging at the "party" past week? It's almost as if they are being groomed to substitute root beer for real alcohol in a couple of years. That has bothered me more than anything on the show.

Reply

I agree, Ty. Running off to drown your sorrows in root beer, or taking root beer shots feels wrong and disturbing.
I think Greg will get the last gold star. If they give it to him now, he will stop trying for it and revert to his previous bad behavior. Also if kids get elected to the council next week, that takes them out of the running for the star since the council can't give it to themselves.

Reply

I was disappointed in the way that the host presented the election results in the Mike-Guylan race. Mike received one vote, obviously he voted for himself. And Guylan received all of the other votes. Was it really necessary to continue to read all of the remaining votes after Guylan had scored the necessary majority? On Survivor, with adults, when a majority is reached in the voting, they do not continue with the remaining votes. Certainly, Mike did not deserve the humiliation of the revealing of the unanimous decision against him.

Reply

Ok so how did yall sign up for this kid nation cuz me and my sister would like to sign up cuz we think we got what it takes we are hard workers

Reply