In my review of The Office last week, I called Ryan one of the best villains on TV today. I thought it was obvious that the producers were taking Ryan in this direction and that my comment was a compliment to the fine acting and writing on the show. I was met with a bit of resistance, however. Some of our readers felt that Ryan's ideas made a lot of sense and that, if anything, Michael's overall incompetence is the real villain on the show. I thought a post was in order to further explain why I thought Ryan was a villain. And what's the best way to explain a point? Well, considering the direction that the internet is moving, the answer is, of course, a numbered list! The nine reasons why Ryan is a villain after the jump.
Note, the following list will be presented as a list of "Don'ts". It's a lot more fun if you read this aloud to yourself mimicking a 1950's-type film-strip voice. This is not a good idea, by the way, if you're currently at work.
1. Don't use your BlackBerry while your coworkers are talking to you. Yes, we know you're more important than the rest of the world and that if you don't finish click-clacking out your short electronic directives the entire company might come crashing down around you, but please, if someone is taking the time to talk to you, the correct thing to do is to put the BlackBerry down, make eye contact with that person, and give them some kind of human-type greeting. Putting up a finger -- like Ryan did to Pam at the beginning of last week's episode -- does not make you seem mature or important or imposing, it makes you look like a world class D-Bag.
2. Don't use someone's work-related dreams to try and bed them. Listen, we'd all like to have sex with Pam Beesly; I don't blame you for trying. Ryan's approach, however, was despicable. Using his knowledge of Pam's art aspirations, he asked her to work on a new logo for Dunder-Mifflin Infinity. When she finished her designs, he asked her if she wanted to talk about them "over dinner," his motives as visible as Dabney Coleman's mustache in 9 to 5. This is how evil people try to get secretaries into bed. Good people do it by superciliously raising their eyebrows, having mussy hair, and playing a series of ridiculous pranks on their co-workers.
3. Don't spend more then $40 on a haircut. Unless you're a girl getting ready for the prom or a woman getting ready for her wedding, spending any more than $40 on a haircut is not only dumb, it's the reason why the rest of the world hates us. You would think that Ryan, a self-proclaimed wunderkind, would have heard of the law of diminishing returns. Seriously, if you want to send a message with your haircut, it'd be cheaper and more direct to simply have "D-Bag" shaved in the back of your head.
4. Don't use the word "young" as a synonym for "better". Ryan's plan for Dunder-Mifflin isn't a bad one -- he wants to get it a website to better serve its customers -- it's the implication of it that makes him so villainous. I'm 31, so my annoyance with his statement isn't personal (yet), I just feel that people are still valuable even over the age of 40. While I'm all for new ideas, being younger doesn't necessarily make you better. Hang out at your local mall on a Friday night the next time you want to get an idea of what the younger generation is up to.
5. Don't grow a beard to look older. There are only four acceptable purposes for growing a beard: 1) You have a weak chin and are trying to hide it. 2) You're a college professor. 3) You live in the 19th century. 4) You've just accidentally killed Santa Claus and are magically turning into the new Santa Claus. Ryan is growing one to look older (while, ironically, is trying to make the company "younger") and that makes him a D-Bag.
6. Don't dress all in black. Ryan's new promotion meant a new wardrobe. When he showed up at Dunder Mifflin, he was dressed all in black for no justifiable reason. There are only two jobs that require you to be dressed all in black: Supreme Court Justice and Sith Lord (here's an interesting bit of trivia: Antonin Scalia is the only person to have held both positions). People who dress all in black are trying to look cool and people who are trying to look cool are obviously D-bags.
7. Don't date someone at your office simply because you have nothing better to do. I think the Ryan-Kelly relationship is really the turning point for what the Ryan character eventually turned into. Early in the show's run he was simply a character type -- the temp who never seems to leave. His initial involvement with Kelly became a symbol of his own personal fear: being trapped at Dunder-Mifflin as a temp forever. Initially we sympathized with Ryan and disliked Kelly because, well, you know, Kelly is annoying as hell. As time went on, however, and we saw how Ryan treated her, our feelings changed. Kelly was annoying, yes, but she was devoted and loving. Ryan, on the other hand, was just killing time. When he got the call to corporate, he callously threw her aside with a "We're through." Funny, yes, but those are not the words of a likable character; they're the words of a villainous D-bag.
8. Don't brag about how easy it is to get sandwiches in New York City. If you work at a branch office and are promoted to a big city, when you go back to the branch office for the first time, just assume everyone knows that it's easier to get various exotic foodstuffs in the big city. Ryan bragged in the episode that he and his new D-bag friends went to get a sandwich "even though it was 2 AM, but you can do that in the city" as if Andy and Kevin had never heard of New York. The only reason to bring it up is because you want to make people whose only all-night food options are microwaved burritos at a gas-station convenience store feel bad about themselves. And if you do that you're a D-bag.
9. Don't think that a promotion in your job is a promotion in your character. Ryan always felt that he was better than the people he worked with and when he got promoted, he felt that his belief was justified. It's not, however; it never is. Your character is separate from your job title. It is this reason that while a lot of what Ryan says actually makes sense -- especially his comments about the time wasted at the branch office -- we look at him as the villain. The Office is like a family: it's painful to be in it, the other people annoy the hell out of you, most of your time is spent trying to get away from it, but also you hate anyone telling you what's wrong with yours. Anyone who does is a villain. A villainous D-bag!
As always, feel free to tell me what a villainous D-bag I am in the comments.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
10-09-2007 @ 11:33AM
KMF said...
Hilarious list. I was laughing all the way through.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 11:38AM
boomfoxx said...
He wasn't a "self-proclaimed wunderkind". He said that people started calling him a wunderkind, but he didn't know what it meant.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 11:43AM
J said...
Great list. Reminded me of the two funniest moments of the ep this week with Kelly. Her saying she was pregnant - and the cut to her shaking her head no - had me almost rolling on the floor. And the second when Ryan was trying to outsource customer service to India..yes Kelly is Indian..priceless. He plays the role of D-bag pretty well I would say.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 11:45AM
Josh said...
I can agree that he is a d-bag on the show, but please for the love of god leave beards out of it...
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:00PM
annacsmith08 said...
Great list! I totally agree!
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:01PM
Mel said...
How can anyone dispute that he is a douchebag? He's the very definition. I know, cause it takes one to know one.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:04PM
Jeremy Tucker said...
I couldn't agree more about #9. He got promoted, yet he NEVER made a sale while he was working in the Scranton branch. I think his undeserved sense of accomplishment due to failing upwards is definitely a reason why he's now a full-fledged D-bag [insert link to Wikipedia page on Jeff Zucker here].
Great list, by the way!
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:14PM
BStu said...
I think both sides are right in a way. Ryan's ideas are good and he has a solid business sense with regards to the direction DM needs to go. But he's also obviously a d-bag for all of the reasons you list. Its going to be interesting to have that dynamic, I think. Especially since Michael is responding to him in the exact opposite way that he should. He thinks he's a great person, but has awful ideas. Its a brilliant set-up.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:24PM
B said...
On the Ryan-Kelly relationship, don't forget that Kelly lied at the begining and said she wasn't looking for something serious. And at the end she lied about being pregnant. Clearly, there wasn't just one douchebag in that relationship. As for Ryan vs Michael, at least Ryan is doing something to save the company, whereas Michael's incompetence should have ended with the Scranton branch closing years ago.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:24PM
Chip said...
He didn't say he didn't know what wunderkind meant, he said he didn't know why people were calling him that. Then he said actually he does. Which is something a D-bag does.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:37PM
Jim said...
Some good arguments, Jay, but I still have to disagree with you. Look at the truly villainous people in the office and you can make your list even longer:
* Don't kill a cat, especially if it's your girlfriend's.
* Don't tell your ex-boyfiend that you're pregnant just to get him to spend time with you.
* Don't [insert any of the idiotic things Michael does every week].
* Don't [insert any of the sadistic things Creed does every week].
I said it before, I'll say it again: Ryan is the voice of reason in the office. Don't be fooled by the black clothes and facial hair.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:38PM
Billy Pilgrim said...
This reminds me of a brilliant sketch by George Carlin: a game show called "Asshole, Jack-off, Scumbag" where contestants would have to identify certain people by one of those defining characteristics.
Just as there are subtle differences between an asshole, a jack-off, and a scumbag, there are nuances that divide a villain and a douchebag that need to be addressed.
This is a very important point this week because Saturday Night Live didn't fully capture the essence of douchebaggery in its "Douchebag of The Year Awards". (I mean, not one member of the Bush Administration was a top 3 finalist. Seems like sloppy writing to me).
Taking your 9, here's where I see Ryan falling on the road from Douchebag to Villain:
1. Using BlackBerry while your coworkers are talking to you. Douchebag
2. Don't use someone's work-related dreams to try and bed them. Villain
3. Don't spend more then $40 on a haircut. Douchebag
4. Don't use the word "young" as a synonym for "better". Toughy but have to go for Douchebag.
5. Don't grow a beard to look older. Easy- Douchebag
6. Don't dress all in black. Classic villain motif.
7. Don't date someone at your office simply because you have nothing better to do.
While Ryan is a class A douchebag on his ladder toward villain, this is perhaps the only Human characteristic he displays as Kelly is the only thing that makes us feel sorry for him.
8. Don't brag about how easy it is to get sandwiches in New York City. Classic Douchebag conversation filler.
9. Don't think that a promotion in your job is a promotion in your character. Villain. The villains biggest asset and biggest pitfall is his ego.
PS: Please don't confuse "then" and "than". (OMG I'm such a dbag)
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:42PM
Chris W said...
Nice list, man. You really have become the flame-bait of this blog. Bob Sassone must be celebrating like crazy.
I agree that Ryan's a d-bag, but he's a long shot away from becoming a villain. He's too "young" and "naive" to really be a villain; his attitude will just bite him in the ass. The writers will find away to knock him down a peg this season.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:52PM
Matt said...
Totally agree. I love hating the Ryan character.
Hopefully he pops up more this season, just so I have someone to vilify.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 12:59PM
jpn said...
It's interesting....he's sort of cocky, with the whole $200 haircut thing, stories about Vince Vaughn, sandwich at 2 AM, Scranton suits you, blah blah. I think definitely supposed to have become a jerk/douchebag. The "heroes" (Jim/Pam/etc.) seem to also have more of a tolerance for Michael's mistakes...a little big of caring, etc.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 1:30PM
martin said...
I completely agree with all of your points (though you forgot the part where he asked Karen out then lied to Kelly) but another thing to do that proves your a D-bag is to make a top 9 list instead of an even 10!!!
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 1:40PM
YouFaceTheTick said...
Funny list but I still like the Ryan character way more than most of the losers on the show (and those hour long episodes are 30 minutes too long). He's only one who has actually worked to achieve anything. I can't fathom why any person would ever be interested in Pam...golly a wholesome, plain girl with low self-esteem is so hot - if you also suffer from low self esteem and have no interest in attracting a mate that's actually interesting.
I see nothing wrong with the way Ryan treats Kelly. She was a fling. Let it go. People have flings. Mature people walk away. Idiots like Kelly cling and moan. I want to grab her and yell, "Hey grow up, he's not into you, tool."
Ryan wants the branch to be run efficiently and wants to generate revenue. michael and his band of idiots stand in the way. What kind of boss would put up with michael scott? Beyond a desperate divorcee?
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 1:44PM
YouFaceTheTick said...
I agree with Jim's post - Ryan is the voice of reason at that office.
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 1:51PM
Eric said...
A lot of his D-baggery was foreshadowed with his relationship with Kelly, but there were much bigger signs to this last season: Not giving up the desk to Jim when Jim returned to Scranton, and the presentation he did on Dunder-Mifflin in front of Micheal
Reply
10-09-2007 @ 2:40PM
J Stein said...
I'm going with D-bag, but not villain and certainly not a voice of reason. He didn't work to get where he is (he got a dimestore MBA) and never made one sale. He's young and cocky, so he thinks he has all the answers. He has a few good ideas (which are really "me-too" ideas stolen from big-box competitors), and if he wasn't into Kelly, he should have manned up and broken it off a while back, not while he was headed out the door. And who the hell asks out a co-worker via E-mail? While dating another co-worker?
No, B.J. Novak is playing one hell of a D-bag. No way he makes it to season 4 still in corporate. 10-1 he ends up a temp in Scranton again.
"Then he went back to what is now known as the former Yugoslavia." It's lines like that that tell you what damn fine writing they have on that show.
Reply