When we first announced that Mandy Patinkin was leaving Criminal Minds, fans were pretty devastated. A lot of commenters felt no one could replace him and some even said they wouldn't watch the show without him. Today, there's word that actor Harvey Keitel is in negotiations to replace Patinkin on the popular series. Keitel is a pretty heavy hitter, but will he be enough to keep fans tuning in?Keitel will no doubt bring a much different feel to the show. Patinkin's character was rather subdued and kind-of morose, but I don't see that coming from Harvey Keitel. And, who would want that anyway? A new character needs to bring something new to the table. (Geena Davis was reportedly in negotiations for Patinkin's role but those broke down last month)
Would Keitel make an adequate replacement for Patinkin?
**TV Guide says the deal is "no longer on the table." Keitel joins the long list of celebrities who considered--and then decided against--joining the show: Geena Davis, Michael Keaton, and Bob Hoskins.
Doctor Who panel - Comic-Con Report
NBC's Kings panel - Comic-Con Report
The Dharma Initiative wants you - VIDEO - Comic-Con Report
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-09-2007 @ 1:25PM
Jo said...
Wow! It would be great to see Keitel on a regular basis; perfect casting.
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 1:54PM
Jimmy said...
Genna Davis would have been fantastic; another strong female presence is needed on this show. Harvey Keitel? Eh.
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 2:01PM
Tony Burgess said...
If they have a problem getting Keitel I have a few suggestions...
Cary Elwes (of Princess Bride and Twister)
Avery Brooks (of Spenser for Hire, Star Trek:DS9)
Paul McCrane (Dr. Ramano from ER)
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 2:29PM
D. said...
I think Keitel is a GREAT CHOICE!!! Bring in him in.
And the person who said that Geena Davis would have been perfect: BLECH. She's a horrible actress, with the exception of Beetlejuice.
And also, The BAU is a boys club. They have three women on the show already. Don't need to add more, cause it will be unrealistic.
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 2:53PM
jesssier said...
Great Great Great casting Get Harvey casted I'm so excited I don't know what to say.
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 3:11PM
Adam Carter said...
I agree with 'D' - i also think harvey would be great - i was terrified at first with the whole geena davis thing - that would have been god-awful.
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 4:36PM
Eirik said...
I'm not worried about the cast changes. I always watched the show as an ensemble, and Patankin hasn't even played the most interesting character to me.
Unless his departure really messes up the chemistry of things, I'll keep watching.
Reply
8-12-2007 @ 1:12AM
Flutesong said...
I wish it had worked out with Harvey Keitel.
I think he is a wonderful actor and could have played gruff/intelligent/empathetic very well. I would love to see him on TV regularly as well, which would be a new thing for him entirely.
I certainly hope they do get a “heavy-hitter” on the show as it is very good and deserves someone who will add even more clout to the ensemble. While the show is certainly character driven, as we see one or another of the team affected by each ongoing case, I hope they stick to the unsub being the most interesting part of each episode. I am sure there are enough weird and bizarre things left for the crazies to commit for many seasons to come.
Reply