(S06E08) I enjoyed this episode tonight, with the loopy Elaine and the Clive Owen-look-alike Homeland Security officer. I also enjoyed this episode way back in Season 2 when it was called "Precipitate." In that episode, Johnny had a blood transfusion with the blood of six different people. He had a vision that one of them was going to die, unless he intervened. So, he and Bruce ran around, tracked down all of the blood donors, and made their lives better so the tragedy didn't happen. It was a great episode.Tonight, instead of Bruce, we have Sara's loopy friend Elaine, who is still single in her thirties and designs crossword puzzles for a living. She's kind of cute when she takes her glasses off for the Homeland Security guy, who seems lonely and perhaps a bit lacking in boundaries. However, the fact that she never puts her glasses back on begs the question of why she needs them to begin with (just kidding, she probably just needs them for reading).
Johnny, of course, has a vision at the bus station of an explosion. True to form, as we have already seen in, oh, every episode for six seasons, including "Precipitate," Johnny would not be Johnny if he didn't try to stop the tragedy from happening.
What saves this episode from being a repeat of an earlier season is that his vision actually plays a trick on him: His vision is dependent on his own better nature in order for the tragedy to occur. Elaine is on the right track when she ways that all puzzles have a pattern. The common thread of this puzzle is that for every person Johnny suspects, he ends up helping that person-- and their loved ones. Helping those people brings him to the next suspects, until finally, all of Johnny and Elaine's wacky running around causes the Homeland Security guy to be curious about what the hell they are doing. This episode was the very epitome of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
However, it raises a good question. If Johnny had just walked away from the situation, from the vision he had seen transpire, it was guaranteed not to happen. Johnny's poking around was the very thing that almost caused the explosion to happen. His meddling, if you will. However, as Elaine points out, his meddling also positively affected each of the lives he meddled in. Not that it would have done them any good if they had blown up though. It's an interesting dilemma.
But I think the key is that his propensity for visions and meddling is causing him not to move his relationship forward, as Elaine tells him. Sara is wondering why he isn't moving. Don't they both want this? Haven't they always wanted it? Johnny lost Sara when he was in his coma, but he gained his ability. He lost true love, but has helped countless people. So, if he has to choose between Sara and his own ability (or, moreover, his own nature to help and not to simply ignore his visions), what will he choose? Will he become the author of his own dysfunction? Or will he choose a family life that can bring him real happiness? Does the world need the talents of Johnny Smith? Does the world need them full-time? At one point this episode, I muttered, "Just stop touching things! Wear gloves!" and that was even before I knew how meta the episode and vision really were.
However, my real question of the evening is this: My close-captioning and two rewindings caught Johnny saying to J.J. as he left the house, "Goodbye Anthony." Did anybody else catch that? What on earth? Was that just funky captioning, or was Anthony Michael Hall (who goes by Michael from what I've read) playing around a bit?















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-07-2007 @ 1:14AM
ral said...
when johnny first thought about telling the security officer, his vision showed him detained until about 3 seconds before the explosion.
so, is this a major gaff or does this show that regardless of johnny, we would've had an explosion?
Reply
8-07-2007 @ 1:30AM
BigTed said...
Ral, I think you're right.
There's also a major time-loop paradox here: If Johnny hadn't had the vision of the explosion, he would have left the station and the explosion wouldn't have happened -- so what caused the vision in the first place?
It seems as if the writers aren't bothering to think these things through much anymore.
Reply
8-07-2007 @ 4:43AM
MrC said...
It's quite possible Johnny's escape from detention would have resulted in a collision with homelandsecuritydude and still precipitated the explosion of wheelchairgirl.
BTW, Elaine was played by the lovely Maxim Roy of the underrated (and never aired in the states) Regenesis (at least the first 2 seasons were good, the 3rd, well, I'm not sure how I felt about that)
Reply
8-07-2007 @ 9:41AM
Jon88 said...
Johnny definitely didn't say "Anthony," so either the captioner was doing a shout-out or, more likely, it was just a screw-up.
I strongly recommend watching all shows with captioning on. The entertainment value is very high, almost like watching an altogether different show. For instance, whoever is captioning "Mad Men" is working without a script, and is too young to grasp many of the references. I'm here to tell you that, in 1960, nobody was living in fear that Russia would drop "the bum." (More seriously, captioning often yields additional dialogue that was cut for broadcast or was changed very late, among other benefits.)
Reply
8-07-2007 @ 11:29AM
Happy Steve said...
it's somewhat possible that something completely unrelated would have caused the officer's gun to fall out the holster and hit the tank anyway. that seems to be the only other explanation.
Yeah, I definitely thought of that other episode when watching this. But still, it's really nice that Johnny had a "sidekick" again to help him along... now that Bruce is gone, the reverend is gone, and the new sheriff is more of a hindrance for now. Hey, where did everybody go?
Reply
8-07-2007 @ 1:15PM
Jon88 said...
TV Production 101: Negotiate contracts with your regular cast that include a clause wherein they don't get paid for episodes in which they don't appear, and then leave them out of as many episodes as you can.
Reply
8-09-2007 @ 8:23PM
Jo said...
I think Johnny said "Goodbye Handsome", because J.J. had just made a comment about Sara looking beautiful and happy.
Reply