
All four programs aim to make the experience of watching online video easier. Web browsers were really designed for viewing text and images, not video. A side benefit is that most of these programs are also welcome additions to an HTPC.
In a nutshell, here's what Mashable found:
- VeohTV has a well designed, easy to use interface and a wide selection of content. But the channels aren't well organized, making it hard to find what you're looking for.
- Babelgum has an excellent design, but very little content.
- Joost has a good balance of decent content and a good layout, but it takes a reasonably fast computer to run.
- Democracy can access almost any video on the web. The downside is you need to download video, there's no streaming capability.
I'll agree with all of those points. I beg to differ with Mashable's decision that Democracy was the best of the bunch. Of course, this is going to be a matter of taste, but I'd go with Joost for now.
The main thing to consider before choosing a video application is what you want from it. Do you want a full screen viewing experience? Do you want to be able to read information about TV shows while watching them?
I'm primarily looking for a program that can run on my home theater PC. Right now I'm getting video content in my living room primarily from a digital antenna and Windows Media Center's online spotlight. Joost, VeohTV, and Babelgum can all help. Democracy just doesn't work that well without a keyboard. If I want to download programs to view on my HTPC, I can use TV Tonic, which integrates with Windows Media Center.
I really like the content available from VeohTV. It includes full length streaming TV episodes from CBS, Fox, NBC, and the CW, as well as tons of short user-generated clips. But the beta software doesn't play well with my Firefly remote control, and wants to start in full screen every time I boot my computer even when I disable the option to start when Windows starts.
I agree that the biggest problem with Babelgum is lack of content right now. And that's why the one program of these four that's earned a permanent place on my HTPC is Joost. It works (most of the time) with my remote control. It's got a great full-screen channel guide. And it's got a reasonable amount of content including comedy, science fiction programs, news, cartoons, and music videos.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-26-2007 @ 2:00PM
Wilson said...
What do you guys think of Roo.
Reply
6-26-2007 @ 10:15PM
Greg said...
I can't agree about Joost. I've tried it several times and the video as so choppy it was un-watchable. I went to the forums and found my system was more than enough to run it. I have 7mbit/sec transfer rates so I have to assume that Joost isn't near mature enought to be serious.
I also just tried to run Joost again to see if things were any better since last week...at least I know the crash reporting system is working. But that's all I can tell. Its just not a real product yet.
Reply
6-26-2007 @ 10:19PM
Brad Linder said...
Greg: have you tried the other programs? I agree, Joost has still got some kinks to work out, but in my experience I've found it the best of these 4 programs (at least for viewing media on a big screen. Democracy might have the edge on a standard PC). I'd be curious to hear if the other programs run better on your system.
Reply
6-26-2007 @ 10:47PM
Topmoo said...
I used to use Joost on earlier versions and found that it's only been choppy lately since the surge of users. It used to be very nice but had no content, now with content it's got too many users to work as good as it did. I like it with my Media Center PC, wish they'd make a MCE plugin Ap.
topmoo
Reply
6-27-2007 @ 1:23AM
JOm said...
Can anyone comment on Vuze?
Reply