TVSquad

We are down to the finals where all are pretty much good singers, although a certain few DO stand out as exceptional. If VFTW stands behind anybody at this point in time, I swear I will never vote again, maybe not even watch the show because it is just too heartbreaking to see the talent and hard work that these kids put forth just to have an asshole like Howard Stern throw it back in their faces. So you don't like Simon, big friggin, deal, this show is NOT about Simon, it's bout giving the kids a chance to realize their dreams. Stern realized his, now its time to back off and give someone else a chance to realize theirs.
I personally stand behind Jordon, and I have since the very beginning. I voted for 2 hours last night and I was only able to get in 9 votes so I'm sure she isn't going anywhere tonight. And as far as lakisha goes, that's just it, she should go. I'm hoping for a Jordon-Blake-Melinda final, with Jordon coming out on top.

Reply

Jordin & Melinda seem to be the best.

Reply

I disagree with your optimism. Yes, Jordin has risen to become one of the top three contestants. However, Melinda have remained consistent in her performance throughout the competition. She is definitely the top runner and deserves to win; with Jordin coming in second. No offense.......

Reply

I am voting for the best: "Jordin"! No one can come close to her. I was a Sanjaya voter and now it is Jordin since I heard her sing, "When You Walk Thru A Storm", last night. But all of em are good and very talented singers.

When Jordin began singing last night I was totally entranced with her till I knew I was seeing and hearing a new SUPER STAR of all times reviving a 60 yr. old song. Simon is correct when he said she could make a num. 1 hit from that song.

Reply

I thought AI was turning into a joke with Sanj. But my faith in the show has now been restored with Jordan. I did think Lakisha was going to go far but I think she got to confident and lost what she had. I think Jordan should win. She gave me goose bumps and brought tears to my eyes. If we're going for real talent, she will win. Don't get me wrong the others are good but not as good as her. As for Melinda, I think she is great but boring. Most of the songs she sings are slow, unexciting, and I don't look forward to her singing, like I do the others. I really enjoyed Blake but even he has changed his manner of singing, and I don't look forward to hearing him anymore either. But I really look forward to hearing what Jordan is going to sing. Everyone needs to remember Jordan is only 17, how many 17 yr. olds do you hear that can sing like her, not anyone I've ever heard. I think she would make a great AI, as good as Carrie.

Reply

Melinda has the ability to make every song a beautiful story from the soul. No matter the style of the song she can make you feel each and every word and feeling.
Jordin is excellent for 17 and will go far, but Melinda has a talent that very few are blessed with and never has there been a contestant that deserved to be The American Idol than she. She is what music is all about.

Reply

Jordin has the widest mass appeal of all and is believable singing anything and shows inner confidence that should be a role model to all teenage girls. Melinda HAS an excellent voice but just does not exude confidence. After the two of them nothing else really matters.

Reply

Melinda has the best vocals, stage presence, and performances that I've seen on American Idol in a very long time. Hands down - she should win this competition. Others have good voices, but not the total package like Melinda. She really delivers! I hope she wins.

Reply

A nice, exciting touch to the end of the show last night---
no one gets voted off. Actually, it was a just decision by the A>I> producers because NO ONE deserves the boot.
And what is all this talk about the new consensus of opinion that Phil Stacy should be the next to go? Poppycock!
Stacy is a fine singer and SO WHAT if he is not a matinee
idol? Ruben was never the most sleek and elegant creature but voters wisely gave more credence to his vocal ability than to his girth. Voters should not get caught up in all this phony-baloney need for ersatz outward beauty and focus more on the good voice than comes from within. The bottom line is--and should be--
that Stacy is a truly superb singer and SHOULD STAY around until....well, until Miss Doolittle rightfully takes her place as the next American Idol. The Elvis-Celine Dion duet was also terrific and maybe younger viewers can
appreciate what a real American Idol loks like. The King
is still alive!

Reply

I really hope that Jordan wins she is great to watch and this week when she sang she was just so wonderfull it made me tear up I have always liked her from day one the other ones are great also but just not as good as Jordan it was so sad last night when they saved her for last and had her thinking that she was going to go home I really hope she wins ........

Reply

If people let judges remarks make their decisson on who to vote for then they need not vote for they have no brain. You have ears so listen and use your own judgement.

Reply

Talk about boring someone needs to give Paula a drink or something to wake her up. I can't believe she gets paid to set there and just agree with Randy on every singer. They should just donate her pay to charity.

Reply

I think Jordin would make a great linebacker,that girl is huge! Likisha is a great screamer but cant really sing.This season is the worst and has begun the fall of this talent search.Theres nobody likable on this run

Reply

Although the other Idol contestants are good, Melinda is the best American Idol contestant, ever! She does not lack confidence but is just humble. Believe me, this girl knows what good is and she is definitely that!

Reply

Lekisha needs to pick the right songs. Phil needs to go along with Chris. Melinda next AI

Reply

Melinda is by far the greatest on the AI show her voice and her presence on stage cannot be beat, Jordan is right behind her. I am hoping that Melinda will win.

Reply

Although Sanji. was a big joke on the show, and definitely could not sing, I felt sorry for him when he was voted off, he is cute and the youngters loved him, maybe he will make in the music industry. Pearl

Reply

i don't like melinda. i think she's faking her humility. she always acts surprised when the judges commend her singing. i like sanjaya because he's truly humble. he took the negative critiques in stride. i'm rooting for blake. i've always liked his contemporary hip style.

Reply

Ok, I thought Phil Stacy on text voting was 5701 tonight, May 1. Why do I keep receiving thanks for voting for Melinda.

Reply