(S06E17) Bill Lawrence and company really seem to be on the back pages of the playbook, aren't they?For the second time this season, we're out of J.D.'s head, this time hearing about the everyday thoughts of Ted, The Todd, and Jordan. We were already privy to Kelso's thoughts in an earlier episode, which means the writers are breaking the pattern of jumping out of J.D.'s head for an entire episode only once per season.
But, you know what? Sometimes, the last pages of the playbook have all the best plays. This was a funny and refreshing episode.
You have to admit: as funny as J.D.'s voice overs and fantasies are, it's good to hear from someone else for a change, especially after six years. And it was a pretty good idea to get in the heads of three secondary characters (read: not in the opening credits) rather than one of the primary ones, though I think the only head we haven't gotten into at this point was Carla's.
Jordan was the funniest, of course. Why do I say, "of course?" Because of the three, she's the most complete character. Unlike the somewhat one-note nature of The Todd (gay-suppressing hound dog) and Ted (doormat with an Oedipal complex), Jordan has shown multiple levels in the past. Yes, we know she's a bitch who has a somewhat complicated relationship with Perry Cox. But we've seen moments where she's cared about what others think, whether it's Cox or... well, that's about it. And we also know she's a great mother. So not only was her desire to purposely sabotage the happiness of Elliot and the Dudemeister completely in character, so was her trying to repair things with Elliot.
I'd repeat Jordan's speech about the desire to cut your significant other in the middle of the night, but it's long, and I just couldn't do it justice. Suffice to say, when Cox shows up with a bandage on his arm, then his face, it was very funny. I just wish they didn't have her ask Cox about the cut on his arm; it felt like they were explaining the joke. At least they didn't bother mentioning the one on his face. Jordan's Oprah-esque fantasy was OK... for some reason, seeing her dancing with a kid that looks like her didn't quite do it for me, though her insulting the cancer survivor did.
Being in The Todd's head was... interesting. My favorite stuff: Trying to figure out what "five" to use with Turk while he should be listening to his friend talk about Todd's teenage boob job patient, complaining about having to stand there while J.D. goes off on one of his fantasies then comes back from it with a weird comment ("We'd have to find a whole lot of gnomes."), and his fantasy about him and his son "Rod" (get it? Fantasy five!) telling each other that they stuff their banana hammocks -- Todd does it with a big hiking sock, of course. The story about the girl was almost secondary. But the way he resolved it did show that Todd's smarter than he looks. That young man will do well in plastic surgery...
By the way, how odd does Donald Faison look with a full head of hair? It almost doesn't look like him (when was the last time he had hair? When he was in Clueless, maybe?). Wonder if he's growing it for the hell of it or for a specific movie role.
Finally, it was good to get in Ted's head for a little while, and to see him display some balls for once, even if it's only stealthily. Funny seeing Carla and the nurses on their slowdown (and Janitor's sympathetic stoppage, since he normally works pretty slowly... nice suntan light). My favorite part of being in Ted's head was his hair fantasy. Talk about ironies... he has hair but his mom has to pay for it with her life. "Why, hair? WHYYYYYYY!!" (I think this is the first time we've ever seen Ted's mom, by the way) Accidentally calling Kelso an ass and internally laughing at his tormentor's racism was also funny.
A few more items:
- For a woman who calls her private parts her "bajingo," Elliot can sex it up, can't she? The stripper pole was a nice touch, and in true role-reversal fashion, an apron-clad Keith comes out with warm cookies when Ted and Lloyd "somehow" find their way into Elliot's house to install it.
- By the way, Lloyd is played by executive story editor/supervising producer Mike Schwartz. I've noticed that we're seeing him more and more on the show. Of course, Lloyd's a complete mess, which was a good way to fit in the story about the $50,000 of needles Kelso was getting for $50.
- The almost complete lack of Zach Braff in this episode made me think he directed it, but he didn't. Wonder if he just needed a few days off...
- Jordan's parents were loving and supportive? Who knew? Then why is she so damned evil?
- When are we going to see J.D.'s baby mommy, Kim, again? Or was that final, Ausiello-filled scene the last time we see Elizabeth Banks on this show?
On our 1-7 ratings scale, I'm giving this one a 5. Like I said, some good laughs were to be had in this one. Not top-notch, but a pretty good episode in the show's usual zany vein. I like that they stayed relatively grounded in reality in this one and didn't get too mired in the heavy stuff this week; after the Laverne arc, we needed a little levity, and this episode accomplished that task.By the way, next week, Sacred Heart gets a little felicity. Read the episode description and you'll figure it out.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-20-2007 @ 12:29AM
Borat said...
I thought it was a great episode...I was laughing consistently for the most part.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 12:51AM
justin said...
I thought this was a pretty solid episode, but Joel I'm sorry, I've gotta call you out and maybe even take away a man card. The last page of a playbook doesn't have your "go to plays" in it, that would be the first page. The last page has the plays you never do, so when you say you're going to "the last page of the playbook", you are saying you're reaching for straws and pulling out a desperation unexpected play.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 1:49AM
Tom said...
First off, I do really hate the new layout. I know you guys got bought out by AOL, but honestly, did it have to go this far? I know the old layout had fewer ads, but it just looked more bloggish. This is just any old TV site.
Oh, and we *have* been in Carla's head before. Can't remember the episode number. I think it's in the fourth season. I know it involves her getting a fertility test, so it's before she gets pregnant, anyway.
I liked this episode. It felt weird having three kind of mini-Scrubs episodes, but it worked. It's funny, I had no idea this was coming up, and just a couple weeks ago I was thinking they should do a "their story." I was gonna include Keith, though. Do I sense His Story V?
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 2:06AM
Lee said...
god elliott on the pole...magical
you didnt mention snoop dogg resident wanting to be called ronald.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 5:25AM
Rich said...
Season 5 had two out of JD's head stories: Her Story II (Karla) and His Story III (the Janitor).
I thought this episode had some really great moments, but felt a little off. I think it's Jordan. Compare her character from season 1 to today. She is so much more whiny and cartoony. In season 1, she was very sharp and dismissive. Maybe it's because she just had another kid, I don't know.
But I loved Todd's comments about JD's fantasies and JD coming out of it with the random comment about gnomes.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 5:53AM
Joel Keller said...
Rich, thanks for the clarification.
Justin, my analogy is correct. When I was talking about the last pages of the playbook, I was referring to desperation plays. But sometimes desperation plays actually work. Just ask Doug Flutie.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 7:17AM
Bill said...
I guess I just didn't find this episode all that funny. It wasn't bad, just... eh. Though for some reason the head of plastic surgery and his bee analogies cracked me up.
http://popculturejunk.blogspot.com/
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 8:12AM
Dave said...
I thought it was a lame episode. There were some funny moments (The Todd waiting for JD's fantasy to finish, Ted calling Kelso an ass, Eliot on the pole), but overall it was subpar. There's a reason why these characters are secondary.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 9:00AM
Hugeliver said...
WHAT was with all the closeups of Jordan/Christa Miller???
Has she had some drastic plastic surgery or is this still from having the baby!?!?
She looked like HELL!!
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 9:17AM
Joe said...
Joel, read up on your Scrubs. As mentioned above, there have been two 'Non-JD' episodes in a season before and Carla's had her turn. Just checking out TV.com or one of those TV sites that have a use would do you some good. Maybe you'll learn a thing or two you can use to improve this site.
Also, I've hated Jordan since around season 3+. She was great in the first and second seasons, but from No. 3 onwards, she's become a parody of herself.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 9:29AM
Alex K. said...
Alright episode. Nobody surprised that all at once there's a new Laverne in the nursing staff? They probably didn't want to lose the iconic arrangement.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 11:06AM
agentmichaelscarn said...
Alex K,
I noticed it too. Although, it was never mentioned in the episode so I just brushed it off as filler.
The episode in which Carla was featured was titled "Her Story II" and was the second of a two-story arc featuring Mandy Moore, Billy Dee Williams was also featured as himself -- playing Julie/Moore's godfather.
Fine episode tonight. I hope they feature a story focusing on Dr. McHead/Snoop Dog Residant/Colonel Dr. next season.
******SPOILER ALERT******
Next weeks guest star is Kerri Russle -- who may be joining the cast next season.
******END OF SPOILER******
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 12:44PM
Happy Steve said...
Love Ted's thought towards Kelso at the end... "YEEEAAAAHHH!!! SUCK IT BITCH!!!"
that just cracks me up.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 3:22PM
mgasaprd said...
"bees, bees, bees..."
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 6:04PM
Bob said...
What is it with this dude and bees?!
Reply