If you caught the recent episode of Lost ('Catch-22'), you may have already started scouring the web in search of clues regarding the little ditty Desmond sang during a flashback, while supping down copious amounts of wine.The key to the song lies in Desmond's nationality. In case you hadn't noticed, he's Scottish (by the sounds of his accent, probably from Glasgow, possibly Paisley).
Henry Ian Cusick, the actor who portrays Desmond, isn't actually Scottish himself -- he was born in Trujillo, Peru. His father is Scottish, but he spent most of his early life in Trinidad and Tobago and moved to Scotland when he was 15.
Presumably, Scotland is where Ian (or perhaps his character, Desmond) developed an affection for the Glasgow-based football (soccer) team Celtic FC (pronounced sel-tik).
Celtic are one half of of two dominant Scottish football teams (both based in Glasgow), known as the Old Firm -- the other club being Rangers FC. Both clubs play in the Scottish Premier League, but also take part in European competitions.
Celtic play their home matches at Celtic Park, a 60,832 capacity all-seated stadium in the east end of Glasgow (it's usually packed full most weeks), which is nicknamed 'Paradise' by the fans.
The club anthem is known as 'The Celtic Song', written by Glen Daly -- which was the song Desmond was singing in the flashback. It's the club anthem, and airs over the stadium PA as the team emerges out on to the pitch before a match commences.
It seems unlikely that the creators of Lost would have inserted such a reference of their own accord, so it's fair to assume Cusick offered it as an ad-lib, perhaps to expand his character's back-story.
It's not that the song (or the reference) is obscure, but I just can't imagine that J. J. Abrams or Damon Lindelof would be too aware of Glasgow Celtic FC (unless they're members of the Los Angeles Celtic Supporter's Club, which I'm reliably told has a fairly big contingent).
However -- and this is where it starts getting interesting -- the episode writers were Brian K. Vaughan and Jeff Pinkner, and I know for a fact that Mr Vaughan is good friends with comic-book writer Mark Millar, who just so happens to be a Celtic fan...
It's entirely possible that Millar fed the line to Vaughan.
So, it starts to become easy enough to speculate on the connection between Desmond, Celtic FC and 'The Celtic Song' (I'm a Celtic FC season ticket holder, and a football journalist based in Scotland myself, so I jumped to a conclusion almost instantly).
You're probably now asking yourself what I'm driving at.
Well, here it is: could it be that Desmond was making a subtle hint at the wider theme of Lost with the subtle connection to Celtic Park being nicknamed 'Paradise'?
Were the writers trying to tell us something about the Island via this little ditty?
Watch the clip again below from YouTube and judge for yourself...












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-20-2007 @ 4:52PM
Andrew said...
After hearing he became a Monk Ruth told him that the closest he ever came to a religious experience was when Celtic won the cup. So I think they meant for him to sing that song.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 7:34PM
William McIntyre said...
Considering Desmond was a monk in the scene, it would make sense for his allegiances to be towards Celtic, who draw their support historically from the Catholic side of the old firm, rather than Rangers who are protestant and as such tend not to have monks or nuns or fans who wish to become either.
Rather than any conspiracy or Celtic inspired love-in, one could comment that it was researched and compliment whoever did it (probably Cusick), to knowing their facts.
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 7:43PM
Allen Mendelsohn said...
Very interesting! But you can read anything into anything on Lost. So who knows.
And Celtic in Scotland would be pronounced Kel-tik, not Sel-tik
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 10:07PM
jbdean said...
Thanks for the info on the song Desmond was singing. :D But Ian _is_ Scottish. You don't have to be born in Scotland to be Scottish. Being half by blood makes him a Scot. And he still has family there and visits regularly. Just an FYI. :)
Reply
4-20-2007 @ 11:31PM
Spudstercool said...
@3: Allen Mendelsohn
I assure you, it's pronounced (Sel-tik) :) , unless you're saying it in Gaelic :p
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 12:05AM
Scott said...
it was only a matter of time before TVSqaud fell to the old firm... and it's sel-tik, but it's all about the Gers anyhow (just not this season >.
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 3:16AM
spud89 said...
When desmond was laying his cloths on the head monks desk there was a photo with a older woman who I think is one of the others can anybody refresh my memory as to who she is.
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 5:41AM
bill said...
tsk, it's pronounced Sellick. As in Sellickfitbaclub.
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 5:55AM
Martin Conaghan said...
Alan - believe me, it's pronounced Sel-tik.
I'm a lifelong Celtic FC fan and a Scottish football journalist, so I can speak with some authority on this.
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 6:53AM
jdl said...
The woman in the photo on the monk's desk was from the jewelry store. She wouldn't sell Desmond the ring.
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 8:34PM
Brainfish said...
As we're now falling into the traditional Scottish tradition....
'mon the Accies!
:)
Reply
4-22-2007 @ 8:05AM
paul doherty said...
i always liked big desmond! c'mon the hoops, champions again!!! oh the rangers are sh!te!!!!!!!
Reply
5-25-2007 @ 11:21AM
Vix said...
no no no...its pronounced sel-tik....kel-tic is the anciant scottish people (like picts...only scottish...their the ones that ran about wae blue face paint and wore tartan skirts (i mean...kilts...lol)
Reply