(S03E16) "One of Us" has added yet another layer to Juliet's past and to her current motives. She's a tough one to read, with those "Who, me?" innocent eyes. We also got to watch what was, hopefully, the last Lost beach reunion scene. How many reunions have there been this season, honestly?
Juliet's flashback picked up right where "Not in Portland" left off, giving us a clear idea of how she got to the island, and a less-than-clear idea of what kept her there. We'll have to wait until next season to learn how Juliet became such a good fighter, though. A pretty intimidating countdown has also been started, and I cannot wait to see what the next Lost week holds.
The Flashback
The flashback caught up with Juliet outside Mittelos Bioscience's private, high-security airport. So far I cannot find anything on Herarat Aviation, the airline that Juliet was supposedly flying with, but some enterprising young Lost fan will undoubtedly find something. Mittelos was still all about secrecy, taking Juliet's vitals before the trip and drugging her.
At the time of her departure, Juliet was still under the impression that she would return in six months. She was also willing to make the mysterious journey without knowing any of the details, and in spite of Mittelos' super-private status. Juliet's conversation with Alpert was very telling. A person would have to be a little shady to take a job under such suspicious circumstances, "special" or not.
One of the flashback's biggest revelations was the island's pregnancy problem. Pregnancy is fatal to women on the island, which will certainly be a major issue for Sun in upcoming episodes. The Others were conducting research on this issue, and Juliet had guessed that "it" happens at conception. After asking Ben to let her leave the island to continue her work, Juliet was given some bad news. Rachel's cancer was back, and Ben promised that Jacob would cure Juliet's sister. This was, of course, on the condition that Juliet stayed on the island. These people are good.
We also learned that Juliet has incredible taste in men, after a nice little bedroom scene with Goodwin. I am not sure what purpose this detail serves, or how it fits in with Juliet's supposed "history" with Ben. Not that I mind more scenes with Brett Cullen; I'm just posing a question or two. Juliet's discovery of Ben's tumor freaked out both her and Ben. The real source of Ben's fear was not discussed (it has to be more than just a fear of death), but Juliet was worried that Ben lied to her about Rachel's recovery. She made a second, desperate request to go home, which Ben denied.
In order to defend himself, Ben took Juliet to the Flame station's communications center (operated by Mikhail) to prove that Rachel was alive. Juliet did her best impression of Liv Tyler in Aerosmith's Armageddon video while watching Rachel and Julian at the playground. Meanwhile, Mikhail was busy watching news coverage of the 815 crash, and doing research on the passengers.
The biggest revelation of the episode: Juliet is still with the Others, and all of her actions in "Left Behind" were part of a larger plan. Juliet's role in Claire's illness and recovery was also set up by the Others. And set your island calendars; Ben plans on meeting up with Juliet in one week, Lost time!
The Beach
Poor, unfortunate Claire was made ill by the Others in order to help Juliet "save the day" and gain the crash survivors' trust. Apparently Claire still has some implant inside of her that the Others can manipulate. If Sayid and Sawyer are any indication, Juliet will have to do a lot more than cure Claire to win everyone over. Sayid was awesome, as usual, and did not take his eyes off Juliet for a second. He'll have to find another way to separate Juliet from Jack if he wants to get any answers out of her.
How much do I hate Jack and his Other-trusting ways? His rationale for trusting Juliet was absolutely ridiculous. At this point, I'm not sure who's dumber: Jack, for trusting Juliet, or everyone else for trusting Jack. At least Sun and Jin didn't jump on the bandwagon. Sun even translated Jin's snarky comment for Juliet, which was the funniest part of the whole episode.
I'm still trying to figure out how much of Juliet's story to believe. She claimed that Ethan took blood samples, and that the Others used Claire as a "control" case for their fertility research. The kidnapping was, apparently, not part of the plan. The second part of the story is definitely true, since Tom's conversation with Ethan in Claire's flashback already revealed this.
Ultimately, Juliet "cured" Claire's illness, and won over...who, exactly? I didn't look like she was invited to join the ping pong league after that. There has to be more to her plan, and it seems to involve the return of Ben and the Others. I'm glad that Juliet turned out to be more than just a banished Other, but I would love to learn how she became such a manipulative schemer. I suppose that's for another episode.
Final questions/thoughts:
-
Hurley let it slip to Juliet that Charlie was the one who killed Ethan. Will this put Charlie in danger?
-
Was Ben completely lying about Rachel's cancer returning? It could have been another way to keep Juliet on the island, like the video of a now-healthy Rachel and Julian.
-
Sawyer may not be able to use nicknames, but he did manage to call Ben a "bug-eyed bastard." Lovely.
-
After the plane crash scene, Ben mentioned that the Others might find more mothers on the p
lane. What will they do to Sun once they find out about her pregnancy?
On a scale of 1 to 7, I would give this episode a 6.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 5)
4-12-2007 @ 12:44AM
ED said...
who is Jacob?
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 12:51AM
hot zizzy said...
I thought the episode was pretty good, and it was nice to once again have flashbacks that were still fresh, instead of ones that have been going on for two seasons. I give it 7.5...out of 10. Anyway, here's my full review:
http://www.arrogantics.com/2007/04/12/lost-season-3-episode-16-one-of-us-review/
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:02AM
Bill said...
So did Sun get pregnant before she came to the island, from her now dead ex, since Jin was firing blanks? That would seem to mean that Sun might be able to avoid whatever causes the pregnancies to go sour. Or did the island mojo cure Jin, which would put Sun in danger? Lots of fun questions. I love it.
http://popculturejunk.blogspot.com/
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:08AM
hot zizzy said...
Why out of 7?
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:17AM
VIgital said...
I'm going on record as saying the "Herarat Airlines" is a reference to Mt. Ararat from the story of Noah's Ark and the Flood (Mt. Ararat is where the Ark came to rest after the waters receded).
So Mt. Ararat is on this island, and somewhere, we'll find Noah's Ark. And further, I think this island may be where the Garden of Eden is located.
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:25AM
wilymon said...
I agree with 'hot zizzy', but i give it a 7.5 out 7
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:30AM
dl said...
It's an anagram for Earhart as in Amelia Earhart.
Reply
6-22-2007 @ 10:52AM
Donkey Dongle said...
I'm going on record saying Mt. Ararat is in Turkey near the border with Armenia. I'm also going on record saying the island in Lost is not in Turkey.
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:35AM
John S. said...
Just like Mittelos is an anagram for Lost Time, Herarat is an anagram for Earhart. Strange. I bet The Others are good at Boggle.
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:35AM
John S. said...
Ahh...beaten to the punch in the time it took me to read the review...
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 1:54AM
Bozack said...
Anyone notice Juliet playing "Downtown" twice in this episode? Once in the car with her sister and then obviously on the island. This is the same song that Desmond played on the record player every morning when he awoke in the hatch (before Locke breached it).
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 2:11AM
em said...
and yet i ask does this episope solve why the plane crashed on that island dont you think ben new who he was crashing?
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 3:29AM
ordo said...
no, downtown wasnt playing when desmond woke up, that was a different song. ur prob just remembering it from when the earlier flashback of the same scene at the start of the season
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 4:42AM
epobirs said...
Desmond listened to a song by The Mamas and the Papas, although notably of the same rough era by a few years. The Dharma Initiative appears to have come together during this same era. How long the Other have held the island is harder to say. Ben says he has been there his entire life, perhaps to avoid a condition that would have killed him in childhood.
One confirmed item from an earlier episode: Juliet is a Stephen King fan. She got Ben to read Carrie and I believe she was holding an edition of 'The Gunslinger' in the book club scenes. This is the first book in the Dark Tower series and loaded with all sorts of Easter Egg potential.
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 4:46AM
epobirs said...
This also reminded me of a favorite gag from a classic BBC Radio comedy show 'I'm Sorry, I'll Read That Again.'
Announcer: Ladies and Gentlemen, Petula Clark Sing!
Audience: We know that!
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 6:04AM
Tele-Toby said...
For me the funniest line was from Juliet. When Hurley mentioned that she wasn't one of the Others on the dock, who put bags over the prisoners' heads after they shocked them, Juliet replied, "I had the day off."
Might have been some nice fireworks if Ana Lucia was still alive and Juliet found out that she was the one who killed Goodwin. Well, at least she got her revenge through a third party....
It's still possible Juliet is pulling a three-level con - playing along with Ben's plot only so far with hopes of still turning against him to break free. I'm willing to wait and see....
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 6:08AM
Tele-Toby said...
One question - I've seen mention in other blogs and websites of the Othersville barracks being referred to as "Downtown", which was the song Juliet played to remember her sister.
Did this nickname for the residence area ever come up in an episode?
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 6:56AM
las6 said...
Was it just me or did that sub look extremely fake? Was that done on purpose (maybe it's a fake sub! it's all about the illusion anyways) ...or is it just bad prop work?
Secondly, if the sub was real - what the heck does Ben have that makes Juliet follow his plan. I think Jack's reason for trusting Juliet is a pretty good one. She definately wants to get out of the island, no matter what the cost. What Jack doesn't get is that things like human life or trust aren't really worth anything to the Others.
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 8:08AM
Christian H. said...
Best episode of the season in my opinion :)
Elizabeth Mitchell does a terrific job here and she's the best addition to "Lost" yet. Even better than Ben/Henry :)
Of course it was absolutely clear that she's a "spy", I think everyone saw that coming... But I hope that she will turn on the "Others" :)
Reply
4-12-2007 @ 8:24AM
Hugeliver said...
Where were Rose & Bernard during the big reunion scene!?!?!? Does anyone remember them? Do the writers!?!?
Pretty good episode. I'd give it a 7 as well.
I LOVED when Hurley just non-chalantly said "We buried him over there" then looked out into the ocean. LMAO!!!
Reply