
What can I say about The Sci-Fi Channel's new show Painkiller Jane? Well, it certainly isn't well-written, well-acted, attention-getting, on par with Battlestar Galactica, or a fine replacement for Stargate SG-1. None of those phrases would describe this show. However, these would: bad acting, bad writing, extremely boring (both my wife an I fell asleep) and not a very good addition to the Sci-Fi Friday schedule. Now, I could be jaded here since the preview DVD I was sent showed rough cuts of the show. Nah, who am I kidding? The show is just bad!
All right, all right, I'm getting a bit ahead of myself here, so let me explain the show. Painkiller Jane is based on the comic book series of the same name, which was created by Jimmy Palmiotti and Joe Quesada (now boy Editor-In-Chief of Marvel Comics) back in 1995. For fans of the series, which featured Jane as a vigilante who has extraordinary healing powers (but still feels the pain of her injures, hence the name of the comic book and TV show), you will not recognize the show. Same thing goes for you fans of the Painkiller Jane movie that premiered on Sci-Fi in 2005. In that one Jane is a member of a Special Forces Unit who gains healing powers as well as every other super-human ability.
This time around Jane Vasko (played by Kristanna Loken) is a former DEA agent who is 'recruited' by a covert government organization to help track down 'Neuros' -- genetically-enhanced super-humans with special mind powers. The abilities vary: one person has the ability to resurrect the dead, another can manipulate human minds to perform acts of murder, while still yet another can make a person think that Star Jones is actually looking good right now. While in the course of her initial investigation with her new employees, she is attacked by one of her comrades, who is being controlled by a Neuro, and ends up making a swan dive from the 46th floor of a office building, killing her instantly.
Or so we think. It turns out that Jane can heal herself of these horrific wounds. This is good, because if she didn't this would be an extremely short series (which may have actually been okay. Stop it, Rich, Stop it!). So, not only is she hunting Neuros, but she's now trying to figure out why she has these powers, and if there is any connection to the Neuros in any way.
It sounds like an interesting concept, but it goes bad in soooo many ways. Let's begin with Jane. Raise your hands if you've seen one too many blonde-haired, blue-eyed, leather jacket-wearing, risk-taking, tough-as-nails agents of the law who think their poop don't stink. Yeah, that's what I thought. Guess what? Jane is all of that stuff, plus she doesn't have a good relationship with her father. How original! Here she is, recovering from injuries that resulted from a 46-story fall to her death, and she goes back to her apartment for a drink. I'm sorry, if that happened to me I'd want to lie down for a bit while the screaming stopped in my head.
Let's talk about those healing powers for a second. The DVD preview I was sent came with two episodes. Her powers were barely shown in both. This is particularly true in the second episode, which barely alluded to her abilities. As the show is called Painkiller Jane you would think that they would show her getting shot, knifed and exploded on a regular basis. Oh, I forgot to mention that Jane isn't that happy she has these powers now. In fact, through the magic of voice-overs (which is such a fresh concept) we learn that Jane feels very much like the two-headed stepchild right now. If I could re-heal myself I'd be lighting my hand on fire just to see what happens afterward.
Moving onto the covert government organization she works with. Its leader is the stereotypical senior hard-ass who was part of some former Special Ops thingee before he joined the Neuro search. Then there's the stereotypical strong, dumb guy who thinks it's stupid to have a girl on the team. Then there's the stereotypical computer expert who thinks he's smarter and better than all of the other IT people out there. By the way, this reminds me of something . . . why do all 'computer experts' out there type really fast on their keyboards to bring up 3-D displays of building schematics? Haven't they heard of a mouse?
Look I know I sound rough here, and it's hard to gage a show after only seeing two episodes. Hell, this thing could improve greatly and we could be talking about an Emmy sweep years down the line. However, I don't think that's going to happen. Painkiller Jane is just a terrible show that should have never made it on the Sci-Fi schedule. So, when it comes on watch it when you can because it may be gone before you blink.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
4-09-2007 @ 12:11PM
David said...
Wow... it's a bad replacement for SG-1? Damn, that is really bad!
So I guess this show will have huge ratings of 4 million viewers a week, ggreat. The part that pisses me off is better shows get 13 episode seasons yet this show and Flash Gordan get 22 episode seasons. I rather they both get 13 episodes and then then can use the leftover money to make another new show.
Reply
4-09-2007 @ 12:41PM
Karen said...
Not only is she yet another blonde ass-kicking crime fighter, but hey--we even already HAVE a blonde self-healer! Couldn't they come up with *anything* original??
Reply
4-09-2007 @ 2:35PM
The Dude said...
Well to be fair Painkiller Jane has been around a lot longer than Heroes:the show is based on the comic book... which I don't think anyone ever really read. I don't know anyone that did. The powers folks exhibit in heroes are pretty well tread themselves (hey, not slagging them: comics do it too).
It should be readily apparent to everyone that SciFi has almost no idea what constitutes a show worth making and what they should be showing. Hell, they can't even edit Doctor Who for american TV correctly.
Reply
4-09-2007 @ 3:37PM
ToxicBaby said...
I think this criticism is rather harsh. I've seen the pilot of PK Jane and think it looks pretty good. Kristanna Loken is perfect for the role and I expect that the show will have some depth to its darkness. I'm looking forward to seeing where it goes.
Reply
4-09-2007 @ 10:10PM
Fred said...
Sometimes a better show -- by which I'm guessing you mean something like BSG -- gets a shorter season because that works better for that show, not because the network is trying to shaft the producers or viewers. (They have oh so many other ways to do that, after all.) More doesn't always mean better.
That said, I haven't seen this. I was vaguely interested, but I think that interest has evaporated with this review.
Reply
4-09-2007 @ 11:41PM
Stigmata said...
i wanna hear Kieth Mcduffee's review on this show, richard keller is not as good a reviewer for sci fi stuff.
Reply
4-21-2007 @ 1:35PM
Dean FH Macy, DLit said...
I watched 40 minutes of Painkiller Jane and then could not stand it anymore. It is the worst piece of "sci-fi" I have ever seen on the Sci-Fi channel. On a scale of 1 to 10, this is a -8 for acting, dialogue, effects, script and plot. Go read a book instead.
Reply
5-09-2007 @ 12:08PM
Amai said...
I've watched the first two episodes. The first one reminded me of the collector. Vaguely interesting, and too short, leaving me anticipating next week. The second made me wonder what the hell I was doing wasting my time on this.
I'm going to watch next week, and if its an echo of this I'll watch something else. Stylistic problems. Plot problems. Ech!
The worse part is, the concept well used, is solid. Maybe I should just look for the comics.
Reply
6-19-2007 @ 8:25PM
Steph said...
gee, no-one here has really read the original "painkiller jane" comics? for those naive sci fi watchers, painkiller jane was the original self healing, ultra hot, super crime fighting chick. actually, the only thing wrong with this particular sci fi series is the fact that she's a redhead in the comics and not a blonde, also, she kills at least one bad guy in every single comic i've collected. the sci fi series is quite slow compared to the comic. i suggest that everyone, especially karen, pick up the latest series of painkiller jane at your local comic book store and come back with a much more constructive comment. for those that know who she is, good on you! i have to admit, i never thought kristana loken was a perfect choice for this, but she surprisingly pulls it off! personally, i would have picked that chick off run lola run and borne identity, but it guess she's getting too old now.
cheers, steph :)
Reply
6-23-2007 @ 8:36AM
Shannon Kelly said...
I don't think the show is all that bad. It's not the best storylines, but I do feel Ms. Loken does an adaquate job in the role
Reply