Welcome to TV Squad Lists (formerly 'The Five'), a feature where each blogger has a chance to list his or her own rundown of things in television that stand out from the rest, both good and bad.
OK, so yesterday I gave my list of the Five Greatest Police Detectives, and several readers gave their lists. Today I thought I'd do the other end of the invesitgation spectrum, private eyes, amateur sleuths and other investigators. This list was even hard to do. So many great characters.
1. Spenser (Robert Urich): I picked this Boston-based private eye because he seemed to be a great mix of brain and brawn. The type of guy who could go to the ratty gym and knock around some boxer and then go off to a fancy Beacon Hill cafe and have coffee with his girlfriend and talk about politics or literature. He was smart, clever, caring, a wiseass, and ridiculously moral. What else do you want in a private eye?
2. Sherlock Holmes (Jeremy Brett): You can't have any list of great investigators and not include the most classic of investigators.
3. Banacek (George Peppard): While most investigators and P.I.s only had to solve one measley murder, Banacek had to find missing airplanes, armored cars that were taken, and a football player that was snatched on the field, in front of thousands of fans and TV viewers.
4. Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury): You have to have a woman on the list, and who solved more crimes than Jessica Fletcher? Sure, I think people should have started to investigate her because everywhere she went someone was killed and she was the one who just "happened" to solve it. And how many murders occurred in the small town she lived in up in Maine? Still, her resume is kinda impressive, and no one else around her was going to solve those crimes and all those villains would have gotten away scott free.
5. Carl Kolchak (Darren McGavin): I put intrepid reporter Kolchak on the list because it's actually pretty incredible what he did week after week. Here was a guy who worked for an independent news service who tracked down deadly monsters and other supernatural foes, and didn't even get to write about them or get any recognition for saving the world. And no one ever believed him! What a lonely life that must have been. And may I add that while he may have seemed a little bumbling, the guy had balls of steel. I'll never forget the episode where he crawled into the back of a car to pour salt into the mouth of a sleeping zombie and the zombie woke up halfway through it. That scared the hell out of me when I was a kid, so I gotta give Kolchak his due.
6. Mike Hammer (Stacey Keach): The classic private eye: didn't care for authority, smoked cigarettes non-stop, and had a buxom secretary that helped him on cases. (David Janssen's Richard Diamond character should go in this spot too, and he had the bonus of working with Mary Tyler Moore's legs.)
7. Robert McCall - The Equalizer (Edward Woodward): He's like Jessica Fletcher, only with a gun and a crafty team of operatives. How can you not like an ex-spy who actually puts an ad in the classified section of a newspaper, telling people to call him if they had problems they couldn't solve themselves?
8. Thomas Magnum (Tom Selleck): I think a lot of people underestimated Magnum, because he seemed like a pretty boy, a guy who drives around in a sports car (that wasn't even his), a guy who never had any money, and he wore shorts and a baseball cap all the time. But he ultimately solved the crimes, and had a respect for the occupation. He wouldn't even let you call him a private eye, it was "private investigator," thank you very much.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
3-28-2007 @ 9:46AM
Zachary Freiesleben said...
Keith and Veronica Mars.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 9:57AM
Bill said...
How about Angel, Monk, or Duckman (Private Dick/Family Man)?
I'm not a fan of Banacek or the Equalizer, but Spenser I think should be #1. Also, I was very young when it was on, but I'm pretty sure that Hawk is the coolest character in the history of.... characters.
http://popculturejunk.blogspot.com/
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:18AM
Carl said...
What -- no Father Dowling?
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 9:59AM
Martha Fischer said...
Dude. Jim Rockford. Jim Rockford!
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:16AM
Jack said...
Did Sherlock Holmes ever have a weekly television show? What is the criteria for getting on this list?
I agree that Adrian Monk should be there. In a few more seasons, I'd include "Psych" too.
What about Simon & Simon?
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:18AM
Jack said...
Oh, or the Remington Steel couple? Or Dave and Maddie from Moonlighting?
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 11:09AM
cmonks said...
Yeah, leaving off Jim Rockford is pretty much unforgivable.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:29AM
Kevinc said...
Good List.
Jack - Holmes is the framework all other private eyes are based on.
Monk is a new version of Holmes.
Angel and Duckman?!?!? Duckman??
Never really liked Rockford.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:37AM
cmonks said...
Yeah, leaving off Jim Rockford is pretty unforgivable.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 1:15PM
judodog said...
This list should begin and end with James Rockford, period!
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:46AM
Draconismoi said...
Veronica Mars - sure she hasn't solved as many crimes as some...but she's only been at it for 3 years. And how many 17, 18,19 year old PIs have as impressive a resume?
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:53AM
badmojo1b said...
Absolutely nailed this one. Spenser was the best. Mike Hammer could have been higher.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 12:18PM
slutty_whore said...
UH, JESSICA FLETCHER WAS AN AUTHOR, NOT A P.I!
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 11:39AM
N. Suga said...
Okay, so this was a limited run on A&E, but the Timothy Hutton acted-and-produced Nero Wolfe series was really fun, and stayed stylish and true to the source material. Maury Chaykin was phenomenal as Wolfe!
Also, does Batman count as an amateur detective?
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 11:22AM
JENNIFER said...
Awesome list and I must say I am happy to see Carl Kolchak on the list. My brother and I and even my mom still talk about that show today and I get very excited when its on Sci Fri. Also I was a HUGE Spencer fan. I remember with longing the days that it was a mainstay on the Lifetime Network. Any idea when the series (not the movies) will come out on DVD??? Also, Magnum is a great choice too. I didnt know much about Vietnam when the show ran ( cause I was young) but it encouraged me to do some research and may I say I think they really brought the struggle of the Vietnam Vet to mainstream American homes and did it with style, accuracy, and tenderness.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 11:10AM
Bob Sassone said...
Yeah, the Rockford Files is one of my favorite shows (I even spent months looking for the same car he owned when I bought my first car in the early 80s, didn't find one), but he juuuuust missed making this list.
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 11:11AM
khamel said...
where does mcgyver fall on this list? hes not officially a private eye but he does alot of sleuthing
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 11:17AM
Bill said...
Draconismoi: The only one I can think of is Encyclopedia Brown, but as we all know, his career didn't end well:
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/29537
Kevinc: Sure, Duckman. I know not many people are fans, but I always enjoyed the show. And we're not ranking the skill of the detective, we're ranking the quality of the character. At least I hope detective skill isn't being ranked, or else I take issue with Bob's choice of Sledge Hammer in the police detective list.
http://popculturejunk.blogspot.com/
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 4:05PM
Jeri said...
Your list is almost perfect, I also loved Spencer and the rest. Jeremy Brett was the perfect Holmes. (for the other commenter, it was a series on A&E when they did Mystery Saturday and rotated a group of mystery shows.) BUT, there is one glaring omission on your list... How could you leave off Columbo?????????
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 2:37PM
KKH said...
Rockford Files, bar none, was the best private eye series. What can you possibly be thinking? Leaving it off all together, let alone not having ahead of Spenser at Number 1?!?! I think you need your "private eyes" examined!
Reply