(S02E10) When HBO failed to renew Carnivale for a third season a few years back I was absolutely outraged. Carnivale was like a lover to me. Sexy, intelligent, mysterious, and beautiful in a bright but dirty way - all attributes of a good mate in my book.
To this day, it remains the only show I ever coordinated a watch party for which is saying a lot because I like a lot of shows, and I still quote Brother Justin's "Be Still!" line when I want someone to shut their mouth. Needless to say, I was pretty much heartbroken when the show was cancelled but I didn't go down without a fight.
I signed every online petition available to try and get the show back on the air. I left hundreds of messages to the HBO offices voicing my discontent with their foolish decision. I even went so far as to mail every HBO executive a circus midget in a box holding a sign that said "What would Sampson do?" for a solid month, but all was for naught because HBO stuck with their decision and left the show in an unfinished state. Lame.
I didn't think I'd ever forgive the network for what I deemed a horrible transgression, then I sat down and watched Rome, and Carnivale became nothing but a fond memory. And now, here we are at the series finale and another love affair of mine must come to an end, but at least this one received a fitting ending.
My favorite relationship in the show has always been the one that existed between Vorenus and Pullo. Although they weren't brothers by blood, the bond that existed between the two was no less binding.
Octavian summed up Vorenus best when he said, "the man turns loyalty into a vice." In a tragic show full of tragically flawed figures, I found Vorenus' flaws to be the most compelling to watch.
You could always tell that Vorenus was a kind-hearted human being, despite his dance with darkness while he was head of the Aventine. It was pretty fascinating that he was able to let his loyalty for Antony supercede his aforementioned kind-heart and not stop Antony after he'd morphed into the epitome of corruption while in Egypt.
In the end, I was happy to see that Vorenus showed the most loyalty to Pullo by bringing Caesarian back to his father - and also appreciate the whole Pullo knocking up Cleopatra thing being written into the plot - despite there being a 100% chance it is historically inaccurate. It made for good television.
And now is as good time as any to point out that Titus Pullo has a Garmin GPS unit implanted in his cranium. I count no less than three times this season where he was miraculously able to track down and find Vorenus despite having no clue of his whereabouts. I found it very impressive.
Atia, or as I like to call her - Debra Messing with boobs, was another one of my favorite characters. Her relationship with every other character on the show, particularly the one that existed between her and Servilia, always made for uncomfortable but entertaining television to say the least.
Although, Atia was pretty much evil, I found myself sympathizing with her when Octavian arranged the marriage between Antony and Octavia. In the screen capture that accompanies this commentary I can just imagine her wondering why she was doomed to a fate of misery and unhappiness. To that I say, she bore and nurtured the mechanical beast who is responsible for making her life miserable. That, and people tend to reap what they sow.
I was pretty shocked to see Cleopatra pull the wool over Antony's eyes when she sent him the faux suicide letter. For most of the show Antony was very crafty, self-assured, and cunning. Had he not been all cracked-out, as indicated by the fuzziness in the camera when viewing through his eyes (nice touch), I'm sure he'd have seen through the ploy. That being said, Cleopatra redeemed herself in my eyes by killing herself by Antony's side.
The series kind of painted Octavian as this robotic, methodical, and cruel figure illustrated best by his parading the bodies of Antony and Cleopatra through the streets of Rome and his lust for killing Caesarian. Be that as it may, from what I understand of history, Gaius Octavian actually goes on to lead Rome to several years of prosperity during his rule.
I got a real kick out of Caesarian not really being Caesar's son, and the "about your father," line Pullo throws out to end the series was a riot. It was little touches like this that made the show so enjoyable to me.
It was actually terribly difficult reviewing this series finale not having had the opportunity to muse on the 21 episodes that came before it, but the show was just so epic in nature and well executed that it deserved some sort of acknowledgement. From the acting to the writing to the cinematography - there are just too many good things to say about Rome. Sunday nights are going to feel really empty for a while to come.
I highly recommend everyone run out and purchase these on DVD.











Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
3-26-2007 @ 12:53PM
Rob said...
I'm glad to see something about Rome on here. I was a great series! I started watching it with a "Nothing else to watch tonight" attitude. By the start of the second season it over took most of my other shows in the priority list.
Great writing, great acting and a story that balanced between history's facts and entertainment value.
I couldn't help but to wonder thought, during the shooting of this last episode - how hard would it be for the actor and actress of Antony and Cleopatra to do their job while there's a big orgy going on in front of them? To act all serious despite the background...
Anyway, your review summed up a lot of my thoughts. Sad to see it go but they did it well!
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 12:55PM
Matthew H. said...
I'm glad TVSquad finally acknowledged the show with a review!
Whilst I agree that Pullo has a sixth sense for finding Vorenus, in this episode, I think it was planned. Vorenus left the Niobe painting behind intentionally, I reckon, and he camped out at the same spot they did back in season 1 when they were chasing after Cleopatra.
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:06PM
Rob said...
...and before I forget - the ONE issue I had with Rome....
Thumbs down for the actor selection in the older Octavian. It was WAY too big of a change to adjust to. I'm not sure if it was the young Octavian who wasn't properly cast but going from the curly haired boy to the beedy eyed upper teen never sat well with me.
Octavia remained the same hot chick though! :-)
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:10PM
JJ said...
2. Good point. Pullo did pick up that trinket. I just failed to remember.
3. Yeah, that Atia quote giving Servelia a back handed compliment of sorts was pretty funny. But not quite as funny looking as Octavian's wife :)
And Rob. The Octavian change really screwed with me too. I've always had a problem with actors that couldn't pass as brothers in real life portraying each other at different times in their life on TV. This one was a bit hard to swallow.
And yeah. Octavia was smoking hot. Wish her and the Gipper would have worked out. Man, I'm really sad it's over...
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:13PM
const said...
why didn't TVSquad reveiw Rome in the first place?
I'd rather read those reviews than revisit the latest Rosie O'Donnell has no grip with reality posts.
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:20PM
kattrell said...
I think Rome was excellent. It made History come alive in vivid detail.In particular the depliction of the orgies so much detail. I was quite agasped to say the least! (smile)
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:20PM
Kaxx said...
I completely agree with your feelings of loss over these two series. :( However, I wanted to mention that 1. Pullo found a trinket (or something) by Antony's body which lead him to the place that Vorenus says he knew Pullo would remember. 2. Atia knows why she is so cursed... because of crazy old Servilia (I think that was her...) calling the dark gods down on her. That lady was a witch to be sure. I so loved Atia... such a character... "Better women than you have wished the same. Try to find them now." (paraphrased)
Here's to hoping the next series they make that's this good goes for more than 2 seasons... (how about 8?)
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:39PM
1iPete said...
Yay, Rome finally gets acknowledged on TVS!
This was the best finale of the night (sorry BSG), to a top quality series. It's unfortunate that the series was so expensive to make and they had to condense what was to be season 2 & 3 into this season, but it still was riveting.
I agree that the switch in Octavian actors was harsh. I missed the young actor with the way everyone dismissed and underestimated him while he masterfully outmaneuvered and manipulated. Yes, Octavian went on to become Augustus Caesar who presided over the Pax Romana, the most prosperous and peaceful run of the Empire.
It was fun to see that the Roman newsreader remained the same and that many Romans apparently spoke with British or Scottish accents. All in all, a great TV series which ended too soon and was much better than Carnivale.
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 1:43PM
SHANNON said...
I WAS SHOCKED WHEN THEY CANCELLED ROME!!! (AND DEADWOOD)SHAME ON U HBO!!! FINALLY SOMETHING GOOD 2 WATCH & THEY SCREW IT UP
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 2:22PM
Alan said...
I was always surprised that TV Squad didn't review this one regularly -- some of the episodes of this season have truly been some of the best TV I have ever seen. Far better than the crap that passes for 24 these days or even Battlestar Galactica.
Great conclusion. Titus Pullo is the man.
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 2:42PM
Walt said...
I hope the producers, writers and the actors had fun doing this show, because I enjoyed watching it all played out. Thanks to HBO/BBC for giving this a shot, inaccuracies and all. I was really expecting Atia to have a great death earlier on (a few episodes back, close to when she actually died) but I have to admit I enjoy seeing that character onscreen enough to forgive any problem there.
I'm sure that the economic reasons why this series didn't continue is probably killing any chance of another series set in Roman times, but I'd be onboard the second one was proposed. I'm a big fan of Lindsey Davis' Marcus Didius Falco detective series and think something like that could be done for TV, ala THE THIN MAN movie series from the 30s only in Roman times.
There's just got to be some economic compromise between this expensive HBO/BBC version Rome and the old "I, Claudius" one.
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 2:51PM
Eric J. said...
I wish the finale had been 20 minutes or so longer, or that we had had more episodes. I think that the political changes going on got lost amidst the personal drama, and that last season they did a better job balancing the two.
There wasn't a sense that we were seeing the dividing line between the Republic and the Empire.
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 3:35PM
Veronica said...
This was one of the best series to watch these past two seasons even with all the channels I subscribe to. Avidly watched all episodes including the repeats during the week. Am sorry to not have any further seasons of ROME. HBO/BBC - THANKS SO MUCH. IT WAS THE BEST!!
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 5:28PM
David said...
Rome ended? Damn, does HBO have any TV shows left now?
Now Showtime can take over with it's Henry the 8th show! Long live the king!
Reply
3-26-2007 @ 5:38PM
wes said...
Haven't watched the finale yet, but I will. I mean, I kind of knew what was gonna happen from History class. Anyways, Rome was excellent and dirty, and raw and surprisingly reminiscent of modern society, probably on purpose by the writing staff, but you can't argue w/the actual recorded history they decided to leave in. I will miss Octavia the most.
-W
Reply
3-27-2007 @ 1:01AM
MIke said...
Great show sad to see it leave, but I've gotten to the point now where if any show gets canceled, I can't get upset. I'm through fighting with the damn execs. Quality shows rarely last in today's society.
Reply
3-27-2007 @ 1:18AM
Adrian said...
"The series kind of painted Octavian as this robotic, methodical, and cruel figure illustrated best by his parading the bodies of Antony and Cleopatra through the streets of Rome and his lust for killing Caesarian. Be that as it may, from what I understand of history, Gaius Octavian actually goes on to lead Rome to several years of prosperity during his rule."
If it is of any interest, Octavian of history wanted to rid of his cruel harsh image. Thus his change in address to Augustus Caesar, 1st emperor of the Roman Empire.
Reply
3-27-2007 @ 11:06AM
Rogphi said...
This was a great Show, Im sad That its Over But if anyone wants to folow the characters( Not Pullo Because he was made up) you can watch I claudius. The sets are a bit BBC cheesy but the acting is still superb!! well worth watching!
Reply
3-27-2007 @ 8:15PM
Rogphi said...
This Series was brilliant and Im sad to see it End. You can always follow BBCs I claudius to see what happened to the Characters( Pullo was Made up so Not so Much with finding out about him) Its a little dated but the acting is superb!
Reply
3-28-2007 @ 10:06AM
nan4ROME said...
Why is everyone here so blah about HBO cancelling Rome? Romans unite!Stop HBO's tributes!Let THEM go w/o grain!Follow me across the Rubicon, and let's make the barbarians bring Rome back!
Reply