TVSquad

Is it really "popularity" that's keeping him around or is it this movement to vote for the worst? Even Howard Stern jumped on the vote for the worst bandwagon now because apparently there's just nobody that great this season.

Reply

If Simon thinks he's so terrible, then why did he put him through in the first place? Isn't that the point of the tryouts and Hollywood, to weed out the people who would embarrass Simon to the point of leaving the show if they were to win?

Reply

Vote for the Worst has had no hand in keeping Sanjaya on the show so far since this is the first week they're throwing their support his way. Until now, they were backing Sundance and only switched to Sanjaya when Sundance was voted out.

Reply

Oh Simon, I think that Sanjaya will be LONG GONE before that! He'll be eliminated right away if the viewers can attest to last night's terrible performance. He's not anywhere near the other singers. But that's what some of the viewers like--a continuation of the bad auditions from January's shows to be seeped into the top 12. They feel that if former auditioner William Hung did well with his off key singing outside of Idol, so will Sanjaya. They don't like to see 12 very good singers in one setting. He's a good looking young man, but his singing needs serious work afterwards if he's removed. I'm sure he's not paying attention to the outrage and criticism he's gotten the past few weeks. His removal will avoid some embarrassment for the show.

Reply

I wonder if Simon Cowell means it? What a great way to get him off the show...

Reply

hmmm - I might just vote for this guy ... if it will get AI off the damn airwaves - and stop jerking House around.

Reply

It does beg the question, why did you have him in the top 24?

And on the AOL poll last night he was 4th to win it all, now he is 6th. People sicken me.

Reply

They seem like a pretty mediocre lot this season, but if all it takes to get rid of Simple Simon is a vote for Sanjaya,I'll vote for him. It's probably an empty promise anyway. I mean what's he gonna do, go back to living in his mommy's basement?

Reply

As far as I can see (hear) the only one worthy of winning is Melinda Dolittle with Lakita(I think I have spelled that correctly) a very close second. Not one guy is worth listening to.

Reply

I think Sanjaya doing the hula was the first time I almost vomited watching a TV show. He can't keep time, esp. in a fast song and he holds his notes too long. He screams "I am woman, hear me whispter".

Reply

Personally I like Simon. Most of these people(contestants) need a wake up call and he does that. Were he to leave the show wouldn't be worth watching.

Reply

And while we're at it, did anyone think it strange that Simon and Ryan went to Africa together? That's a lot of time in the air and in the same tent. I hope they had quality time together, they have to pretend to be distant and straight when they're on national TV

Reply

Sanjaya is flat out awful. There was at least a dozen singers that would of been better in the top 24. I don't get why anyone votes for him. He's one of the worst ever.

Reply

SIMON IS THE SHOW BECAUSE HE LETS THEM KNOW WHO NEED'S TO IMPROVE AND WHERE AND I PERSONALY WANT THE TRUTH EVEN IF IT HURTS. SANJAY HONEY YOU HAVE NO SOUL AND YOU CAN'T SING NO HARM MENT BUT PLEASE GO HOME AND PUT US OUT OF ARE MISERY.# 12 YOU CAN WIN IF YOU KEEP SINGING LIKE YOU DID LAST NIGHT. BRING YOUR GAME MORE EVERY WEEK THANKS

Reply

FANJAYAS!! HAHAHA I need a shirt! I am a Fanilow! What does it feel like to be a Fanjaya? I'm gonna try that!

Reply

Sanjaya is not moving forward because of his popularity. He's moving forward because of his race. Plain and simple. He's annoying, physically repulsive, and not talented. His race is keeping him alive, much like Hawaiians voted en masse for Jasmine Tryas.

But the person above who said that Simon is at fault is damn right. The judges put this jerk in the final 12 in the first place. He should never have come that far. He is simply not good enough.

Reply

Has no one but me noticed Sanjaya's physical/personal resemblance to Michael Jackson? The thin body, the shyness, but certainly not the voice? I too believe his race is keeping him going. Surely every Indian with a cell phone is voting numerous times for him because no American in their right mind would waste a call on his weak performance. Stay with us, Simon, we need your stark, sometimes crude reality. Pobody's nerfect!

Reply

I agree with Simon, I will quit watching Idol if Sanjaya wins. He needs to go and should have been gone a long time ago. When sundance left last week I was shocked as he should have been at least in the top 6. Simon is good, sometimes a little harsh but usually very accurate. He judges as if it is a singing contest not personality.

Reply

Please vote for her to WIN, so he quits and this show ends!!! This would be the best for TV!

Reply

Hm. You mean Idol will end if I vote for Sanjaya? I may just vote for him after all...

Reply