I really wanted to like this show, but I couldn't even make it through the first episode. Although, to be honest, the only thing that made me want to check it out was knowing that Penn Jillette was hosting it. I've been a fan of Jillette's for years, both solo and as one-half of Penn and Teller, but watching Identity was like listening to paint dry -- not watching paint dry, listening to it dry, which is much more boring.
Since networks don't make decisions based on my personal preferences, Identity will be returning to NBC Fridays in March. The first new episode will air at 9:00 p.m. on March 16, and will then slide into its regular timeslot beginning March 23 at 8:00 p.m.
Okay readers, should I have given the show more of a chance? Is it actually better than I thought it was? I'll admit I might not have been in the right mood when I watched it. Perhaps I had just been shot down by a girl at the bar, or maybe I ate some bad ham. If you think it deserves a second look, here's your chance to convince me.
The TV Squad Podcast: Vik Sahay of Chuck, Oprah talk, brutal timeslots, and more!
TV Squad Ten: Top Ten ESPN shows from worst to first
Andy Richter: The TV Squad Interview
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-16-2007 @ 11:16AM
Jon88 said...
Let's not put this show to sleep until after they've paid my way to the Left Coast to stand on their stage and be identified, shall we? (Dare I risk breaching security and revealing my identity? Let's just say that you might be one of the million or so people who saw me playing the piano in a documentary released last year.)
Reply
2-16-2007 @ 11:32AM
Elf said...
Idenity has the same problem that 1 vs. 100 does, namely that the hosts can hardly be themselves. You know the jokes that Bob Saget makes on 1 vs 100 are probably the third or fourth ones that come to his mind, after editing out the really dirty ones. And Penn looks like he wants to scream "You idiot!" at a contestant each time they make a mistake. I'm a huge fan of both Saget and Jillette and I think both shows would be so much more entertaining if they could both just be themselves and let it rip.
By the way, has anyone noticed that the hosts of all of the NBC prime-time game shows were in "The Aristocrats"? If NBC starts another game show, which is a distinct possibility considering the chances of an upcoming writers' strike, who would be next? I'm thinking George Carlin...
Reply
2-16-2007 @ 11:37AM
David said...
The show is completely pointless like all other game shows in prime time today.
And why doesn't NBC just start showing it at 8pm to begin with? Show it at 9pm for a week then move it?
Reply
2-16-2007 @ 1:09PM
John said...
I thought it was a fun show to watch with someone and a tivo. With someone (my wife) because it fun to guess out loud and hear what they are guessing. With a Tivo so you can pause on the list of Identities instead of trying to remember them all. (plus all the other advantages Tivo has, ff past commercials etc.)
Reply
2-16-2007 @ 4:08PM
Tom Brady said...
I'm with you on this one, Adam. We turned it off after about ten minutes of trying to get through the first show. There's very little interesting gameplay involved, and while Jillette can be a very entertaining guy, here he's reduced to a stock-phrase chattering block of wood.
A tangential rant: It seems that ever since "Millionaire" it has been decreed that prime-time game shows require a catchphrase, something repeated over and over, to help with marketing. I realize that this isn't a new phenomenon ("Come on down!", "Survey says...", etc.), it's just that the sheer obviousness and banality of the intended catchphrases is so grating.
OK, I feel better now :)
Reply
2-19-2007 @ 10:32AM
Preston said...
I think it was smart that they took the show off for a few months since NBC doesn't want Identity to steal Deal or No Deal's thunder. There would be too much one-upmanship among Penn Jillette and Howie Mandel and badmouthing each other in the press. That said, I thought that Identity was quite good in its initial run. There's a good chance that somebody could win the entire thing. It does require a lot of thinking in this show. Though I would avoid the having of friends/family members on the side (it makes it blatantly look like Deal). I was surprised with what their identities were--they had these anonymous personalities to them.
Reply