(S06E02)We're in Seattle for episode two, and it is raining cats and dogs. That doesn't stop nine thousand hopefuls from standing outside all day to wait their turn to shine. By now, most of us have already heard that the Seattle contestants were the worst ever in Idol history. But it doesn't seem that bad on my end. Maybe I'm easily amused. Or maybe I'm just happy that Paula is awake and coherent tonight. Randy also seems in a better mood. And Simon is barely rude to contestants who clearly need to have their delusions shattered.
APOLLO CREED #2: Brandon Groves (26) is first up in Seattle and he's our SECOND Apollo Creed of the season. He appropriately sings "God Bless America." It turns out Brandon is a repeat audition offender. Last year, he sang "I Shot the Sheriff" in his police uniform. Simon takes one look at him entering the room and complains, "It's going to be a long day." As he exits, Paula wonders aloud if next time he'll come dressed as an Indian Chief. And we get verification that Paula does indeed possess the ability to speak.
FINAL VERDICT: NO
THE HOTNESS: Jennifer Chapton (23) come with her own moniker, "The Hotness." She compares herself to Mariah Carey (don't they all?). Paula has to remind her to remove her gum before singing (wow Paula spoke again). The Hotness is scary looking with freaky-looking plump lips. Simon says: "You were all over the place. It was a terrible audition." She tells Simon he doesn't know anything about music. Paula loves her feisty attitude. Randy thinks she's awful too.
FINAL VERDICT: NOT HOT
THE STAY AT HOME MOM: Amy Salgado (23) shares how her non-supportive husband told her she's wasting her time trying out for Idol. I want to call that man and give him a piece of my mind, until she sings and I realize he may have been trying to spare her this humiliating experience. She blames a cold for her poor performance. Simon says: "I think you have worse than a cold." She gets a drink of water and tries again, and she's still bad. Simon insults her again, and Paula punches him. And we get verification that Ms. Abdul is indeed awake and back to being playful-punching Paula.
FINAL VERDICT: HUBBY WAS RIGHT. TIME TO GO HOME.
THE BLONDE BOMBSHELL: Darwin Mischa Reedy (27) has frizzy fried-bleached blond hair, bright red lipstick, and large saggy boobs, desperately in need of a bra. She tells the judges that she wrote a novella about a singing competition. The freak flag is definitely flying on this one. So it's appropriate that she sings the lines "Dontcha wish your girlfriend was a freak like me?" She brings in her mom and it becomes apparent where she got her looks and her freak flag.
FINAL VERDICT: BUH-BYE BOMBSHELL
THE COCKY KID: Thomas Daniels (21) appears to be cocky, too cocky. I instantly want him to fail miserably. He's back for his third audition with Idol, hoping that the "third time will be the charm." He sings "Arms of a Woman" and I have to admit that he's good. The judges like him, especially Randy who tells him several times that he likes his fro.
FINAL VERDICT: HE'S GOING TO HOLLYWOOD!
My prediction: He could be a Final 12 Contender.
Outside the audition room Paula holds a Chihuahua and jokes, "If Simon and I ever have a baby, this is what it will look like." Wow, Paula's on a roll. First talking, and now joking. Way to go.
THE GOOFY GIRL: Melissa Stavros (22) is a larger woman dressed in a wacky outfit with "pink" legs and arms. Simon looks confused when she enters the room. Randy gets her to sing, "I Like Big Butts." Then she sings a Christina Aguilera song, and it isn't as bad as I expect it to be. Still, they quickly dismiss her. I hate how they treat the girls who aren't thin, blond, and cute. If she looked like last night's flirty-Shakira-girl, Simon definitely would have smiled, and asked her to stick around and try another song.
FINAL VERDICT: SORRY
THE BEATBOXER: Blake Lewis (25) calls himself a "beatboxer." I have no idea what that is, but he gives us a sample, and I learn something new from watching TV. Then he sings Seal's "Crazy." Simon Says: "You're good, you're just very over-the-top." Randy tells him that his beatboxing is better than his singing. Paula loves him because Paula seems to LOVE everyone tonight.
Paula: I'm going to go on the record, I love you, I think you're really talented.
Simon: I think you're easily pleased, Paula
Simon says nay, but Randy and Paula put him through to Hollywood.
FINAL VERDICT: SEE YOU IN L.A.
THE BROTHER AND SISTER: These two are adorable. Their dad was a classical Indian musician.
Shyamali Malakar (19) sings "Summertime" and no surprise, Paula loves her. Simon doesn't think she's anything special. But Randy's vote is enough to get her a golden ticket. It's 8:55 PM and we finally have a girl going to Hollywood.
FINAL VERDICT: YEAH, BABY
Sanjaya Malakar (17) has a terrific smile and pleasant attitude. He sings Stevie Wonder, and Paula does her weird applauding thing. Simon tells Sanjaya that his sister has the stage presence, but he has the voice.
FINAL VERDICT: COLLECT YOUR GOLDEN TICKET
THE SUPERGEEK: Nicholas Zitzmann (27) is a software engineer from Utah (and he is sporting big Osmond-sized teeth). He brags that he's a self-taught musician. His co-workers encouraged him to try out for Idol, and I have to believe that they were totally goofing on him. He butchers one of Simon's favorite tunes, "Unchained Melody." Simon says, "It was almost non-human."
FINAL VERDICT: DUDE, DON'T QUIT YOUR DAY JOB
THE LAST CONTESTANT OF DAY ONE: Rudolpho Cardenas (28) is originally from Venezuela, but now lives in L.A. He sings Journey's "Open Arms" and I immediately have flashbacks to the 1980s. I think he rocks, but Simon says no. Paula is feeling the love once again, and Randy agrees to send him to Hollywood.
FINAL VERDICT: SEE YOU BACK IN L.A.
At the end of Day One, only seven contestants make it through to Hollywood. Then they work in Daniel Powter's "Bad Day" because American Idol knows how to beat a dead horse.
On Day Two the sun comes out, but the Seattle contestants are not happy that Simon told the press they were the "the worst bunch of miserable contestants EVER."
Today we meet two special friends, who met during the Idol auditions and have become each other's biggest supporters. They are Kenneth "Bush Baby" Briggs and Jonathan "Augustus Gloop" Jayne.
BUSH BABY: Kenneth Briggs (23) is skinny and has large, bulging eyes. He says that he's been compared to Justin Timberlake. He sings "Tearing Up My Heart" by N'Sync and Randy and Paula lose it. Paula actually turns her chair away from him to laugh. Simon says: You look a little odd, your dancing is terrible, the singing was horrendous, and you look like one of those creatures that lives in the jungle with those massive eyes. What are they called? Bush Baby." It's a little mean to tell the guy he looks like a monkey. But at least Paula thinks he is adorable.
FINAL VERDICT: SORRY, BABY
AUGUSTUS GLOOP: Jonathan Jayne (20) is chubby and kind of resembles Augustus Gloop from Willie Wonka so I stick him with that unfortunate moniker. He also wears a very loud Hawaiian shirt and sings "God Bless America." His friend, Kenneth, listens outside the door with Ryan Seacrest and thinks that Jonathan, "sounds real good." Paula says: "You have a great personality, I don't think this competition is right for you." Simon is actually nice in his rejection. Outside the room, Jonathan claims, "They would make a ton of money if I got on that show."
FINAL VERDICT: NO GOLDEN TICKET FOR AUGUSTUS GLOOP
TAYLOR HICKS-ALIKE: Eric Chapman (28?) is a hairdresser with salt-and-pepper hair and a strong resemblance to last year's Idol, Taylor Hicks. He even tries to imitate Taylor's moves, but is more spazzy, if that's possible. He sings "Drift Away" and I wish that I could drift away. Simon asks: "Is this serious? Are you drunk?"
FINAL VERDICT: HAIR TODAY, GONE TOMORROW
SECURITY ALERT! Things get exciting for a minute when Taylor Hicks-Alike takes out some hair product and tries to fix Simon's hair and is quickly escorted out the door by several security guards who pop out of the wall from nowhere.
THE AMAZON: Anna Kearns (20) is 6'4" without heels, literally towering over the Seacrest, which means she could crush all 5 feet of me. She was kicked out of the Air Force because of a weak heart. I think this sounds like the beginning of an inspirational back-story. Hey, what's the deal? Seattle doesn't get ANY inspirational back-stories? She sings "Respect" by Aretha Franklin and Simon calls her loud. Randy and Paula like her so much that they growl when Simon tries to critique her, causing Simon to throw a hissy fit, refusing to speak. Paula and Randy both say yes, and Anna gets a golden ticket. Simon says: "You just put through a giraffe," which is a little unnecessary and rude.
FINAL VERDICT: GOOD THINGS COME IN TALL PACKAGES
THE NATURAL: Jordin Sparks (16) looks like a normal teen. And she has a great smile. She sings Celine Dion's "Because You Loved Me." Paula, of course, adores her. Randy is blown away, calls her "A Natural." Simon says "It was a little bit too sugary for my taste." Jordin reveals that her father is Philippe Sparks, an ex-NFL player. Paula stands up and pumps her arms strangely. Is she cheering? Dancing? Convulsing? Paula says: "I'll make a prediction...you'll do really well." I agree, predicting another possible Final 12 Contender.
FINAL VERDICT: WELCOME TO HOLLYWOOD
At the end of Day Two, only seven more contestants advance to Hollywood.
But before the episode is out, we get a look at one more, very special contestant. Ryan Seacrest calls this contestant "the most definitive reason to leave Seattle and never return."
BIG RED: Steven Thoen (27) is called "Red" because of his bright red hair and beard. Right off the bat he admits he's not a big fan of the show, and has only seen a couple of episodes. He murders Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody" and seems to be oblivious to his lack of talent. The judges chuckle. He's pretty damn bad. After completing his song, he states, "I can also do Country, as well." Simon says: "I've heard weird auditions in my life, but I've got to tell you that is possibly the weirdest..."
FINAL VERDICT: NO WAY, RED
Seacrest is out. Next week's episode will take us to Memphis, Tennessee.
And I have to thank my 10-year-old daughter, Olivia, for snapping the digital photo included with this post.












Reader Comments (Page 1 of 12)
1-18-2007 @ 1:34AM
Ted said...
The producers of these early shows spend so much time looking for losers and freaks that I wonder if there are some decent singers who get lost in the shuffle and never even get to audition in front of Randy, Simon and Paula. Maybe some of them would turn out to be surprisingly good, and the program wouldn't end up with a half-mediocre top 12 the way it usually does.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 1:56AM
Andrew said...
Paula was slurring her words and clearly has parkinson's.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 2:02AM
Melissa said...
What is with all the clips of people trying to open the wrong door, and then showing the judges say "other door" ???
I really, really liked the brother and sister team. He showed a lot of character by not saying that the judges liked his voice better. I hope they make it at least to the top 24.
I have to say that I didn't really like Jordin Sparks. I agreed with Simon that it was just so over the top. I think she lacks a bit of the "likability factor" as well, but maybe it's just me.
About the looks thing... on one hand, it's sad when they make fun of the way someone looks, but it's also an integral part of being the "American Idol." I'm not saying you have to be hot, but you should look put together, and like you have a sense of self-awareness. That chick with the pink fishnet bodysuit thing was so over the top, it wouldn't have looked right even if she weighed 125 lbs. She was all over the place.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 8:03AM
terri said...
what a show! It was nice to see Paula was her old self again! Can't wait for next week!
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 8:10AM
Carmen said...
After the first night, half way through we put it on record since there was so little action compaired to so very, very, many commercials. We will record from now on and pass up all the commercials and too much information on the performers and just watch the auditions and what the judges decide. Enough is enough, we know that the commercials pay for the shows but way too many!
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 8:45AM
Sherry said...
I enjoyed American Idol the first few years but it has gotten like a freak show. I watched Tuesday night and even some of the singers that were chosen to go on I was in real doubt of. I think that sometimes the judges just think they have to pick someone. Personally I don't know why friends and family members aren't honest with some of the people that think they can sing and tell them the truth (you suck!!!) The first young lady on Tuesday that sat down on the floor and cried because she thought she was great was horrible and the guy that was so foul mouthed. These people are only making fools of themselves. There is no way I could sit there and listen to all of that garbage and keep my composure. 90% of the time I agree with Simon and his tactics, be blunt and tell these people to get a life.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 8:48AM
RLM said...
Being in the entertainment biz most all of my life, and having been on American Idol year before last, it still amazes me that some people can actually think that they are great performers. I guess thru friends and family, they are lead to believe that they can do anything. Pretty incredible I think, at the same time, actually sad...
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 8:48AM
Lili Cunningham said...
I think that the show has sunk to an unfortunate level. Why humiliate people like that? It is heartless and painful, and certainly NOT funny. Maybe a 10sec clip showing many of the misses, but to place most of their main focus not on talent but on much toooo long clips of people who are obviously limited in their ability to see their reality compared to what the show is looking for...but who by the way, must be surrounded by people who love them and are doing a good job of making them feel pretty good about who they are.... is rediculous. I say shame on the producers, and the 3 judges, who don't deserve to be named.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 8:58AM
wed1984 said...
The first two shows they seem to be downright insutling people not on their singing but on their looks.
I wasn't embarrassed watching the people sing I was more mad at the comments about looks.
Going to commercial Ryan said the "hit in the face with a shovel Taylor Hicks lookalike".
What was that?!?!
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:00AM
Jeff Denton said...
Don't forget, the BEST RECAPS EVER are found at author Linda Sharp's blog - hysterical and instantly addictive!!! Her take on Seattle is spot-on!
Bookmark her site - it's like getting a Christmas present the day after each show!
http://dontgetmestarted-lindasharp.typepad.com/
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:03AM
Misty said...
"He sings "Drift Away" and I wish that I could drift away."
It was more along the lines of yelling than singing.
*shudder*
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:11AM
Malik said...
I know wuz going on with Paula...She is feeling bad for these poor AI hopefuls! This year they just seem to be meaner than ever (Randy & Simon).
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:12AM
Robin Jacobson said...
Simon is just being honest, not mean!! This is not a high school talent contest, SHEESH!! And most of the ones that do just sing, are TONE DEAF!! They really believe they sound good, cause they totally TONE DEAF!!
And a few of em are TONE DEAF and BLIND, or have never looked in a mirror, I mean, we're looking for an American Idol!!! again, i say, SHEESH
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:14AM
Jeanne said...
I think AI needs to rethink it's show format. Why waste the public's time with such "Jerry Springer" type trash? Why not just stay true to finding the next AI by showing ONLY the contestants from each of the various auditions that are possibles? I TRULY feel sorry for the misfits they are exploiting!! I will NOT watch AI's "let's make fun of people" segments again. I'll wait until the REAL AI competition begins.
If I want to laugh I'll watch some of the great comedy sitcoms that are available on TV. I hope others will do the same.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:16AM
sandy evans said...
Its just so hard to imagine that some of these contestants are REALLY seriously thinking they have talent! Do they not tape themselves and listen!? WHY NOT??? Are there that many tone deaf people? I guess having ones "15 minutes" is desirable...NO MATTER WHAT!
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:18AM
Peg said...
Kenneth Briggs can't sing but he certainly did not deserve the insulting remarks about looking like a monkey. Come on Simon. This was uncalled for.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:19AM
Maggie said...
It's amazing to me that so many people are unable to see the way they look to others. Some of those poor people were really upset when they were rejected and it's unfortunate that it got so far. Someone somewhere down the line could have told them gently and compassionately that they had no talent. That lady with the red net thing on her arms and legs HAD to have some sort of family or friend who could have told her just how bad she looked and sounded BEFORE she humiliated herself in front of millions of people like that.
How awful for the contestants, how awful for their families...how awful for US!
Having said that...it was entertaining as hell wasn't it?
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:20AM
John Shooter said...
My interest in this show has eroded. Same old same old!
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:21AM
Dee said...
I am a devoted American Idol fan...but after all the initial auditions. After the first half hour, the bad auditions get old real fast. Let me see the talented ones!!! I really don't care about all the ones that cannot sing. I agree with a former poster who said the focus has become more on the bad ones and how many potentially good contestants were passed over for entertainment purposes?? Like the one man who had auditioned three times and finally was moved on....was he sacrificed to have William Hung or the woman from last year who strutted around and then used so many expletives when she was rejected that all you heard from her was the bleeping from editing. Come on American Idol! Let's shorten this up and get to the heart of the competition which is what we all really want to see.
Reply
1-18-2007 @ 9:24AM
Gavin said...
I am forced to watch this show with my wife and after having seen the last 2 shows I commented to my wife that I believe that many of these "freaks" who audition for the show are staged. A good is example is the first night with the guy juggling sticks. The "tip off" is when he leaves the audition and is crying about how he was told that he was the epitome of Seattle. If you paid attention to the background you can clearly see one of his "family members/friends" (heavy set woman) bowing her head and laughing. Kind of odd don't you think? People cannot be this stupid to go voluntarily on a show like this. You are all being duped.
Reply