If ever a subject of this PBS documentary showcase series lived up to the title "Independent Lens," it's eighteen year old Shadya Zoabi. Shadya is a Muslim Arab living in Israel, a beautiful, athletic and headstrong girl who loves karate and who has very little interest in following the typical Muslim path of becoming a servant and housekeeper. Throughout the film, Shadya's feminist views clash with those of her older brothers, the eldest of which insists Shadya must give up karate and behave in a manner more fitting to Muslim customs and laws. Shadya, meanwhile, flaunts her independence at every turn. She even gives up praying because she says she hasn't got the time.
The film makes clear, however, that Shadya could not be the free spirit she is without her father, who supports Shadya in every decision she makes. Her older brother abhors this, but their father insists times have changed, and that it's time for everyone -- Jews, Christians and Muslims -- to get along.
I always enjoy the documentaries featured on Independent Lens, but this one really stuck with me. It helps that Shadya is a lovely young girl who lights up every room she's in, but it's also both uplifting and heartbreaking to watch someone struggle to be themselves in a world that demands they be someone completely different.
Shadya airs January 16 at 10pm on PBS.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-16-2007 @ 11:46PM
Rohit said...
A cherubic happy kid who at the start of the movie impishly said she'll go to "jahannum" since she stopped praying, seemingly just enters one as she moved out of her parents place where she had full support from her father to her in-laws place with traditional values and defined roles for men and women. She seemed too young to realize the drastic change in life which is apparent when wishes to win the competition near the end of the movie but loses since she has not practiced - it is an attempt to keep the bridge open with the free life - the zeal to live a free life is what keeps us going. Shadya needs to sustain it one way or another - she is every one of us.
Reply
1-17-2007 @ 7:07PM
Anne said...
Saw this documentary last night and was very impressed with the open, progressive thinking of Shadya's father. It's unfortunate that his mind set does not extend to the general population of the region. I felt very sad that so many young women, in the name of their religion, are oppressed and made subserviant to men. Shadya was a confidant, interesting, outspoken young person at the beginning of the film, and at the end, she practically cowered to the whims of her rather brutish husband. I also felt the sadness of her father when a Jewish shop owner refused to serve him a cup of coffee. Peace seems so, so far away.
Reply