(S03E19) And it all comes down to this. If we flash back to the beginning of the season, I don't think anyone would really be surprised to see Mario in the finals. He and Karina came out of the gates as the favorite, and never let up. Emmitt on the other hand, I think that would have surprised a lot of people. Maybe it was because of Jerry Rice's performance, but I didn't give Emmitt near enough credit going into the competition. He's worked his way into the top two, and now has a legitimate chance at winning.Round one is a new feature with both couples dancing to the same song. It's an interesting idea. Something that would get tedious if they did it with any regularity, but as a one shot deal in the finals, I like it.
Emmitt & Cheryl (samba) Great dress for Cheryl. Horrible shirt and shoes for Emmitt. It was a bit of a slow start, but once they got into the dance it picked up nicely. Cheryl was right when she talked about Emmitt's footwork in the pre-dance package. He moves with an easiness you don't expect. Really nice performance overall. Emmitt's personality shined through. The judges dig it. Len says it didn't disappoint in any way. Bruno says Emmitt is blessed. Carrie also thought the start was slow, but said they blew her away. The scores, 10 - 10 - 10. And that right there told me that the judges had already checked out.
Mario & Karina (samba) Mario wins round one in the wardrobe competition. I don't know what is up with Karina and the wigs though. This was a great performance. Clearly a step above Emmitt & Cheryl with the difficulty. I don't think Mario can match Emmitt's charisma and personality, but he definitely out danced him here. The judges all really liked it. Len does comment on a misstep on the running promenades, but other than that, all positive comments. The scores, 10 - 9 - 10.
For the second round each couple was able to pick their favorite performance from the season and do it again.
Emmitt & Cheryl (mambo) An interesting choice since that wasn't the dance that earned them the perfect score. Still a good choice though. This was a great performance the first time, and again this time. I liked it better than their samba from round one. Aside from the fact that Emmitt lost the hideous green shirt, it also had more technical moves. The judges were impressed again. Bruno said it looks like Emmitt has been doing this all his life. Carrie agreed. And Len pointed out that Cheryl should win the M.V.P. for most valuable partner. The scores, 10 - 10 - 10.
Mario & Karina (pasa doble) They also chose to do a dance that didn't garner a perfect score. And it worked for them as well. This was every bit as good as, if not better than, the first time they did it. What Mario lacks in charisma and likability, he makes up for with dramatics. This dance is a show. Another round goes to Mario & Karina. The judges love it. Len said it was great. Bruno compared Mario to a star over the sun baked Spanish plains. Carrie said Mario's lines were beyond perfection. The scores, 10 - 10 - 10.
Now, if at this point in the show you were thinking that round three would bring Emmitt & Cheryl a 29 and Mario & Karina a 30... well, you are just as cynical as I am. Round three was the fabled freestyle performance.
Emmitt & Cheryl (freestyle) Ok, did you ever think you would see Emmitt Smith doing M.C. Hammer? Not only that, but doing a pretty good job of doing M.C. Hammer. That was an impressive performance. I thought they struggled a little bit getting in and out of one of those lifts, but they were impressive nonetheless. The judges like it too. Carrie was impressed. Len called Emmitt his dancing hero. Bruno said it was the hammer, the chisel, and the shovel. The scores, 10 - 10 - 9. Hmmmmmmm.
Mario & Karina (freestyle) Their freestyle was good, but oddly, this was the one round of the night where I thought they were outperformed. Mario referred to it as a kitchen sink performance, and I think that was apt, though not in a good way. It was like parts and pieces of different dances tossed together, but not really a cohesive routine. And their lifts, while good, didn't match Emmitt & Cheryl's. But since the judges had to score this a 30 anyway, they loved it. Bruno called it a hit parade. Carrie said it was the best dance of the season. Len thought that if the dance was a film, it would win an Oscar. The scores, 10 - 10 - 10. Surprise!
As was expected, it all comes down to the fan vote. Either team could win it. While I gave Mario & Karina the dance victory tonight, two rounds to one, I'm picking Emmitt & Cheryl to win the championship tomorrow night. Being a Superbowl champion trumps being A.C. Slater when you put it all to the fan vote.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-15-2006 @ 9:38AM
theattack said...
not just that, Mario is such a pompous loser. He is AC Slater for gods sake, thats it. Emmit Smith is among the top running backs of all time. And Emmit so so gracious to the fans, the judges, and is generally likeable. I'm rooting for Mario to lose as much as for Emmit to win.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 9:42AM
Jake said...
Mario is the best dancer and I'm sick of all the bashing -- especially given that it is so unfounded. There is still time to vote for Mario at abc.com until noon today!
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 9:53AM
Erosia said...
I think people forget that the judges are irrelevant in this round anyway. The fan vote decides the final round no matter what when there are only two people left. Emmitt and Cheryl could have gotten all 1's and as long as they get more votes they'll still win. When the judges tie the couples it just becomes more obvious that the fan vote is the determiner to people who don't know the scoring rules.
I also want to mention that I live in Indianapolis and the reception went out at the beginning of the show! It was horrible. They had some sort of technical problems and I thought it was my TV reception, but my aunt with cable called and had the same problems. They fixed it by the fourth dance, but it was completely aggravating.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 10:48AM
anon3803 said...
"Mario is the best dancer and I'm sick of all the bashing"
The same could've been said about Stacy last year. The best *dancer* doesn't always win.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 10:19AM
MrsEldubya said...
I am with you, as soon as I saw the first marks I figured the judges would be tied in the end. Chickens! I didn't particularly like Mario's freestyle. I agree he had more difficult moves in his first two performances but the freestyle didn't flow. He's a good dancer but I'm for Emmitt all the way. It's the total package and Emmitt is the man.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 11:02AM
Maribel said...
I'm also so sick of everyone saying how Mario isn't as famous as Emmitt. So what. When it comes down to it, Mario's the better dancer. Sure Emmitt is very likable, but it's not a personality competition, it's a dance competition. Let the best dancer get the trophy for his talents, not his fame. Do right by the person who has the most talent in dancing and vote for Mario.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 11:30AM
bnr said...
Everyone always says that Mario is the better dancer, but he had more ability going in to the competition from the beginning - and never has really grown from there. Emmett has grown from a football player to the better dancer, in my opinion. There's just something about Mario's dancing for me that seems more cheesy than talented.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 12:41PM
Chris said...
On the popularity vote, don't count out the fame of Mario. I know Emmit played some great football, but a lot of people are not pro football fans. Mario on the other hand was on one of the most popular shows ever for people who are now around the age of 25 (plus or minus a few years). Most of the people I know grew up watching every single episode of Saved By the Bell.
My pick - Emmit for most improved, versatility (each of his dances look different), and charisma.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 6:07PM
TomB said...
The judges vote was a tie - again. No surprise there. I have no idea who will win. It could go either way. I think Mario is better technically, but Emmit has the personality.
Reply
11-15-2006 @ 4:55PM
Erika said...
What is with Emmitt and those stupid arm bands? You have muscles. We get it. Try some sleeves next time.
Reply
11-16-2006 @ 1:43AM
Jenny said...
What is with Emmitt having the personality -- Mario has got the movie star looks and personality and I know am his biggest fan thanks to dwts. If he makes the right choices, he could be the next big movie star! So HOT
Reply
11-21-2006 @ 11:05AM
Tania said...
SIGN THE PETITION!!
http://www.petitionspot.com/petitions/marioshouldvewon
Reply