(S06E22) After all the criticism that's been heaped on the Palladinos lately, from their departure from Gilmore Girls to the depressing storylines they've written this season, it's time for me to give them some praise. First of all, despite everything, I'm going to miss them; Amy Sherman-Palladino's voice is unique in the TV universe and GG is not going to be the same without her or her husband Daniel. So I want to thank them for giving me and a loyal fan base an entertaining, funny, and charming show for six years.As far this episode, one that essentially explodes the world of GG as we know it, is concerned, I will give AS-P praise for this: Lorelai's look.
I mean, we all knew what was going to happen. Between the spoiler/interview from Mike Ausiello and the far-too-revealing WB promos, the basic structure of the episode was well-known to anyone who had eyes and/or ears. Logan reluctantly leaves Rory to go to England, who lets him go. And, most importantly, Lorelai gives Luke an ultimatum: Elope or I'm gone. Lunkheaded Luke says it's not time, Lor leaves, and takes solace with good ol' Christopher. And, as most people know, the episode -- and, it turns out the reign of Team Palladino -- ends with Lorelai waking up naked in Christopher's bed.
But Lorelai had that look.
The look that said "What the hell did I just do?" The look that said "I just threw away the best relationship I've ever had to sleep with the guy who has given me nothing but trouble." The look that might just redeem the next, and possibly final, season of Gilmore Girls.
As much as I've been complaining this season about GG not having as much of the quirky cutsey scenes of Stars Hollow-ness that we're used to seeing, this episode is the one that I think really shouldn't have had any cutsey town stuff at all. Don't get me wrong; Troubador Invasion '06 was funny and creative. I especially liked the fact that not only did we have Grant Lee Phillips as the original singer that got a chance to tour with Neil Young ("He was in the Monkees," Kirk tells Taylor) then come back after he got booed off the stage, but we also got Yo La Tengo, Thurston Moore and Kim Gordon of Sonic Youth (along with their daughter Coco), and 24's Mary Lynn Rajskub. And the songs they were all singing were very funny. It just didn't fit in with the overall tone of the episode, which of course, we all knew wasn't going to be a happy one.
Neither did the scenes where Lorelai sits and watches while her parents clumsily try to set Christopher up with a psychologist (played by Melora Hardin, who plays Jan on The Office). In this case, it's weird that Lor is distraught over what she thinks is the ending of her relationship, but she can still be jokey and torture her parents and act loopy to help Christopher out. Again, it showed Lor turning the off emotions that have seemed to overcome her -- the brillant opening showing Lor's look as Sookie and Jackson try to leave without waking her up shows this -- in order to be Wacky Lorelai again. While I know that this is one of Lorelai's specialties, for some reason it just doesn't seem to work for me here.
But it does show how in tune Lor and Chris have always been with each other, as the bathroom scene where they cook up their plan to get him out of the date demonstrated. Also, it set up nicely Lor's automobile session with Chris' "date", where she is told that she should just ask for what she wants (duh) and if it doesn't work out, maybe it wasn't meant to be. It was good to see Lor let loose and just go over why she loved Luke so much and why she asked him to marry her. It was also good to see why she's so ready to get married and can't wait for Luke anymore. Huh. Makes you wonder why Lorelai didn't get therapy sooner.
The confrontation with Luke was great in that Lor finally says what she should have been saying since April came to town, telling Luke how quiet she had to be and how much she hated it. It was raw and emotional, which is something she hadn't been with Luke for months, if ever. But Luke, a person who's cared so much for Lor over the years (she tells the therapist as much in the car) just stands there and blinks, saying "give me time to think," not realizing he was about to lose the love of his life. Luke was not supposed to be this clueless, and I don't understand why AS-P wrote him this way all year. But I guess that was a good way to send Lor back to Chris, even if it is inconsistent with how the previous five-and-a-half years of the show transpired.
The Rory/Logan plot had its moments: I liked Rory's elevator confrontation with Mitchum, where she finally finds out that Logan's being sent away for his own good, to get away from the Life and Death Brigade idiots. The Brit-themed party she threw for Logan was cool, especially her bad accent. And, in some of the best acting I've ever seen Alexis Bledel do, her crying as Logan leaves for the airport the next morning showed that Rory knew she had to let him go, even if she didn't want him to leave.
But what I'll take away from this season is that look. Lorelai knew she made a mistake. And the Palladinos have left the world of GG in tatters. I'm really, really hoping that Dave Rosenthal is able to pick up the pieces next year.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
5-09-2006 @ 11:33PM
Tammy said...
Great write up on the episode, you are absolutely right. I thought this episode had some very great moments and I really liked how Rory got it when Mitchum explained why he had to go to London. I know she has school and everything but they are RICH, she's getting a building named after her (you did leave that wonderful part out!), so she can fly over to see him pretty much whenever she wants to. Mitchum might even let her come with him because he knows she has Logan's best interest at heart. If not Emily and Richard would send her, Emily might time share that plane she wanted so badly before. It's not forever even though I guess at their age it does feel like that.
I have been watching the first season again on ABC Family and it's just amazing the changes in everyone actually. Boy has Alexis grown up on us. It's been a while since I watched the first season and it's a delight. It will help ease the time until the next season starts.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 12:27AM
Maria said...
I agree that Luke has been behaving against type all season. I'm very frustrated and disappointed that the Palladinos have left the show in such a lurch. I remember reading that Amy had already written the last scene of the show in her mind. To have her leave the show that she has fashioned with such a unique voice is unthinkable. She is my favorite screenwriter of all time. I really fear for what will happen to this show next season. Will the humor and dialogue be the Gilmore world I have come to adore?
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 12:29AM
Meredith said...
I knew Lorlei would go crawling back to Cristopher. My mom and I watch intently as this unfolded. I can already guess on what it will bring next season. Lorelei being pregnant by Cristopher and her and Luke will never happen....I can see it now.
As for Rory and Logan. I didnt like the chap at first, but this last episode really made me feel like he wouldn't be so bad for her after all. After getting rid of Jess, its really been hard for me to welcome the idea of any guy in Rory's life, especially Dean.
As for all the folk singing and music playing in the town... I had mixed feelings. It was creative, but it was way out of the blue and didn't seem to tie into the story line at all.
I love Gilmore Girls...but there's always a question in the back of my mind going, " how is this going to end". I'm afriad that it will be another open-ended series like 7th Heaven if it keeps going for too much longer without any real resolution or satisfaction of hope for Lorelei and Rory's love lives.
-Meredith
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 1:28AM
Ryan said...
I was also quite surprised at Alexis' acting job in that it was believable and good. It's not often this happens. When she was crying him goodbye, I felt it. Bravo!
And um... if Chris and Lorelai did sleep together doesn't that mean that Chris just too advantage of a confused and hurt Lorelai? And yes, I noticed that look, too. Not sure how Luke will react to it, but it will be Luke/Lorelai in the end. Or at least it's not going to be Lorelai/Chris...
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 8:12AM
Donna said...
I agree with the look of Lorelai. it says so much that it can fill a complete scene. I always felt there was such a feeling for Chris all along that it would always interfere with Luke, and he blew it right there in the middle of the street, like men do,not knowing it is the one moment in their lives they have to get it right. Loralei was correct in having them work Amy into their lives, not the opposite.
I thought the troubador scene was, while hilarious, downright annoying. Rory was excellent in her ability to watch Logan walk away. the look on her face of wanting to beg him to stay, but not letting it out was so clear. I loved it and I can't wait for next season, even though The Palladinos leaving may see it change dramatically. As above mentioned , i am enjoying seeing all the old episodes. I tape them on DVR to watch at night. it's amazing how young Alexis Bleidel was and a so young looking Jared Padalecki. I never watched at first, ny daughter got me into it, so what fun.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 9:49AM
Darlene said...
I think your critique of the season's finale is 100% accurate. I enjoyed the busload of troubadors but felt it didn't ring true to the episode.
I am hoping that the series doesn't end as so many seem to end, with a conclusion that just doesn't fit the characters that we have all come to love (and in some cases, not love.)
I think Lauren Graham is a good actress and hope that after GG we will see more of her in films.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 10:07AM
Kerri said...
I am so angry with the Palladinos for doing this. Even though this episode was shot well before their contract dispute finally ended with them not being renewed, I still can't believe they would have Lorelai behave so out of character. It is in character for her to run to Chris, but not to sleep with him. Even if the Palladinos were going to be with the show next year, how the heck were they going to make this show watchable with Luke & Lorelai destroyed? I understand that they didn't want L&L to become all schmoopy, but there is a difference between that and the complete alienation they wrote between the two all season and now this.
And if you should be complimenting anyone for Lorelai's look at the end, it's Lauren Graham, not the Palladinos.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 10:48AM
Tammy said...
I have a question... why did the tivo say 62 mins when they didn't run over the hour at all. My tivo taped the beginning of Pepper Dennis. Was this just a cute ploy to try and get us to watch that show? They should want everyone to watch Veronica Mars instead since both GG and VM are on CW next season.
Anyway, as for sleeping with Christopher out of character... not so sure about that. Loralei has done plenty of relationship destroying things in the past and feeling like the love of her life is gone forever, yup you do stupid things like sleep with your ex. You want to feel love when the person you love rejects you. It's a hope that you were wrong and this should prove it but it doesn't and then you get that "look".
As for the troubadours being out of place, don't you remember the silly bike race last year in the middle of Loralei proposing to Luke? AS-P loves to have something totally Stars Hallow-ish in the middle of depressing drama. It use to be one of their monthly festivals that was always happening around the drama.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 10:56AM
Laurie said...
I waited with baited breath to see this last episode and, all in all, it was not a disappointment. Rory was fantastic in that last scene and the look on her face when she knew that Mitchem was right about sending Logan away, was priceless. It was her AHA moment! Maybe Logan's parents will start to accept her next season because Mitchem knows now that Rory really cares about what is best for Logan.
I was so hoping, even though I knew it would happen, that Lorelai wouldn't sleep with Christopher. It's too bad that Chris would take advantage of her vulnerability. Shame on him. Did you see that big smile on his face at the end as he got back in bed with her and put his arm around her? He looked like the rat who had swallowed the mouse. He could be in for a rude awakening next season.
The character of Luke has been a mess this year. Lorelai was 100% correct when she said that she and Luke should be trying to fit April into their relationship, not April and Luke trying to fit Lorelai into theirs. Luke made a critical error in judgement with all this. I was shocked that he let her walk away like that.
It also occurred to me that Lorelai would probably be pregnant at the beginning of next season. Then she would really go through hell - especially with her parents. We'll see how that pans out.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 10:57AM
Samuel McConnell said...
Good job, AS-P, for completely sabotaging your show.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 11:02AM
Galen Perkins said...
I think we are all missing a very vital point.... Does anyone see the situation at the end of the finale as being Emily's attempt to reunite Lorelai and Chris? My theory she asked the Psychologist Lenny to come to the house to make Lorelai envious as well as psychoanalyze Lorelai into venting her feelings and to force an ultimatum with Luke. Then noble, beloved Christopher would be there to pick up the shattered pieces while Emily vacations in Europe for two months. I hope this show will absolve itself in the next season, and not continue its downward spiral into yet another crappy, unending WB show.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 11:42AM
Lee Morrow said...
Well, I've not been watching for awhile and with this horrible stuff, I'm now out altogether. Even if they reconcile L/L, ASP spoiled everything that relationship was to me by having that end scene.
I'm convinced Lorelai's ultimatum was ASP's fictional substitute for her negotiations which were: we want two year contract or nothing. Nothing they got; nothing we got. All crap.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 11:54AM
Dana said...
I don't know why everyone is bemoaning the Palladino's departure and wondering if it will be the same beloved Gilmore Girls next year. It wasn't the same Gilmore Girls this year. The Palladino's basically flipped the bird to long-time fans of this show by turning Luke into a character no one likes, and I don't particularly want to see Lorelai get back with him now after the way he's treated her. They also turned Lorelai into a shrinking violet, something she's never been before. And they've decided to reduce Lorelai's and Rory's relationship to phone calls, even though this is supposed to be a show about a mother and daughter. It was also a show that used to have more light-hearted moments with touches of conflict. Now, it's just depressing. I say good riddens to the Palladinos.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 12:17PM
Mike said...
I'm just wondering what is going to happen with Luke next season. He's certainly not going to just be okay with this. So is he going to fight to win Lorelai back? Will he have to, or is Lorelai going to come running back to him? Is he going to be disgusted and disappointed that she ran to Christopher? Is Taylor's worst nightmare of a Stars Hollow divided into Luke and Lorelai camps going to come true?
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 12:23PM
Ash said...
I thought this episode was a kick in the guts to the fans. After a wonderful run and a downbeat season, A S-P and DP should have gone out with a celebration, instead this was the most depressing episode ever. And they managed what I never thought could happen - I don't think I like Lorelei anymore.
If Lorelei ends up with Christopher, that would mean Emily wins out, and that would be unforgiveable. And would turn the whole of the series into an opera where the heroines fate is inevitble and happiness is not obtainable.
I agree with Dana that even the Rory/Lorelei interaction is missing. There really is not much hope left in Stars Hollow and no reason to watch the show anymore.
The Palladinos had a good show, but its like they intentionally sabotaged it for the fans. I agree - good riddence
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 12:57PM
Bob said...
I hope the new writers will write-off the whole year like a dream sequence (Ala Dallas) and start over. The only good thing about this year was Rory's bangs
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 1:09PM
Robin said...
Great review and I think I agreed with every single point you made. Is it really the end of GG? It will ruin the entire 6 years of the show to end it for good this way. I must do some research...thanks for wrapping all up so well...now I don't feel I need to on my blog.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 1:45PM
daverrr said...
Sabotag? AS-P has just given us 29 and under a taste of how it raely is, SH is fake but her story telling has truth in it, part of that truth is pepole are the ones who mess everthing up.
Thank you AS-P for not ending GG with "and they lived happly ever..."
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 2:16PM
Lee Morrow said...
I for one do not dislike Luke or any other character - I don't, however, care for ASP and her rather twisted concept about what she thinks is interesting, believable or in anyway whatsoever enjoyable. The show was written so lousy all season that I didn't buy her pathetic attempts to turn Luke or any other character into someone I didn't like because they all started acting like other people - too absurd for words. I think ASP bought all that hooey about her being brilliant, etc and, unfortunately, fans paid the price by being given drek that ASP tried passing off as entertainment.
Reply
5-10-2006 @ 3:11PM
Joey said...
My DVR do not record the last minute of last nights show. It cut off showing Lorelei alone in bed. Would someone tell me exactly what happened next. Thanks
Reply