When I reviewed last week's episode, I
made a few remarks that the writers for this show weren't really doing much to expand the backstories for the main
characters. They didn't hear me, because this week was the same deal. I want more than just a case. Give me
something on Mac's wife who died in the 9/11 attacks. Give me something on Lindsay's background (we found out she
likes opera... that's it). Give me anything on Stella or Danny. I'll say this much. I'm not the only one who must feel
this way because out of all the shows I cover for TV Squad, this one receives the fewest comments and last week's
didn't get any.
Back to the review... there were two cases. Surprise! A dead college student is found on the subway tracks and a commodities broker hung himself out his window. Let's solve some crime.
Case numero uno. Mac, Lindsay, and Danny investigate the college student found on the tracks. He was beat over the head with a piece of wood and Danny rules out the fraternity paddle owned by the roommate and the axe handle owned by the bouncer of the club they were at. There was also a sharks tooth embedded in the kid's hand. Odd... but not that odd when Adam (one of the new lab techs) determines that the tooth only belonged to one of a certain number of sharks caught on the east coast. And fishing records can be obtained. So guess who caught it? The subway conductor. He had a shark tooth missing from his keychain because the student grabbed at it when the conductor pushed him out of the train. The schmuck had been drunk and causing a good ol' ruckus. And the wood splinters? They matched the paddle used by the conductor to wedge on the brake when the train was parked.
Case number two is a bit easier to explain. After examining the body, Sid is certain the guy was murdered. His name was Q.T. Jammer... I'd pay money for that name. He was one of the biggest brokers in the city and his assistant wanted in. Securities and Exchange Commission rules state that his underbroker would get his client list should he die. So his assistant drugged him, strangled him, and made it look like the guy hung himself. Easy case for Stella and Doc Hawkes.
That was it and don't get me wrong - I enjoy the cases. But am I alone in this feeling? What can be done to make this as good as the other two CSI's?















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-28-2006 @ 3:20PM
Tim said...
I watch it every week and I feel the exact same way. Give me more than solving a crime - any show can do that (and many do). What makes people love a show is being able to feel for the characters. I don't CARE about these characters...especially compared to CSI: Miami which I think does the best job of bringing a personal side to their characters.
I only watched the first 2 episodes of season one, but wasn't fond of it at all - and they changed it up at the beginning of season 2 to make it 'less gritty' and that helped but they can't be done tweaking on this series or else i'll be forced to give up on it again.
Reply
1-28-2006 @ 3:50PM
Jonathan Toomey said...
Right on point Tim. I agree with that 100%
Reply
1-30-2006 @ 9:27AM
Mike said...
Curious about a song from this episode. If anyone could identify it, please?
Scene: Inside Wild, Wild, Wet (the bar)when Mack is questioning the bartender/doorman about the victim's actions in the bar and seizes the axe handle. The song playing in the background.
Lyrics: ....like it just won't quit, you claim the shakes but they just won't sit, i know you love me, you don't know what you like, ??? you stay out all night......
Thank you in advance.
Reply
1-30-2006 @ 2:19PM
Todd said...
I really have mixed feelings on this show - I love Stella (or at least the actress who plays her, Melina K) and I like the new chick Lindsay. But even Gary Sinise seems to feel bored by this show. The only thing worse is CSI Miami. I want more backstories like the real CSI has and I want characters that make me want to like them!
Reply
1-30-2006 @ 4:59PM
Lee said...
We are still waiting for the new series to show in the UK. I LOVED series one... Please dont say that series 2 does not live up to it
Reply