Monday night, TNT premiered The Closer, starring Kyra Sedgwick. Sedgwick plays Deputy Police Chief Brenda Johnson, who is brought into the LAPD from Atlanta, surpassing the rank of all the existing homicide officers to take over a new group on the force, the Priority Murder Squad. When I first caught advertisements for this show, I was thinking "oh boy, another cop show starring someone relatively famous, what will they ever think of next." While I won't say I was wrong about that first judgement, I can definitely see why you would watch this show again.I was a little disappointed that the "trick" behind the first case, as it's either clear that I watch too much crime-TV or it was just plain as day who the criminal was. The fact that OJ was mentioned only six minutes into the show during a murder-related discussion was kind of funny, and the random mix of cop characters who will be working for Brenda Johnson appear to be somewhat entertaining, especially Detective Lt. Provenza, played by G.W. Bailey. Provenza gets called out for calling women "bitches," and notes that he is "proud of it" when he's called an "asshole." So we know who the comic relief will come from every time we tune in.
Sedgwick's character has personal connections to a few people who are introduced to us, including the police chief Will Pope (J.K. Simmons, you might remember him as Jameson from the Spider-Man flicks), whom she was either romantically involved with or had just worked with in a previous life. And, her "friend" from the FBI who happens to show up at her hotel in Los Angeles with part of the evidence needed to solve the case - but you don't learn everything that might have gone on in their history, and that's about the only hook you'll find with regard to the future. Otherwise, it's a "show up when the body hits the floor and we'll figure it out in 45 minutes or less." Oh, and it's cable so we have gratuitous nipples-through-the-shirt shots and a fascination with eating sweets.
Is it enough to keep us enthralled for the next 13 weeks? Probably - Monday nights in the summertime are a decent time to be on television and expect people to be sitting on the couch - but it wasn't anything to write home about. Set the DVR and go with it.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
6-15-2005 @ 11:55AM
e said...
The only thing that really annoyed me about the show was Sedgwick's accent. Ewww. If they want a Southern character, they should hire a Southern actor, not make New York-born Sedgwick (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001718/) attempt a very bad accent. I'm hoping the accent will slowly fade away . . . Otherwise, the show was decent.
Reply
6-15-2005 @ 11:55AM
Belgand said...
Indeed, the accent was terrible. This along with the character's disturbing resemblance to the horrifying Julia Roberts was enough to give it an instant thumbs-down on my TiVo. The cookie-cutter plot, Perry Mason-esque concept of making someone give themself up, and obvious plot were all enough to thorougly damn the show. The fact that it doesn't even try to break any new or interesting ground and that most of the conflict comes from ludicrous internal opposition (I just can't buy police verterans acting like petulant children and even if I could I'm not going to tolerate watching it).
So in the end we have a boringly formulaic cop show with a poor lead, uninteresting supporting cast that often tries to make me dislike them and no real reasons to bother watching it again. In other words: no coffee for this closer.
Reply
6-15-2005 @ 11:55AM
Chris said...
Horrifying Julia Roberts? Dude, you are way out there on your own with that one. :)
As for "yet another formula cop show", that's fine with me. We've got legal dramas, cop dramas, doctor dramas, sitcoms and reality shows. Most sitcoms fail at their job of being ridiculously funny, most reality shows make me gag. Cop, lawyer and doctor dramas at the least give me something to think about or a character to be interested in.
I'd love for there to be "different" shows. There just aren't. Or at the least, there aren't that many. Six feet Under? That went from being entertaining to being "who can be the most neurotic character?" Carnivale? That was good and different and engrossing but apparently no one liked it or watched it. Dead like me? Dude, next season it's nothing but ghost shows. And now Dead Like Me is long dead and that was a fantastic show.
Want something new and exciting? Write it yourself, get your friends to star, and cut it in iMovie. Otherwise be glad this isn't the 80's when summer meant heat and re-runs.
Reply